Atlantiss / NetherwingBugtracker

Official bugtracker for the Netherwing and Karazhan (2.4.3) realms.
52 stars 36 forks source link

[Item] " Ravager " proc rate too low, no on hit effects, character still autoattacking. #6525

Open Tankdiehutte opened 4 years ago

Tankdiehutte commented 4 years ago

Description: The Procrate of the weapon seems to be too low. Link: https://de.classic.wowhead.com/item=7717/verheerer#english-comments ( https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NPMpjuu9XF8 ) ( https://youtu.be/auXIiW2brIk?t=285 )

Current behaviour: The weapon procs every 20-40 hits. Which is is a procrate of 2,5 - 5%. Character continues autohitting. On hit effects (Righteousness tested) doesnt proc on the aoe effect. Judgements stop the effect.

Expected behaviour: The procrate should be around 15%. No autohits should be possible while Ravager proc. ( https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NPMpjuu9XF8 )

See comment from 10th July 2006: "Proc rate seems about 15% or so. Not reliable enough to decide to suddenly start AOEing monsters; but if you are already hunting monsters in packs anyway then it wouldn't hurt ." Comment from 1th April 2005: "The chance on hit is pretty frequent. once every 5-10 hits."

Seals like SoC should also proc ( since all mobs get attacked, see item description) & comment from 4th August 2005: "When engaging a mob judge them with Seal of Crusder, then use Seal of command. When the axe procs your seal of command will proc with it 3 times in a row. MAD DAMAGE!"

The only patch it got mentioned was 2.4.2 (https://wowwiki.fandom.com/wiki/Ravager_(axe)): "Judgements will no longer auto-refresh and break the effect from this item while its effect is active."

Server Revision:

Evolvee commented 4 years ago

+https://github.com/Atlantiss/NetherwingBugtracker/issues/4034#issuecomment-453813832

Tankdiehutte commented 4 years ago

https://youtu.be/rJaA9qlHuJw?t=490 proc after 5 hits ( 20s ) https://youtu.be/rJaA9qlHuJw?t=570 proc after 4 hits https://youtu.be/rJaA9qlHuJw?t=765 proc after 4 hits ( with weapon, see disarm ) https://youtu.be/rJaA9qlHuJw?t=880 proc after 5 hits https://youtu.be/rJaA9qlHuJw?t=900 proc after 2 hits https://youtu.be/rJaA9qlHuJw?t=984 proc after 4 hits https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ptjk2UpqZG4 Early proc after 2 hits in cataclysm ( here equipped in offhand, thats why damage so low ) Also many early procs shown: "turns you into a dungeon clearing machine" - hits to procrate being higher than 0,7 ppm ( ~4% ) https://youtu.be/wjt3T6qCvPE Onetake video of a warrior leveling up 2H axes with that weapon in tbc(see neatherweave bags) (3 procs in 42 hits , 5 hits between 2 last procs) https://youtu.be/x3GO5uJL2hk?t=395 2 procs of the Paladin in the group within 30s singletarget https://youtu.be/x3GO5uJL2hk?t=1393 3 procs on 3 mobs within 30s

Tankdiehutte commented 4 years ago

2007.04.25 (Patch 2.0.12)Betreff: "procs"

In theory yes. Cause you can have your Bladestorm proc off itself. Meaning it still counts every hit you do as an actual strike and not some kind of spell. My friend has a 44 warrior that procs all the time right after he uses whirlwind. Looks awsome. specially when he can use whirlwind right after the attack and proc again.

Tankdiehutte commented 4 years ago

What needs to be fixed:

  1. No more Autohits while channel.
  2. ppm invcreased to 2.0 from 0.7 (2.0 seems still too low, compared with the comments, but players often use too high numbers to make their point why item X is op or sth. 2.0 would be around 11,7 % and every 2nd whirlwind of a warrior. )
Tankdiehutte commented 4 years ago

+last tick of the channel sometimes doesnt trigger the AoE hit

Godmatik commented 2 months ago

Rev 4018 The proc still needs to be rescripted in a number of ways Along with what is stated above - check classic comments for some more details (such as it should be able to proc itself): https://www.wowhead.com/wotlk/item=7717/ravager#comments;280