jyzhkj commented 1 year ago

描述一下这个bug / Describe the bug

air001
选择外部晶振，外部晶振是24M时，下载程序后，不起振。不管是PLL倍频。

实测发现：

RCC_OscInitStruct.HSEFreq = RCC_HSE_16_32MHz;
这一句有问题。改为RCC_HSE_8_16MHz 能跑，当然频率是不对的。

复现步骤 / To Reproduce

在菜单中选择
HSE 24Mhz, HCLK 24Mhz 或 HSE 24Mhz, HCLK 48Mhz

如果正常，应该是什么样 / Expected behavior

x

截图 / Screenshots

x

日志 / Logs

x

系统 / System

win10

PACK包版本 / Version

0.4.1

验证

[X] 检查过该问题，之前没有人提过 / Check that there isn't already an issue that reports the same bug to avoid creating a duplicate.
[X] 提供了最小可复现工程或详细的复现步骤，确保开发者可以复现 / The provided reproduction is a minimal reproducible example of the bug.
[X] 已经提供了完整的报错信息、日志、截图，没有经过删减。

jyzhkj commented 1 year ago

为什么关闭问题？是我搞错了？你没有复现吗？

chenxuuu commented 1 year ago

空那么多项目我还以为是捣乱的

---原始邮件--- 发件人: @.> 发送时间: 2023年8月15日(周二) 上午10:46 收件人: @.>; 抄送: @.>;"State @.>; 主题: Re: [Air-duino/Arduino-AirMCU] 使用外部24M晶振有问题 (Issue #48)

为什么关闭问题？是我搞错了？你没有复现吗？

— Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub, or unsubscribe. You are receiving this because you modified the open/close state.Message ID: @.***>

HalfSweet commented 1 year ago

RCC_HSE_8_16MHz和RCC_HSE_16_32MHz仅会影响晶振的驱动能力，如果方便的话，是否可以提供一下您的原理图和pcb布线，以及晶体的手册？

根据我的实测，24M的晶体是可以正常工作的

jyzhkj commented 1 year ago

相同硬件，用keil一切正常。用arduino编译下载就起动不起来。原理图跟002开发板相同。 22222

HalfSweet commented 1 year ago

使用HSE24M PCLK24M和HSE24M PCLK24M都无法进行启动吗？您使用的是哪一种型号的晶振呢

jyzhkj commented 1 year ago

HSE 24Mhz, HCLK 24Mhz HSE 24Mhz, HCLK 48Mhz 32Mhz 未测这3个选项都不行。晶振就是普通的49S,24M 333

注意同一块板在keil中很正常 跟踪到 variants\air001\air001_dev中的generic_clock.c文件 SystemClock_Config()函数的内容，对比keil基本一致

另外写了个小函数在arduino启动完之后再setup中调用： `void APP_SystemClockConfig3(void) { RCC_OscInitTypeDef RCC_OscInitStruct = {0}; RCC_ClkInitTypeDef RCC_ClkInitStruct = {0}; / 振荡器配置 / RCC_OscInitStruct.OscillatorType |= RCC_OSCILLATORTYPE_HSE; / 选择RCC振荡器为HSE / RCC_OscInitStruct.HSIState = RCC_HSI_OFF; / RCC_OscInitStruct.HSIDiv = RCC_HSI_DIV4; / / 4分频 / // RCC_OscInitStruct.HSICalibrationValue = RCC_HSICALIBRATION_24MHz; / 配置HSI输出时钟为8MHz / RCC_OscInitStruct.HSEState = RCC_HSE_ON; / 开启HSE / // RCC_OscInitStruct.HSEFreq = RCC_HSE_8_16MHz; / HSE晶振工作频率8M~16M / RCC_OscInitStruct.HSEFreq = RCC_HSE_16_32MHz; / HSE晶振工作频率16M~32M / RCC_OscInitStruct.PLL.PLLState = RCC_PLL_OFF; / 关闭PLL / RCC_OscInitStruct.PLL.PLLSource = RCC_PLLSOURCE_NONE; / 不选择PLL源 / / 配置振荡器 / if (HAL_RCC_OscConfig(&RCC_OscInitStruct) != HAL_OK) { Error_Handler(); }

