search

AlexsLemonade / OpenPBTA-analysis

The analysis repository for the Open Pediatric Brain Tumor Atlas Project
Other
100 stars 67 forks source link

key resources table #1366

Closed sjspielman closed 2 years ago

sjspielman commented 2 years ago

According to the Cell guidelines,

Please note that the key resources table and STAR Methods text are not considered part of the SI.

The key resources table should be renamed from TableS5-Key-Resources-table.xlsx to just Key-Resources-table.xlsx.

jharenza commented 2 years ago

@sjspielman we may have to reach out to the editors because this is in contrast to what I posted the other day that if we go over the KR table limit, then it becomes a supp table

jharenza commented 2 years ago

My read of what you have above is that the actual KR table which they provide the template for, and STAR Methods, are not part of the supplement, but per this, if we expand (>10 items within a heading of the table), then we need to make that an official supp table. If you have a different understanding, then I can email the journal quickly to find out. In this case, table S5 is really a software resources table expanded from the KR table.

sjspielman commented 2 years ago

Aha! Thanks. What a shame this information is not linked from the other set of information that says Key Resources isn't SI! We can probably ignore all of this then!

jharenza commented 2 years ago

💯