search

Anime-Lists / anime-lists

106 stars 50 forks source link

Removed wrong mappings #391

Closed Guslletas closed 10 months ago

Guslletas commented 10 months ago
AniDB TVDB/TMDB/IMDB Notes
https://anidb.net/anime/708 https://thetvdb.com/index.php?tab=series&id=79654 Removed mapping
https://anidb.net/anime/3626 https://thetvdb.com/index.php?tab=series&id=286895 Removed mapping

So I've been implementing support for mapping using absolute numbers on my app and found those 2 are wrongly mapped:

Those two seem like a nightmare to map manually but I believe it's better to not provide the mappings than to provide wrong ones.

BrutuZ commented 10 months ago

The IDs exist and match on both. The TVDB entry being incomplete or "too complete" is out of scope for the list, it's just a matter of some dedicated volunteer fixing up the TVDB entries

Guslletas commented 10 months ago

The IDs match but the mappings are wrong, it's not about the tvdb entry being incomplete it's about the mappings providing wrong info. For those 2 shows the absolute numbering mapping can't be used because TVDB's absolute order and AniDB one can't match. For example according to the mappings for Shin Chan anidb's 1006 episode(https://anidb.net/episode/219235) is mapped to tvdb absolute order episode 1006(https://thetvdb.com/series/crayon-shin-chan/episodes/6871930) when it should map to tvdb's episode 1062(https://thetvdb.com/series/crayon-shin-chan/episodes/7311859).

BrutuZ commented 10 months ago

Still no reason to remove the ID mapping. If there's some discrepancy midway it should be fixed either on TVDB or with a mapping-list override