search

AuburnSounds / Dplug

Audio plugin framework. VST2/VST3/AU/AAX/LV2 for Linux/macOS/Windows.
https://dplug.org/
Other
483 stars 32 forks source link

VST3 + (Ableton Live or Studio One or Mixcraft) => no presets #374

Closed p0nce closed 3 years ago

p0nce commented 5 years ago

It seems Live cannot read such presets, as VST3 has several ways to expose them.

p0nce commented 5 years ago

It's a bit frustrating because we do expose a kIsProgramChange parameter, and implement the required getProgramListInfo.

p0nce commented 5 years ago

Ableton internal source said:

I could speak with someone with the VST3 team and at this point, it seems like we didn't implement this feature on our side. So there's nothing wrong with your plugin

p0nce commented 5 years ago

Reopened because it happens in FLStudio too.

p0nce commented 4 years ago

The key would be to convince hosts to support internal VST3 presets, since external files seems to be harder to deal with than previously on macOS.

p0nce commented 4 years ago

It's written in the SDK the preset file format, where to put them etc. But it requires collaboration from the installers, and on macOS will probably cause some headache.

p0nce commented 3 years ago

image

Still getting a bit of support for this feature, it's not nice to say people to uninstall the VST3 plugin.

p0nce commented 3 years ago

Same problem with Mixcraft.

p0nce commented 3 years ago

Note: older VST3 SDK have actual working HTML documentation unlike newer ones.

p0nce commented 3 years ago

Also affect SPAN, do JUCE plugin fare better?

image

p0nce commented 3 years ago

Also affect TDR Nova, which is AFAIK done with JUCE...

p0nce commented 3 years ago

Same in Studio One 5. EDIT: same in Ableton live 11 However, FLStudio does display them now.

p0nce commented 3 years ago

Wrote to both Studio One and Ableton support.

p0nce commented 1 year ago

Note: Studio One 6 also doesn't support IProgramList... sad