search

Athena9355 / Fire-extinguisher

2 stars 1 forks source link

Week 8 Review Ticket #79

Open allisonthuang opened 3 years ago

allisonthuang commented 3 years ago
  1. Updated README File
  2. TPT 3.7 and 3.8 work
  3. Class Recommendations/Comment Page - Made comments stay, made like button
  4. Feedback Page--Satisfaction with various aspects
  5. Feedback generator
  6. Logic Gate Lab
jm1021 commented 3 years ago

Review ticket in zoom

1 minute of Project

2 minute runtime

Technical overview

Great introduction on ideas and future. Really like the feedback response (logic gates). Great discussion of list to JSON objects.

Comment box dialog needs a little better integration to ideas.

Danny4w commented 3 years ago

positives-very nice structure and ideas. I liked how relatable it is to high school students improvements- for the comments you should expand that tab and center it more (user friendly)

hamzahakak commented 3 years ago
  1. Updated README File
  2. TPT 3.7 and 3.8 work
  3. Class Recommendations/Comment Page - Made comments stay, made like button
  4. Feedback Page--Satisfaction with various aspects
  5. Feedback generator
  6. Logic Gate Lab

positives: warm and cozy aesthetic unique idea very professional and not cluttered

negatives: not much really, maybe make the UI better

3ghin5 commented 3 years ago

+very detailed and organized presentation +overall theme is nice +detailed informative description of code

-the layout and appearance of the page could be improved. for example the discussion has very small boxes and the button only shows "P".

KylieScharf commented 3 years ago

I like the idea of an interactive website where multiple people can interact through your website so it can actually bring people together. I also was really impressed with how you were able to have a post page where the posts are actually stored. I also liked the calm background of your site and how you kept it consistent throughout. One thing I think you could improve is making the index page less like the original page and making it more your own page.

christinlee367 commented 3 years ago

Positives:

yolandayangg commented 3 years ago

Positive: I really liked that you included the trademark, it shows great dedication to the project. I also particularly liked the discussion forum, it is definitely a hard task. The logic gates was also really interesting, I liked that there were emotions attached to the class.

Improvement: if there is any way that the forum can be displayed in a way closer to a discussion board, it would make the website a lot more aesthetically pleasing.

KhushiB24 commented 3 years ago

One thing I like about your project is how this website is to help with the new schedules, so then there are can be more features to be added. Another thing I liked about your project is that there is a comment forum page as that helps the students to let others know information that we might miss. I liked how there is a feedback page, because the users would be able to input their ideas and let others know about the grading. One thing you can add is to use different tabs for different subjects, that can help the users to navigate to go to a specific subject that they want to look into.

JakubPonulak commented 3 years ago

Positives - clear/organized presentation & website, easy to understand TT/CB topics and notes Negatives - Theme could be improved in text form ( different font, color, size)

DistilledVinegar commented 3 years ago

It’s always great to see things be developed so close to home. The commenting and logic gate systems were really cool to see. The future plans you have also look highly promising. I’m struggling to find criticism, but be sure to polish the commenting system more stylistically. Using case switches instead of several if’s may also be technically useful.

AkhilNandhakumar commented 3 years ago

The background of the site looks pleasing and fits in with the theme of the site. The look and the integration of the feedback page/chat page was really cool. I also thought that integration of the logic gates and rgb into the page was creative and worked well too. Your presentation was also very clear and engaging.

The UI could be a bit nicer and expanded.

TheRadRabbidRabbit commented 3 years ago
B-G101 commented 3 years ago

The idea of your website is super unique and you guys have super clear goals. The design of your website is super pretty. Once thing you could add is sizing up the comment area because it was kinda small.

shrutiapcsp commented 3 years ago

I liekd your incorporation of the logic gates minilab and other technicals, the code seemed very techincal and intricate.

Suggestions: The layout on the website could be a bit larger to make it easier to read.

Ritvik-Keerthi commented 3 years ago

I thought that your incorporation of the mini-lab technical into your project was well done. I also think that your overall idea is very good, as well as the extra .py files added.

One thing you could improve on would be changing the layout.

rebecca-123 commented 3 years ago

Positives

  1. Like how user is able to interact with website (commenting, rating)
  2. Nice implementation of API for comments
  3. Explanation of code was thorough

Improvements

  1. Clearer submission box for comments
Kevinc023032 commented 3 years ago

The overall design of the website was visually appealing, the feedback page was interesting because I haven't seen that before. The explanations of the code were easy to understand, the website was easy to navigate through.

Stanleyy03840 commented 3 years ago

positives: really like how the theme of the website and how it stayed consistent throughout and looked really clean. implementation of logic gates into review tab was also very creative. improvements: probably make the page more personalized

gigiguan commented 3 years ago

I like the idea of your website. I also like how you incorporated many interactive features that the user can input to. One thing you can improve on is adjusting the textbox size for your "leave a comment" page and also make it centered on the page.

NathanShih04 commented 3 years ago

+Interaction with the website was very streamline and easy +The implementation of the logic gates was really cool +Code was neat and intricate -Styling features could be improved to be more visually appealing

kkwan0 commented 3 years ago

interaction was good, spacing could be improved

KoolKidKai commented 3 years ago

+well planned and formatted website +creative ideas +cohesive pages all work together -improve size and ease of use with comment box

ValenReynolds commented 3 years ago

I like the feedback page it is very simple yet helpful. The site looks very clean and simple. The backgrounds look good but they aren't too distracting. I would make the comment box larger.

nehapavani commented 3 years ago

I really liked how you had feedback pages and comment pages. I think you could add more information for the topics you include feedback pages on.

jacksongolding commented 3 years ago

I liked the idea of the project and the feedback page is very interesting. I think that the textbox of the feedback page could be bigger.

Athena9355 commented 3 years ago

Grade for presentation 4.5/5 for every member (as instructed by Mr. M.) Aadya and Athena 3.7, 3.8 notes plus notes from TO’s presentation: all notes are present. Therefore, a grade of 3/3 is given Allison and Gaurish 3.7, 3.8 notes plus notes from TO’s presentation: all notes are present. Therefore, a grade of 3/3 is given

Overall grade for each member: Aadya: 7.5/8 Allison: 7.5/8 Athena: 7.5/8 Gaurish: 7.5/8

link to week 8 review ticket: https://github.com/Athena9355/Fire-extinguisher/issues/79 link to improvement: https://github.com/Athena9355/Fire-extinguisher/issues/82 sum of comments: 25 from peers