AkaneTan / Gramophone

A sane music player built with media3 and material design library that is following android's standard strictly.
GNU General Public License v3.0
1.01k stars 56 forks source link

[FR] Search UX issue #172

Open akrram0 opened 5 months ago

akrram0 commented 5 months ago

When you search for a music on gramophone it only plays the musics that upper with the search result Screenshot Screenshot_2024-05-01-11-18-02-24_7b63ba6ba855e67dd5ee1b08e9300b77 Screenshot_2024-05-01-11-19-41-14_7b63ba6ba855e67dd5ee1b08e9300b77

AkaneTan commented 5 months ago

Sorry but I'm confused, in your screenshot the second song is added to the playlist. Just hit next and the second song will be played.

nift4 commented 5 months ago

It's intended behaviour that only the search results are added to the queue. If you have a better idea, let us know.

akrram0 commented 5 months ago

It's intended behaviour that only the search results are added to the queue. If you have a better idea, let us know.

I have around 150 songs so I have trouble finding songs so I use search to find that one song but the problem is when you search a song it only plays what's upper in the search which is coincidently have same name but I want THAT one song and not the others but the problem comes when 1 only song upper in the search so it plays it and then stop instead in home page when you pick a song it choice other songs and keep playing so I hope you fix it and make it when you search a song it plays like normal like you click it in home page and everything work smoothly this would be much better Screenshot_2024-05-01-18-37-52-01_7b63ba6ba855e67dd5ee1b08e9300b77 Screenshot_2024-05-01-18-37-48-56_7b63ba6ba855e67dd5ee1b08e9300b77 Here i picked the same song from home page Screenshot_2024-05-01-18-28-04-19_7b63ba6ba855e67dd5ee1b08e9300b77

AkaneTan commented 5 months ago

It's intended behaviour that only the search results are added to the queue. If you have a better idea, let us know.

I have around 150 songs so I have trouble finding songs so I use search to find that one song but the problem is when you search a song it only plays what's upper in the search which is coincidently have same name but I want THAT one song and not the others but the problem comes when 1 only song upper in the search so it plays it and then stop instead in home screen when you pick a song it choice other songs and keep playing so I hope you fix it and make it when you search a song it plays like normal like you click it in home screen and everything work smoothly this would be much better Screenshot_2024-05-01-18-37-52-01_7b63ba6ba855e67dd5ee1b08e9300b77 Screenshot_2024-05-01-18-37-48-56_7b63ba6ba855e67dd5ee1b08e9300b77 Screenshot_2024-05-01-18-28-04-19_7b63ba6ba855e67dd5ee1b08e9300b77

Sorry but still it's an intended behavior and no changes will be made. If you want to find a specific song you can use all the sorting options we provide, not to mention you can use the side slider to reach to your favorite songs faster. I have no trouble finding my favorite track although I have 3000+ songs store locally that way 😉

akrram0 commented 5 months ago

It's intended behaviour that only the search results are added to the queue. If you have a better idea, let us know.

I have around 150 songs so I have trouble finding songs so I use search to find that one song but the problem is when you search a song it only plays what's upper in the search which is coincidently have same name but I want THAT one song and not the others but the problem comes when 1 only song upper in the search so it plays it and then stop instead in home screen when you pick a song it choice other songs and keep playing so I hope you fix it and make it when you search a song it plays like normal like you click it in home screen and everything work smoothly this would be much better Screenshot_2024-05-01-18-37-52-01_7b63ba6ba855e67dd5ee1b08e9300b77 Screenshot_2024-05-01-18-37-48-56_7b63ba6ba855e67dd5ee1b08e9300b77 Screenshot_2024-05-01-18-28-04-19_7b63ba6ba855e67dd5ee1b08e9300b77

Sorry but still it's an intended behavior and no changes will be made. If you want to find a specific song you can use all the sorting options we provide, not to mention you can use the side slider to reach to your favorite songs faster. I have no trouble finding my favorite track although I have 3000+ songs store locally that way 😉

What do you mean by all sorting options?

AkaneTan commented 5 months ago

It's intended behaviour that only the search results are added to the queue. If you have a better idea, let us know.

I have around 150 songs so I have trouble finding songs so I use search to find that one song but the problem is when you search a song it only plays what's upper in the search which is coincidently have same name but I want THAT one song and not the others but the problem comes when 1 only song upper in the search so it plays it and then stop instead in home screen when you pick a song it choice other songs and keep playing so I hope you fix it and make it when you search a song it plays like normal like you click it in home screen and everything work smoothly this would be much better Screenshot_2024-05-01-18-37-52-01_7b63ba6ba855e67dd5ee1b08e9300b77 Screenshot_2024-05-01-18-37-48-56_7b63ba6ba855e67dd5ee1b08e9300b77 Screenshot_2024-05-01-18-28-04-19_7b63ba6ba855e67dd5ee1b08e9300b77

Sorry but still it's an intended behavior and no changes will be made. If you want to find a specific song you can use all the sorting options we provide, not to mention you can use the side slider to reach to your favorite songs faster. I have no trouble finding my favorite track although I have 3000+ songs store locally that way 😉

What do you mean by all sorting options?

Screenshot_20240502-015706_Gramophone

nift4 commented 5 months ago

I'll think about how to properly solve this. It's not a bug, but your usecase certainly is valid I guess.