/ 时钟源配置 / RCC_ClkInitStruct.ClockType = RCC_CLOCKTYPE_HCLK | RCC_CLOCKTYPE_SYSCLK | RCC_CLOCKTYPE_PCLK1; / 选择配置时钟 HCLK,SYSCLK,PCLK1 / RCC_ClkInitStruct.SYSCLKSource = RCC_SYSCLKSOURCE_HSE; / 选择HSE作为系统时钟 / RCC_ClkInitStruct.AHBCLKDivider = RCC_SYSCLK_DIV1; / AHB时钟 1分频 / RCC_ClkInitStruct.APB1CLKDivider = RCC_HCLK_DIV1; / APB时钟 1分频 / / 配置时钟源 / if (HAL_RCC_ClockConfig(&RCC_ClkInitStruct, FLASH_LATENCY_0) != HAL_OK) { Error_Handler(); } }`

发现只要是设成"RCC_HSE_16_32MHz" ,就会死。所以是不是驱动底层的问题？

HalfSweet commented 1 year ago

尝试注释掉所有关于HSI的配置，看看是否可以正常工作

jyzhkj commented 1 year ago

没作用，还是死. 相同代码在keil中正常：

`void APP_SystemClockConfig3(void) { RCC_OscInitTypeDef RCC_OscInitStruct = {0}; RCC_ClkInitTypeDef RCC_ClkInitStruct = {0}; / 振荡器配置 / RCC_OscInitStruct.OscillatorType = RCC_OSCILLATORTYPE_HSE; / 选择RCC振荡器为HSE / RCC_OscInitStruct.HSEState = RCC_HSE_ON; / 开启HSE / RCC_OscInitStruct.HSEFreq = RCC_HSE_16_32MHz; / HSE晶振工作频率16M~32M / RCC_OscInitStruct.PLL.PLLState = RCC_PLL_OFF; / 关闭PLL / RCC_OscInitStruct.PLL.PLLSource = RCC_PLLSOURCE_NONE; / 不选择PLL源 / / 配置振荡器 / if (HAL_RCC_OscConfig(&RCC_OscInitStruct) != HAL_OK) { Error_Handler(); }

/ 时钟源配置 / RCC_ClkInitStruct.ClockType = RCC_CLOCKTYPE_HCLK | RCC_CLOCKTYPE_SYSCLK | RCC_CLOCKTYPE_PCLK1; / 选择配置时钟 HCLK,SYSCLK,PCLK1 / RCC_ClkInitStruct.SYSCLKSource = RCC_SYSCLKSOURCE_HSE; / 选择HSE作为系统时钟 / RCC_ClkInitStruct.AHBCLKDivider = RCC_SYSCLK_DIV1; / AHB时钟 1分频 / RCC_ClkInitStruct.APB1CLKDivider = RCC_HCLK_DIV1; / APB时钟 1分频 / / 配置时钟源 / if (HAL_RCC_ClockConfig(&RCC_ClkInitStruct, FLASH_LATENCY_1) != HAL_OK) { Error_Handler(); } }`

jyzhkj commented 1 year ago

如果 RCC_OscInitStruct.HSEFreq = RCC_HSE_16_32MHz;

HAL_RCC_OscConfig 函数返回值就 =3 timeout

chenxuuu commented 1 year ago

最简单的办法，邮寄寄一套测试硬件给开发者

jyzhkj commented 1 year ago

直接来个boards.txt中的配置吧：解决的问题： 1:外部晶振问题，其实是 generic_clock.c中 #undef 不起作用引起的。选择外部晶振后，程序中打印一下HSE_VALUE就明白了，全是8M 2:增加JLINK支持 3：mcu flash/ram 可选

menu.cpu=Processor

###############################

Py32All Dev

###############################

Py32All.name=Py32all

Py32All.menu.cpu.64k=64k/8k Py32All.menu.cpu.64k.upload.maximum_size=65536 Py32All.menu.cpu.64k.upload.maximum_data_size=8192

Py32All.menu.cpu.32k=32k/4k Py32All.menu.cpu.32k.upload.maximum_size=32768 Py32All.menu.cpu.32k.upload.maximum_data_size=4096

Py32All.menu.upload_method.AirMethod=AirISP Py32All.menu.upload_method.AirMethod.upload.tool=AirISP

Py32All.menu.upload_method.jLinkMethod=JLINK Py32All.menu.upload_method.jLinkMethod.upload.protocol=jlink Py32All.menu.upload_method.jLinkMethod.upload.tool=jlink_upload Py32All.menu.upload_method.jLinkMethod.build.upload_flags=-DCONFIG_MAPLE_MINI_NO_DISABLE_DEBUG Py32All.menu.upload_method.jLinkMethod.upload.device=CORTEX-M0+

