Youtube Laggy with Hardware Acceleration if Twitch Streams Open any browser.

Alex313031 / Thorium-Win

Chromium fork for Windows named after radioactive element No. 90; Windows builds of https://github.com/Alex313031/Thorium

https://thorium.rocks/

BSD 3-Clause "New" or "Revised" License

1.29k stars 33 forks source link

Youtube Laggy with Hardware Acceleration if Twitch Streams Open any browser. #103

Open thesunnymachine opened 8 months ago

thesunnymachine commented 8 months ago

System Details

OS: Windows 10
Version 117.0.5938.157 (Official Build) (64-bit)

Problem If I have ANY Browser open running twitch streams and I am watching youtube on Thorium, the Youtube video will get out sync, buffer, and struggle to play correctly.

Turning off Hardware acceleration fixes the issue. But this issue does not happen with Edge or Chrome at all.

Screenshots NA

Additional Notes Add any other context about the problem here.

gz83 commented 8 months ago

Please check whether the graphics card driver is normal and is the latest version

thesunnymachine commented 8 months ago

Please check whether the graphics card driver is normal and is the latest version

thesunnymachine commented 8 months ago

Looks like it's only happening in Thorium when I tested today. When I posted I tested with Edge and Chrome and it was causing issues in Thorium with YT playback, but today I can only get it to happen when Thorium has windows open for live streams.

I recorded a video of the issue: https://youtu.be/dEZ5PSg-vT4 It's still processing but you can see clearly that when I open the streams and close them that youtube lags / buffers and catches back up when I close the streams.

Wolfsbane378 commented 8 months ago

I'm having the same issue with youtube in general on Thorium. Had to switch back to chrome

Rairof commented 8 months ago

YouTube playback on Fullscreen gives a lot of stutters with hardware acceleration on but disabling it solves the issue. Hope its fixed soon.

gz83 commented 8 months ago

Please provide the link(s) to the problematic video(s) and I will try to reproduce the problem you are experiencing.

Rairof commented 8 months ago

https://github.com/Alex313031/Thorium-Win/issues/103#issuecomment-1794267954 It's all videos in full screen. You can watch any videos in full screen and it stutters with hardware acceleration on.

gz83 commented 8 months ago

I use Thorium on my computer to randomly play some videos in full-screen mode, using 1080P image quality. Under the default configuration, no abnormalities have been found (at least during the video playback process), and the progress bar can also be dragged at will.

fubaWoW commented 7 months ago

Same issue here, but...

This is not a Thorium only issue and it is definitely not just Intel! Also Edge have this issue but only if Hardware Acceleration is enabed on my System! Very easy to test if you have a Unreal 5 Engine Game and "try" to run Youtube or Twitch on a 2nd Monitor for example while the Unreal 5 Game is running. This will make ALL Browser Videos almost "stop" and stutter all the time.

Had to disable Hardware Acceleration and it works now.

My System btw: CPU: Intel i7-13700k RAM: Corsair DDR5 64GB 6600MHz CL32 GPU: Nvidia RTX 3070Ti ...

thesunnymachine commented 7 months ago

Same issue here, but...

This is not a Thorium only issue and it is definitely not just Intel! Also Edge have this issue but only if Hardware Acceleration is enabed on my System! Very easy to test if you have a Unreal 5 Engine Game and "try" to run Youtube or Twitch on a 2nd Monitor for example while the Unreal 5 Game is running. This will make ALL Browser Videos almost "stop" and stutter all the time.

Had to disable Hardware Acceleration and it works now.

My System btw: CPU: Intel i7-13700k RAM: Corsair DDR5 64GB 6600MHz CL32 GPU: Nvidia RTX 3070Ti ...

Interesting. I am not having this issue with Chrome at the moment.

Today, I tested this issue again and I am not seeing buffering, but I am seeing a lot more dropped frames and completely different stats in the "stats for nerds" info.

Using the same exact video, here's my info from chrome:

I only got dropped frames while I alt tabbed and setup to take the screen grab on chrome.

With Thorium: Here I was dropping frames pretty often, while just watching the video.

On a third test, I got no dropped frames at all. 2 Streams open in other windows, no buffering no stuttering. Maybe the Nvidia driver 546.01 update fixed the issue? I will use thorium for a while again and see if the issue comes back.

fubaWoW commented 7 months ago

Interesting. I am not having this issue with Chrome at the moment.

Yeah on Chrome i also so not have this issue, but on Edge, Thorium and Brave. don't ask me why -> i don't know ^^

On a third test, I got no dropped frames at all. 2 Streams open in other windows, no buffering no stuttering. Maybe the Nvidia driver 546.01 update fixed the issue? I will use thorium for a while again and see if the issue comes back.

Ok.. I have 546.08 installed I will Test it later with Remnant 2, that Game forced all the Browsers i tested (except Chrome) to stutter on my 2nd monitor if Hardware Acceleration is enabled.

Also tested with Chrome now and it seems Chrome begin to stutter but "recover" itself instantly and stutter is gone. Edge and Thorium does not "recover", they keep stuttering until almost stop the Video!

Disable Hardware Acceleration on Thorium or Edge and there is no Stutter at all!

ElPrudi commented 7 months ago

All videos and gifs flickered black constantly on Thorium. Disabling hardware acceleration definitely helped me.

Consumaut commented 6 months ago

Same here. Used to use Edge, Chrome and Firefox without any problems. What others describe only happened with Thorium.

Windows 11 23H2 (Build 22631.2715) AMD Ryzen 9 5950x @4100 MHz NVIDIA GeForce RTX 3090 546.29

I`m glad I found this threat, cause with Hardware Acceleration off everything works like a charm. It feels like while playing the buffer it is not loading anything from the network till the buffer end is reached. Happens on Youtube and Twitch when playng both in seperate windows on a widescreen at the same time, also when a video is in background while opening a new tab on youtube to search for another video.

HerXayah commented 2 months ago

Heya, i have this aswell on AMD hardware. 7900XT on Windows. latest thorium avx2 build.