Autodesk / standard-surface

White paper describing the Autodesk Standard Surface shader.
Apache License 2.0
341 stars 25 forks source link

Thin film with Specular and Transmission #14

Open ix-kcam opened 3 years ago

ix-kcam commented 3 years ago

Hello,

We have noticed an unexpected behavior about the thin film when using it with a specular and transmission. It seems that when the thin film is enabled the transmission is not handling the TIR anymore. Is this the expected behavior ?

Here some images from Maya Arnold (MtoA 4.0.2 - 46d4a92e (master) - Feb 13 2020 03:01:44) that shows the issue :

Here we can see that increasing the depth transmission change nothing when the thin film is enabled :

New Project

And if we are visualizing this LPE : CTT+TL which correspond to internal reflection we have the TIR for the case when there is no thin film for the depth 3 and 4 but there is nothing when the thin film is enabled.

lpe

Thanks,

Kevin