Py32All.build.core=AirMCU Py32All.build.board=AIR001_DEV Py32All.build.mcu=cortex-m0plus Py32All.build.series=AIR001xx Py32All.build.cmsis_lib_gcc=arm_cortexM0l_math Py32All.build.product_line=AIR001 Py32All.build.variant=AIR001/AIR001_DEV Py32All.build.air_extra_flags=-D{build.product_line} {build.enable_usb} {build.xSerial} Py32All.build.drivers_include="-I{build.system.path}/Arduino-Air001-Drivers/{build.series}_HAL_Driver/Inc" "-I{build.system.path}/Arduino-Air001-Drivers/{build.series}_HAL_Driver/Src" "-I{build.system.path}/{build.series}" "-I{build.system.path}/Arduino-Air001-Drivers/CMSIS/Device/{build.series}/Include/" "-I{build.system.path}/Arduino-Air001-Drivers/CMSIS/Device/{build.series}/Source/gcc/"

Py32All.menu.UploadSpeed.115200=115200 Py32All.menu.UploadSpeed.115200.upload.speed=115200 Py32All.menu.UploadSpeed.57600=57600 Py32All.menu.UploadSpeed.57600.upload.speed=57600 Py32All.menu.UploadSpeed.38400=38400 Py32All.menu.UploadSpeed.38400.upload.speed=38400 Py32All.menu.UploadSpeed.19200=19200 Py32All.menu.UploadSpeed.19200.upload.speed=19200 Py32All.menu.UploadSpeed.9600=9600 Py32All.menu.UploadSpeed.9600.upload.speed=9600 Py32All.menu.UploadSpeed.4800=4800 Py32All.menu.UploadSpeed.4800.upload.speed=4800 Py32All.menu.UploadSpeed.2400=2400 Py32All.menu.UploadSpeed.2400.upload.speed=2400 Py32All.menu.UploadSpeed.1200=1200 Py32All.menu.UploadSpeed.1200.upload.speed=1200

HSI/HSE选择和主频

Py32All.menu.ClockSourceAndFrequency.HSI4M_HCLK4M=HSI 4Mhz, HCLK 4Mhz Py32All.menu.ClockSourceAndFrequency.HSI4M_HCLK4M.build.temp=-D{build.series}_HSI_4M_HCLK_4M Py32All.menu.ClockSourceAndFrequency.HSI4M_HCLK4M.build.f_cpu=4000000L Py32All.menu.ClockSourceAndFrequency.HSI4M_HCLK4M.build.HSI_VALUE=4000000L Py32All.menu.ClockSourceAndFrequency.HSI4M_HCLK4M.build.HSE_VALUE=4000000L

Py32All.menu.ClockSourceAndFrequency.HSI8M_HCLK8M=HSI 8Mhz, HCLK 8Mhz Py32All.menu.ClockSourceAndFrequency.HSI8M_HCLK8M.build.temp=-D{build.series}_HSI_8M_HCLK_8M Py32All.menu.ClockSourceAndFrequency.HSI8M_HCLK8M.build.f_cpu=8000000L Py32All.menu.ClockSourceAndFrequency.HSI4M_HCLK4M.build.HSI_VALUE=8000000L Py32All.menu.ClockSourceAndFrequency.HSI4M_HCLK4M.build.HSE_VALUE=8000000L

Py32All.menu.ClockSourceAndFrequency.HSI16M_HCLK16M=HSI 16Mhz, HCLK 16Mhz Py32All.menu.ClockSourceAndFrequency.HSI16M_HCLK16M.build.temp=-D{build.series}_HSI_16M_HCLK_16M Py32All.menu.ClockSourceAndFrequency.HSI16M_HCLK16M.build.f_cpu=16000000L Py32All.menu.ClockSourceAndFrequency.HSI16M_HCLK16M.build.HSI_VALUE=16000000L Py32All.menu.ClockSourceAndFrequency.HSI16M_HCLK16M.build.HSE_VALUE=16000000L

Py32All.menu.ClockSourceAndFrequency.HSI22_12M_HCLK22_12M=HSI 22.12Mhz, HCLK 22.12Mhz Py32All.menu.ClockSourceAndFrequency.HSI22_12M_HCLK22_12M.build.temp=-D{build.series}_HSI_22_12M_HCLK_22_12M Py32All.menu.ClockSourceAndFrequency.HSI22_12M_HCLK22_12M.build.f_cpu=22120000L Py32All.menu.ClockSourceAndFrequency.HSI22_12M_HCLK22_12M.build.HSI_VALUE=22120000L Py32All.menu.ClockSourceAndFrequency.HSI22_12M_HCLK22_12M.build.HSE_VALUE=22120000L

