Automattic / pocket-casts-ios

Pocket Casts iOS app 🎧
Mozilla Public License 2.0
1.66k stars 133 forks source link

Playback: audio skipped #44

Open pocketcasts opened 2 years ago

pocketcasts commented 2 years ago

Initially reported p1650892587223279-slack-C02A333D8LQ

What the listener said:

I was just listening to a 2hour podcast and at about 1hr10min it just skipped back to the beginning. Yet the progress bar still showed that the episode was at 1:10!?

It happened when they played the Biblical Series: Genesis 1 - Chaos & Order episode.

What has been done so far

joashrajin commented 1 year ago

6039157-zd-woothemes

azollafox commented 1 year ago

6343848-zd-woothemes

Time 5/29/2023 about 9:15pm Episode https://pca.st/episode/3118338d-c50f-4607-984c-a38466f035d8?t=3511.0 Jack by MSW Media After resuming for about 10 minutes it jumped back about 1.5 minutes spontaneously Time No ad playing Getting to the end of the episode Episode was streamed Intelligent playback enabled

Logs at C646FF30-6374-44AA-852C-555070F38655

the unexpected skip back is happening during playback after it has been playing for a while. Last it happened I had paused the episode and resumed much later but the skip back occurred after it had been playing for over 10 minutes. It doesn’t skip back repeatedly, so not “stuttering “ per se. On one skip back seemed to be over 1.5 minutes back. It was quite a ways.

It is also possible that it only occurs during episodes I have paused and resumed at some point. But I do that quite a lot as I move through my day. I’m trying to pay attention if it ever happens if I play a pod straight through. Not confident on this however.

azollafox commented 1 year ago

6343305-zen-woothemes Logs at E3995B9E-B84F-4EF1-A6D7-EFDC6E468D2F

This happens with all podcasts, with ads and without. It only happens when streaming. It happens with podcasts that playback starts and stops through , but have also noticed this on podcasts that have played straight through from the beginning.

mdrockwell commented 1 year ago

6381827-zd-woothemes Logs at 4B55E696-2DEA-435B-AB97-A89E2D9A56C8

No ad blockers or network services that could be causing issues. Issues happens on Wi-Fi and on cellular.

The occurrence that occurred before they sent logs — playback was on phone's speakers, episode was being streamed over Wi-Fi, intelligent playback was off.

Episode: The Bulwark episode for 6/14/23

Skip-back to about 34:17 (9:39 remaining) from about 34:36. So about 20 seconds.

https://pca.st/episode/d9169a7c-16ae-4c65-bc66-2d6972e7cf8d?t=2076.0

Truncated about 26 seconds before end. Reloaded podcast- scrolled forward to skip back time(34:17) and now it has 10:04 remaining. So about 25 seconds difference. (Times are all approximate)

joashrajin commented 1 year ago

+1 at 6481378-zd-woothemes

Yes I think this is the only podcast and I believe it is with ads inserted. It does happen with downloaded episodes. I notice the skips even if I don't resume the podcast and listen straight through, I believe.

joashrajin commented 1 year ago

+1 in 6537366-zd-woothemes

In this case, the user confirmed that the podcasts affected have ads, but the issue also is happening for them with downloaded podcasts. It is specific to Spreaker Podcasts (e.g. https://www.spreaker.com/user/17058220/the-m-a-s-h-up-glop)

joashrajin commented 1 year ago

+1 in 6541254-zd-woothemes

User noticed it happening when using Pocket Casts via Bluetooth in a car, but it does not happen when the episode is downloaded

mdrockwell commented 1 year ago

Occasionally when I’m listening to an episode of a podcast, an episode will skip forward on its own, completely cutting out certain parts of the episode. And it’s not me accidentally hitting the fast forward button either, because if I rewind it still skips forward at the exact same point in the episode every time. And it will happen whether it’s an episode I’ve downloaded or am just streaming. Anyone have a fix for this?

iOS 16.5.1 and app version 7.42.0.1

I do not have a vpn or firewall on my phone and no ad blocker on my wifi. Also, the problem happens whether I am on wifi or using my phone data.

https://forums.pocketcasts.com/forums/topic/parts-of-episodes-are-completely-cut-out/?view=all#post-913

joashrajin commented 1 year ago

+1 in 6645033-zd-a8c

erricgunawan commented 1 year ago

During almost every podcast episode I listen to the episode skips at various times. How can I prevent this?

App Version: 7.44 Device: iPhone14,5 OS: 16.6

6718555-zen

mdrockwell commented 1 year ago

Pocket Casts randomly rewinds after resuming from a pause in iOS app when casting to an external device via Apple Air Play. It only happens if I pause for a longer time and the Air Play connection disconnects and I reconnect to resume the podcast. I don't have Intelligent Resume enabled, but it occurs regardless of that setting. It rewinds more than 30 minutes typically. If I resume the podcast before the Air Play connection ends, there are no rewind issues.

