search

AtlasOfLivingAustralia / specieslist-webapp

Species lists and traits tool
https://lists.ala.org.au
Mozilla Public License 2.0
6 stars 21 forks source link

Lists tool - Supplied vernacularName, CommonName not retained on upload #246

Closed rosemaryjoconnor closed 1 month ago

rosemaryjoconnor commented 1 year ago

Lists tool is removing supplied fields such as vernacularName (Vernacular name) and CommonName (Common name) if they are supplied in the upload file. Common name is populated via matching and if either of the above are supplied they are not being retained.

This is problematic for our authoritative lists as supplied fields may be specific to the local region for Conservation or Sensitive data and need to be retained.

Could this please be investigated.

adam-collins commented 1 year ago

Uploaded lists will always have additional columns added. There will always be a problem when the upload file has columns with the same names as the columns added by lists.

It would be worthwhile noting this issue on the upload page after a UI review https://lists.ala.org.au/speciesList/upload

The solution is to rename the conflicting columns before uploading. Please confirm that this works.

nickdos commented 1 month ago

Hi @rosemaryjoconnor - can we close this issue, as I note the related 1004 has been closed?

rosemaryjoconnor commented 1 month ago

@nickdos I'll have a word with Amanda Buyan and see if this is still an issue.

rosemaryjoconnor commented 1 month ago

@nickdos Amanda has done some testing for authoritative lists. As long as vernacularName is used to represent the common name the state gives a species, and then the Common Name (Matched) is what the ALA comes up with. Not the most ideal but is a workaround. She has updated her code and documentation accordingly. I'll close this off now thank.