Open samuelsonric opened 1 year ago
The function junction
has a similar problem:
using Catlab.ACSetInterface, Catlab.WiringDiagrams
wd = singleton_diagram(UntypedUWD, 1000000);
function collect_junctions_1(wd)
js = Int[]
for i in ports(wd)::UnitRange{Int}
push!(js, junction(wd, i))
end
js
end
function collect_junctions_2(wd)
js = Int[]
_js = collect(subpart(wd, :junction))
for i in ports(wd)::UnitRange{Int}
push!(js, _js[i])
end
js
end
Then
collect_junctions_1(wd)
@time collect_junctions_1(wd);
outputs 0.206502 seconds (3.00 M allocations: 177.620 MiB)
.
On the other hand,
collect_junctions_2(wd)
@time collect_junctions_2(wd);
outputs 0.006355 seconds (19 allocations: 17.411 MiB)
Thanks for the catch here. According to @code_warntype
it is a problem in ACsets parts code.
julia> @code_warntype parts(wd, :Port)
MethodInstance for ACSets.ACSetInterface.parts(::UntypedUWD, ::Symbol)
from parts(acs, type) @ ACSets.ACSetInterface ~/.julia/packages/ACSets/1pqJM/src/ACSetInterface.jl:36
Arguments
#self#::Core.Const(ACSets.ACSetInterface.parts)
acs::UntypedUWD
type::Symbol
Body::Any
1 ─ nothing
│ %2 = ACSets.ACSetInterface.nparts(acs, type)::Any
│ %3 = (1:%2)::Any
└── return %3
nparts
has the same problem
julia> @code_warntype nparts(wd, :Port)
MethodInstance for ACSets.ACSetInterface.nparts(::UntypedUWD, ::Symbol)
from nparts(acs::SimpleACSet, type::Symbol) @ ACSets.DenseACSets ~/.julia/packages/ACSets/1pqJM/src/DenseACSets.jl:341
Arguments
#self#::Core.Const(ACSets.ACSetInterface.nparts)
acs::UntypedUWD
type::Symbol
Body::Any
1 ─ nothing
│ %2 = Base.getproperty(acs, :parts)::ACSets.LVectors.LVector{(:Box, :Port, :OuterPort, :Junction), Int64}
│ %3 = Base.getindex(%2, type)::Any
└── return %3
Full MWE:
using Catlab.WiringDiagrams
using Catlab.CategoricalAlgebra
wd = singleton_diagram(UntypedUWD, 1000000);
@code_warntype nparts(wd, :Port)
I tested on Catlab 14 and 13 so this isn't a (recent) regression. with the ACSets refactor.
Consider the following two functions:
Then, on my machine,
outputs
0.051219 seconds (3.00 M allocations: 70.801 MiB)
.On the other hand,
outputs
0.004928 seconds (17 allocations: 9.782 MiB)
.