Py32All.menu.ClockSourceAndFrequency.HSI24M_HCLK24M=HSI 24Mhz, HCLK 24Mhz Py32All.menu.ClockSourceAndFrequency.HSI24M_HCLK24M.build.temp=-D{build.series}_HSI_24M_HCLK_24M Py32All.menu.ClockSourceAndFrequency.HSI24M_HCLK24M.build.f_cpu=24000000L Py32All.menu.ClockSourceAndFrequency.HSI24M_HCLK24M.build.HSI_VALUE=24000000L Py32All.menu.ClockSourceAndFrequency.HSI24M_HCLK24M.build.HSE_VALUE=24000000L

Py32All.menu.ClockSourceAndFrequency.HSI24M_HCLK48M=HSI 24Mhz, HCLK 48Mhz Py32All.menu.ClockSourceAndFrequency.HSI24M_HCLK48M.build.temp=-D{build.series}_HSI_24M_HCLK_48M Py32All.menu.ClockSourceAndFrequency.HSI24M_HCLK48M.build.f_cpu=48000000L Py32All.menu.ClockSourceAndFrequency.HSI24M_HCLK48M.build.HSI_VALUE=24000000L Py32All.menu.ClockSourceAndFrequency.HSI24M_HCLK48M.build.HSE_VALUE=24000000L

hse

Py32All.menu.ClockSourceAndFrequency.HSE8M_HCLK8M=HSE 8Mhz, HCLK 8Mhz Py32All.menu.ClockSourceAndFrequency.HSE8M_HCLK8M.build.temp=-D{build.series}_HSE_8M_HCLK_8M Py32All.menu.ClockSourceAndFrequency.HSE8M_HCLK8M.build.f_cpu=8000000L Py32All.menu.ClockSourceAndFrequency.HSE8M_HCLK8M.build.HSE_VALUE=8000000L Py32All.menu.ClockSourceAndFrequency.HSE8M_HCLK8M.build.HSI_VALUE=8000000L

Py32All.menu.ClockSourceAndFrequency.HSE16M_HCLK16M=HSE 16Mhz, HCLK 16Mhz Py32All.menu.ClockSourceAndFrequency.HSE16M_HCLK16M.build.temp=-D{build.series}_HSE_16M_HCLK_16M Py32All.menu.ClockSourceAndFrequency.HSE16M_HCLK16M.build.f_cpu=16000000L Py32All.menu.ClockSourceAndFrequency.HSE16M_HCLK16M.build.HSE_VALUE=16000000L Py32All.menu.ClockSourceAndFrequency.HSE16M_HCLK16M.build.HSI_VALUE=16000000L

Py32All.menu.ClockSourceAndFrequency.HSE24M_HCLK24M=HSE 24Mhz, HCLK 24Mhz Py32All.menu.ClockSourceAndFrequency.HSE24M_HCLK24M.build.temp=-D{build.series}_HSE_24M_HCLK_24M Py32All.menu.ClockSourceAndFrequency.HSE24M_HCLK24M.build.f_cpu=24000000L Py32All.menu.ClockSourceAndFrequency.HSE24M_HCLK24M.build.HSE_VALUE=24000000L Py32All.menu.ClockSourceAndFrequency.HSE24M_HCLK24M.build.HSI_VALUE=24000000L

Py32All.menu.ClockSourceAndFrequency.HSE24M_HCLK48M=HSE 24Mhz, HCLK 48Mhz Py32All.menu.ClockSourceAndFrequency.HSE24M_HCLK48M.build.temp=-D{build.series}_HSE_24M_HCLK_48M Py32All.menu.ClockSourceAndFrequency.HSE24M_HCLK48M.build.f_cpu=48000000L Py32All.menu.ClockSourceAndFrequency.HSE24M_HCLK48M.build.HSE_VALUE=24000000L Py32All.menu.ClockSourceAndFrequency.HSE24M_HCLK48M.build.HSI_VALUE=24000000L

Py32All.menu.ClockSourceAndFrequency.HSE32M_HCLK32M=HSE 32Mhz, HCLK 32Mhz Py32All.menu.ClockSourceAndFrequency.HSE32M_HCLK32M.build.temp=-D{build.series}_HSE_32M_HCLK_32M Py32All.menu.ClockSourceAndFrequency.HSE32M_HCLK32M.build.f_cpu=32000000L Py32All.menu.ClockSourceAndFrequency.HSE32M_HCLK32M.build.HSE_VALUE=32000000L Py32All.menu.ClockSourceAndFrequency.HSE32M_HCLK32M.build.HSI_VALUE=32000000L

Py32All.menu.LowSpeedClockSource.None=None Py32All.menu.LowSpeedClockSource.None.build.lsc_temp=-D{build.series}_LSC_NONE

Py32All.menu.LowSpeedClockSource.LSI=LSI 32.768Khz Py32All.menu.LowSpeedClockSource.LSI.build.lsc_temp=-D{build.series}_LSC_LSI

