search

Anonymousdog / displaycameras

System for displaying RTSP feeds from IP cameras on the Raspberry Pi
Apache License 2.0
566 stars 113 forks source link

Using 2nd HDMI on Pi 4 #21

Closed drugfrog closed 2 years ago

drugfrog commented 5 years ago

Love the work so much I got the Pi 4, It would be great to utilise the 2nd HDMI port for another display.

Usage Modes I would envisage needed would be: Mirroring Current Rotation method spread across two displays Differing Rotation on each display, eg. 1st rotating Fullscreen, the 2nd static matrix of all feed.

routerino commented 5 years ago

For that matter, how is the performance on the pi4? I'm specifically thinking about 4k applications, such as having a 4x4 display on a giant 4k output.

Is downscaling improved on the pi 4 as well? We have 4k cameras that I would like to decode and downscale to 1080p (as a single display).

icepicknz commented 5 years ago

I'd love this too, I have a rpi4 ready to go and would like to do something similar with 1 full screen and 6 matrix on second screen (one large and 5 smaller)

Anonymousdog commented 4 years ago

I have no idea when I might be able to revisit this for RPi 4's new capabilities. I suspect that all or most of these requests would require significant reworking and are probably beyond the capabilities of a shell scripted system. I don't even have an RPi 4. If I get one, I may revisit this. Feel free to make code contributions or fork the code.

SebDominguez commented 4 years ago

Just throwing this here and I don't know if that will be useful but if we had in the feeds configuration file both HDMI 0 (main HDMI output) and HDMI 7 (second HDMI output) we can then send the --display option to omxplayer.

This play the feed in the first screen omxplayer --no-keys --no-osd --avdict rtsp_transport:tcp rtsp://x.x.x.x:7447/yxzyxzyxz --live -n -1 --timeout 30 --display 0

And this play on the second omxplayer --no-keys --no-osd --avdict rtsp_transport:tcp rtsp://x.x.x.x:7447/yxzyxzyxz --live -n -1 --timeout 30 --display 7

pzzt2t commented 4 years ago

I'm looking for a solution with Anonymousdog's displaycameras but to output on 2 screens. It will send 4(2x2) to display1 and 6(3x2) to display2 In total 10 different cameras. But is it possible?

Currently using displaycamera on different RPI's, and its working very nicely ... just need that last tweak :)

bal0u45 commented 4 years ago

@pzzt2t Using a 2nd display is possible. See the reply above your comment from @SebDominguez. However, this does require some trial and error especially with camera and display resolutions. I have an RPi4 4GB model running omxplayer to output 6 cameras on a 16:10 aspect ratio monitor and another 2 cameras on a 4:3 monitor. I had to tweak the camera resolution and fps settings quite a bit though. Especially so that there is no downscaling at all, otherwise omxplayer would crash immediately. You can have a look at my fork of this repo for a way this could be done with displaycameras. I will finish testing and updating that fork when I have time so that it might be added in a future version.

pzzt2t commented 4 years ago

@bal0u45 Wow.. sounds very nice. I look over your repo, not 100% sure what do to. I run anonymousdog's setup right now. Do I only need to replace displaycameras with your displaycameras?

or do will I just have to install your modified displaycamera? .. And im not sure which files needed to modify for the cameras to be displayed on the two different screens.

Sorry for all the questions, hope for you helpfull reply :)

Best Regards

bal0u45 commented 4 years ago

@pzzt2t The fork is still WIP. You would need to include the designated monitor in the layout.conf for each camera you want to display. As I said, I will update the repo and then submit it to @Anonymousdog

sanaking commented 3 years ago

Hi @bal0u45 ! Thanks for that, I downloaded it, however I am not seeing how to specify which display in the configuration? Also, I am using two screens with the exact same resolution, so I'm not sure if that would be an issue or not

Anonymousdog commented 3 years ago

The project doesn't support multiple displays. That's outside the use case. However, you may edit the main script code to include an omxplayer target display parameter (in both places the omxplayer command line is constructed in the script, lines 121 and 223). That appears to be '--display 2' for HDMI 0 and '--display 7' for HDMI 1.

On Thu, Dec 17, 2020, 8:19 PM Ajay notifications@github.com wrote:

Hi @bal0u45 https://github.com/bal0u45 ! Thanks for that, I downloaded it, however I am not seeing how to specify which display in the configuration? Also, I am using two screens with the exact same resolution, so I'm not sure if that would be an issue or not

— You are receiving this because you were mentioned. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/Anonymousdog/displaycameras/issues/21#issuecomment-747806456, or unsubscribe https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AHIYIKM76URDMXNMIBUJNVDSVKU2JANCNFSM4H7OIEIA .

sanaking commented 3 years ago

@bal0u45 @pzzt2t I have modified displaycameras to display to multiple screens, if you'd like to see my revisions, lmk and I can setup a fork. I basically did what anonymousdog suggested before I read his comment, making modifications to the script and the config file appropriately.

pzzt2t commented 3 years ago

@bal0u45 @pzzt2t I have modified displaycameras to display to multiple screens, if you'd like to see my revisions, lmk and I can setup a fork. I basically did what anonymousdog suggested before I read his comment, making modifications to the script and the config file appropriately.

That does sound very nice sanaking. I would like to try it

Best regards

SvenVD commented 3 years ago

Hi,

Just want to give a heads up that v3 of Rpisurv has been released https://github.com/SvenVD/rpisurv/releases/tag/v3.0.0-beta3.

This includes full support for dual displays.

Mirroring = possible by configuring the same streams for each display Current Rotation method spread across two displays = each display will have his own rotation. Differing Rotation on each display, eg. 1st rotating Fullscreen, the 2nd static matrix of all feed. = This is possible

Please test it out, we need some beta testers for the new version.

Thanks

Anonymousdog commented 3 years ago

Nice job!

On Tue, Dec 29, 2020, 6:04 PM SvenVD notifications@github.com wrote:

Hi,

Just want to give a heads up that v3 of Rpisurv has been released https://github.com/SvenVD/rpisurv/releases/tag/v3.0.0-beta3.

This includes full support for dual displays.

Mirroring = possible by configuring the same streams for each display Current Rotation method spread across two displays = each display will have his own rotation. Differing Rotation on each display, eg. 1st rotating Fullscreen, the 2nd static matrix of all feed. = This is possible

Please test it out, we need some beta testers for the new version.

Thanks

— You are receiving this because you were mentioned. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/Anonymousdog/displaycameras/issues/21#issuecomment-752270477, or unsubscribe https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AHIYIKPFVE5Y46WO5N6GB3DSXJOAPANCNFSM4H7OIEIA .

sanaking commented 3 years ago

@pzzt2t > That does sound very nice sanaking.

I would like to try it

Best regards

I haven't been able to make it stable (it keeps spawning new omxplayer processes which layer on top of each other until it closes them all), so while I could give you the tiny mods that make it work, I haven't figured out how to keep it running or what the issue is. That said, it may not be a displaycameras issue, because it is also complaining about finding the root and pid file for omx in /tmp and I don't know why, so.. I gave up, and I moved on to rpisurv