search

AileneKane / bayes4cons

0 stars 0 forks source link

Question: How to include case studies #16

Open lizzieinvancouver opened 2 months ago

lizzieinvancouver commented 2 months ago

     -Option A: include short descriptions, equations and figures in the main text, with code as an appendix/supplemental file      -Option B: include only short description/summary in the main text and include all equations/additional details as separate vignettes       -Option C: some other idea that you may have?

lizzieinvancouver commented 2 months ago

I would vote for either option A for ONE case study (and mention the other, but put in a supp) or option B ... but I could be swayed to option A for all case studies if we really want to frame the ms as us walking through examples so more people will do it. If we do that (frame the ms as us walking through examples), I think we could cut some of the text not related to case study concepts.

hneyster commented 2 months ago

I like the idea of the ms walking through examples so that people really understand. Maybe we start with (A) for both, and then we could always move one of the examples elsewhere if we think it's too example heavy?

AileneKane commented 2 months ago

Deirdre votes for Option B (via email)

AileneKane commented 1 week ago

Seems like most support for Option B, so let's do this one- only short references to case studies in the main text, and include full details as supplmental files. Next step is for everyone to modify their case study for inclusion as a supplemental file with details that refer to/better align the new version of the main text.