ArchipelaGOAL / Archipelago

Archipelago Multi-Game Randomizer and Server
https://archipelago.gg
Other
2 stars 1 forks source link

Add ability to channel eco as a drop #55

Open Zedb0T opened 1 week ago

jacobmix commented 6 days ago

So you won't be able to use blue/yellow/red eco vents, and pickups without these new items? If this get's added as an option it would also be something to tie to the last 3 orb caches in Citadel. I assume green, and light eco wouldn't be included.

massimilianodelliubaldini commented 1 day ago

Channeling green eco is used for Basin's dark eco plant minigame. It's the only usage of it in the game, so it's not a total loss if we leave it alone, and I don't know where you would map it to a location. (warp gate buttons?)

massimilianodelliubaldini commented 1 day ago

Things that would need to change if you wanted "Channel X Eco" as an item:

Blue

Red

(I don't think anything in the entire game requires red eco, but the places it is available I would consider adding it to the location rules.)

Yellow

Needless to say this would be a massive change.

massimilianodelliubaldini commented 1 day ago

And then the additional work of:

... A really massive change.

massimilianodelliubaldini commented 8 hours ago

Fun Fact

With the following settings:

There are only 9 checks you can actually do (7 cells, +1 for fisherman, +1 scout fly in Beach, cannon tower can open it for you). You can also reach 231 orbs.

This extremely small number of checks would almost certainly lead to early BK's, even in 2 player Jak games with the same settings. For example, one player would get their Channel Blue Eco in these first 9/18 checks, and then they have a ton of things to do, while the second player has to wait for the first player to find their instance of Channel Blue Eco. And forget larger games with more players, or players playing other games. This would be equivalent to worse than being stuck on Geyser Rock (there's a reason you can leave Geyser immediately) (Geyser has 10 checks total).

The only way I could conceive this working is if you had a Friendly Limit on it. In order for you to enable Eco Channeling: