AppliedEnergistics / Applied-Energistics-2

A Minecraft Mod about Matter, Energy and using them to conquer the world..
https://appliedenergistics.github.io/
Other
1.43k stars 655 forks source link

Channels is still kind of activated when you turn them off in config. #1369

Closed fresser closed 9 years ago

fresser commented 9 years ago

Hi.

Was playing on my local server with channels deactivated (boring me, haha) So when i went above ~820 devices on the network, it went offline and said "Device Missing Channel". I tried removing one interface, and it worked again, placing anything requiring a channel, turned the whole system offline.

I tried in singleplayer too, same thing happens, but with a different amount of devices. ~800 but with 350 devices that needed a channel.

I am running AE2-Beta30 on ftb infinity.

thatsIch commented 9 years ago

Are you actually missing a channel (most devices have an indicator if they are active or not), or just WAILA trolling you?

fresser commented 9 years ago

The whole network is offline, and waila says "Device Missing Channel". Is there a way to tell if there is a reason for this, or if it's actually a bug?

No matter what, i don't think i should ever get the message "Missing Channel" when channels is turned off. :)

thatsIch commented 9 years ago

Your whole network is offline? Please post a screen of state before and after.

Wrong messages are another issue.

fresser commented 9 years ago

Screen of state? I've uploaded 4 images to imgur http://imgur.com/YvXws4F,yPfQuB2,jjXSFDG,n5YxuRU first 2 it works fine, the next 2 i place one more interface and it's offline.

I notice though, the drives are online, but all terminals are offline, even the wireless ones.

thatsIch commented 9 years ago

Sounds more like a power issue to me, do you per change have not enough energy buffer (sufficient AE2 energy cells)?

thatsIch commented 9 years ago

Also please use the default texture pack next time for screenshots. I basically can not see any difference in off and on behavior with a non-default TP applied.

yueh commented 9 years ago

Also keep in mind that it does not actually disable channels, but technically allows infinite channels. Thus it will still need to initialize the network and recurring power issues or chunk unloading will force the network to rebuild. While it is doing it, there can still be devices without channels.

thatsIch commented 9 years ago

Maybe we should call it infinite channels

vallard192 commented 9 years ago

That might make a lot of sense... I haven't tested, but (using fancy new terminology) if you turn on infinite channels, can you set up a equal length route that ends up with devices offline since there are multiple paths to it? (As described on http://ae-mod.info/Channels/)

If so infinite channels is probably a much better way to describe it since there are still channel-like limitations to network design.

On Fri, May 1, 2015 at 12:37 PM, thatsIch notifications@github.com wrote:

Maybe we should call it infinite channels

— Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub https://github.com/AppliedEnergistics/Applied-Energistics-2/issues/1369#issuecomment-98174023 .

fresser commented 9 years ago

I have 12 dense energy cells hooked up. I just tried hooking 8 more up, no difference what so ever, they are all fully charged according to wailo (other ways to see if they are charged?)

@vallard192 Shouldn't make any difference, since there is no controller either. There is no place the cable is going from, so in my head it wouldn't make sense there is such limitations?

you cannot tell any difference if the terminals are online or offline visually. Even with default tp.

vallard192 commented 9 years ago

Can you try a creative cell? Someone had the issue below a couple weeks ago...I'm hoping I summarize it well.

On large networks is possible to go from "large and sufficient generator" -> "power storage" -> AE network

However if your power srorages hold less power than your network pulls each tick, then your network will still have power issues. Even though your generator makes more than enough power.

Using made up numbers...

If you generate 200 power a tick, but only have power storage for 50, any network that needs more than 50 at some point may have issues because the AE network won't receive more power than your STORAGE can put out...it can depend on your power design...but a creative cell would be an easy way to test. On May 2, 2015 7:03 AM, "fresser" notifications@github.com wrote:

I have 12 dense energy cells hooked up. I just tried hooking 8 more up, no difference what so ever, they are all fully charged according to wailo (other ways to see if they are charged?)

@vallard192 https://github.com/vallard192 Shouldn't make any difference, since there is no controller either. There is no place the cable is going from, so in my head it wouldn't make sense there is such limitations?

you cannot tell any difference if the terminals are online or offline visually. Even with default tp.

— Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub https://github.com/AppliedEnergistics/Applied-Energistics-2/issues/1369#issuecomment-98347732 .

fresser commented 9 years ago

Hmn. I tried a creative cell. Same issue.

And yes, i understand, and it took me a while figuring out. (Have been there, when the network was offline for some weird reason xD)

fresser commented 9 years ago

Sorry if this stresses you. Just wanted to say, i have not had luck to fix this issue. I've tried with multiple cables attached on the Energy Acceptor, which is the closest we get to a controller on this network..

Energy Cells doesn't affect anything, and the network has plenty of charge. (full)

Can i enable some debug thing, that may output why it deactivates the terminals? The drives are still online, although every automatic process in the system is on halt.

XFactHD commented 9 years ago

Controller? How can you have a controller with channels turned off?

fresser commented 9 years ago

I do not have a controller. I have a Energy Acceptor, which i think is the closest to a controller we'll get. But probably has nothing to do with it though. Worth a shot at least :)

ClintonFlowers commented 9 years ago

I'm having the same issue. If I add devices, it shuts off. Everything on, working mostly fine: http://i.imgur.com/q2vp0A9.png +1 assembler, everything turns off: http://i.imgur.com/1nDUdHf.png (Energy cells on the right to show that it's full.)

Lyokomzm commented 9 years ago

Also having this issue on my server. Channels are disabled, and we have tried everything that was mentioned prior, (creative energy cell, more energy acceptors). If you need any configs, images or logs from us just ask, will gladly provide them.

thatsIch commented 9 years ago

We might need to remove/disable the "infinite channels" flag again, if this creates so many untraceable problems..

thatsIch commented 9 years ago

Closing this in favor of https://github.com/AppliedEnergistics/Applied-Energistics-2/issues/1510