Py32All.menu.LowSpeedClockSource.LSE=LSE 32.768Khz Py32All.menu.LowSpeedClockSource.LSE.build.lsc_temp=-D{build.series}_LSC_LSE

Py32All.menu.xserial.generic=Enabled (generic 'Serial') Py32All.menu.xserial.none=Enabled (no generic 'Serial') Py32All.menu.xserial.none.build.xSerial=-DHAL_UART_MODULE_ENABLED -DHWSERIAL_NONE Py32All.menu.xserial.disabled=Disabled (no Serial support) Py32All.menu.xserial.disabled.build.xSerial=

debug

Py32All.menu.dbg.none=None Py32All.menu.dbg.enable_sym=Symbols Enabled (-g) Py32All.menu.dbg.enable_sym.build.flags.debug=-g -DNDEBUG Py32All.menu.dbg.enable_log=Core logs Enabled Py32All.menu.dbg.enable_log.build.flags.debug= Py32All.menu.dbg.enable_all=Core Logs and Symbols Enabled (-g) Py32All.menu.dbg.enable_all.build.flags.debug=-g

optimize

Py32All.menu.opt.osstd=Smallest (-Os default) Py32All.menu.opt.oslto=Smallest (-Os) with LTO Py32All.menu.opt.oslto.build.flags.optimize=-Os -flto Py32All.menu.opt.o1std=Fast (-O1) Py32All.menu.opt.o1std.build.flags.optimize=-O1 Py32All.menu.opt.o1lto=Fast (-O1) with LTO Py32All.menu.opt.o1lto.build.flags.optimize=-O1 -flto Py32All.menu.opt.o2std=Faster (-O2) Py32All.menu.opt.o2std.build.flags.optimize=-O2 Py32All.menu.opt.o2lto=Faster (-O2) with LTO Py32All.menu.opt.o2lto.build.flags.optimize=-O2 -flto Py32All.menu.opt.o3std=Fastest (-O3) Py32All.menu.opt.o3std.build.flags.optimize=-O3 Py32All.menu.opt.o3lto=Fastest (-O3) with LTO Py32All.menu.opt.o3lto.build.flags.optimize=-O3 -flto Py32All.menu.opt.ogstd=Debug (-Og) Py32All.menu.opt.ogstd.build.flags.optimize=-Og Py32All.menu.opt.o0std=No Optimization (-O0) Py32All.menu.opt.o0std.build.flags.optimize=-O0

Py32All.menu.SupplyVoltage.3V3=3.3V Py32All.menu.SupplyVoltage.3V3.build.sv_tmp=-DVDD_3V3 Py32All.menu.SupplyVoltage.1V8=1.8V Py32All.menu.SupplyVoltage.3V3.build.sv_tmp=-DVDD_1V8 Py32All.menu.SupplyVoltage.2V5=2.5V Py32All.menu.SupplyVoltage.3V3.build.sv_tmp=-DVDD_2V5 Py32All.menu.SupplyVoltage.2V8=2.8V Py32All.menu.SupplyVoltage.3V3.build.sv_tmp=-DVDD_2V8 Py32All.menu.SupplyVoltage.3V8=3.8V Py32All.menu.SupplyVoltage.3V3.build.sv_tmp=-DVDD_3V8 Py32All.menu.SupplyVoltage.5V=5V Py32All.menu.SupplyVoltage.5V.build.sv_tmp=-DVDD_5V

boot

Py32All.menu.BootConnection.defaule=default isp circuit Py32All.menu.BootConnection.defaule.upload.boot=default_reset Py32All.menu.BootConnection.direct=direct connect Py32All.menu.BootConnection.direct.upload.boot=direct_connect

Py32All.build.extra_flags={build.temp} -DF_CPU={build.f_cpu} -DHSI_VALUE={build.HSI_VALUE} -DHSE_VALUE={build.HSE_VALUE} {build.lsc_temp} {build.sv_tmp} -DAIR001_DEV

Upload menu

HalfSweet commented 1 year ago

好的，问题已收到，我们会尽快解决

py32我个人后期会单独开一个仓库进行维护，此组织仅作为AirMCU的交流

Air-duino / Arduino-AirMCU

使用外部24M晶振有问题 #48

描述一下这个bug / Describe the bug

复现步骤 / To Reproduce

如果正常，应该是什么样 / Expected behavior

截图 / Screenshots

日志 / Logs

系统 / System

PACK包版本 / Version

验证

Py32All Dev

HSI/HSE选择和主频

hse

debug

optimize

boot

Upload menu