App Version: 7.45 Device: iPhone15,3 OS: 16.6

6764753-zd-a8c

UPDATE

I was listening to the This week in Google podcast will the title Stupid Dove Nests. I was at least 1 hour into the podcast. I parked out for at least 30 minutes and the fair Play connection timed out. When I resumed the podcast episode had rewinded to 7:27.

C431C412-289A-418F-A2B2-E48BEBAFB5EB.log

joashrajin commented 1 year ago

Certain podcasts routinely skip huge chunks or jump backwards. Seems to be an issue with the actual file upload itself.

6775282-zd-a8c

joashrajin commented 1 year ago

7154312-zd-a8c

azollafox commented 1 year ago

7169092-zd-a8b

azollafox commented 1 year ago

7155905-zd-a8c

azollafox commented 1 year ago

I was a subscriber to pocket casts plus since 2018 and have listened to over 140 days of podcasts on the app since then. It has a horrible skipping problem in every episode you listen to (downloaded or not) where it’ll skip back to a previous part of the episode. I’ve had this issue for over a year and a half without any fixes. Doesn’t happen on Spotify or other podcast players, so I’ve cancelled my subscription and couldn’t be happier.

iOS app review

azollafox commented 1 year ago

In latest versions of the app I've encountered a weird problem: when playing a podcast, it'll sometimes jump back to earlier in the podcast -- like 15 min or so. Then I have to drag the cursor around to try to find where I left off. Love the app otherwise.

iOS app review

joashrajin commented 1 year ago

7217534-zd-a8c

I’ve been having this issue on Pocket Casts for iOS the past couple months. I’ll be listening to a podcast and randomly it will skip back about 1 minute and play a section I’ve already heard. I have no idea how to fix it and often it means the podcast will end before it is actually over. The issue does not occur when I am listening offline. Any ideas on how I can fix this? I am on version 7.49.0.3.

erricgunawan commented 1 year ago

For the past few weeks anytime I stop a podcast and come back to it. It’s much further ahead than when I stopped. This includes when I leave the app and when j pause it. I’m up to date on the app updates. It’s really really frustrating to have to skip back all the time. Can you let me know is this a a common issue?

App Version: 7.50 Device: iPhone11,2 OS: 17.1.1

7302969-zen

erricgunawan commented 10 months ago

This happens to me all the time and it’s been happening for over a year. I’m finally getting frustrated enough with it to write it because now it will do it five or six times during a 2 hour episode, downloaded or not and all different kinds of podcasts. I am on iOS (currently 17.2.1) and am running the latest Pocketcasts (7.5.3.1).

https://forums.pocketcasts.com/forums/topic/playback-skips-backwards-randomly/?view=all#post-2548

joashrajin commented 10 months ago

I often have podcasts just back 10-15 seconds and play the same section again. This is happening with my hands off the phone or not touching my headphones

7588740-zd-a8c

joashrajin commented 9 months ago

I moved to this because I didn’t like the updates on the Apple podcast app. This is good and you can make changes to suit how you listen. But quite often it jumps back 10 seconds or so and if this happens a few times in one podcast you end up missing the end.

App Review

7649851-zd-a8c

joashrajin commented 9 months ago

7710761-zd-a8c

erricgunawan commented 7 months ago

3-star app review (7931914-zen):

This is a great app but recently there have been so many issues with podcasts skipping ahead a minute and then cutting the episode off before the end- not sure what’s causing this but surely something which could be fixed easily. I’ve checked the episodes on other apps and no issues there so must be the app

azollafox commented 6 months ago

I just am able to download it if it skips/rewinds to get rid of the skip/rewind. I don't download episodes though I stream them, so the issue is probably carrying on, unfortunately

Android support. v7.60 Plus Account Phone: Google - bluejay - Pixel 6a - bluejay Podcast: https://play.pocketcasts.com/podcasts/6502f720-729a-0139-3455-0acc26574db2/af2e6a0e-46e2-4dd5-b7a9-88e23098287a?t=0

azollafox commented 6 months ago

This app used to be a favourite of mine. So much so I’m still using it in the hope they will finally get round to fixing a known issue where the audio will randomly skip back 20 seconds or so multiple time per podcast. It’s infuriating and I’m sick of it. Every update I hope it will be fixed but it’s just not happening. Ready to move to overcast or some other player.

May 10, 2024 Version 7.62.1

https://appstoreconnect.apple.com/WebObjects/iTunesConnect.woa/ra/ng/app/414834813/ios/ratingsResponses?reviewId=11252846334

erricgunawan commented 5 months ago

Playback Skipping but otherwise good

I’ve been using Pocket Casts for years and overall it is a good app. However i often experience an issue where the playback skips ahead a minute or 2 and then cuts the end off by the same amount. I thought this might be a problem caused at source but it happens on different podcasts so it must be a bug on the app itself.

Jun 2, 2024 Version 7.64

8274543-zen (3-star iOS App Review)

joashrajin commented 1 month ago

Skipping during podcasts. Repeats sections.

8774546-zd-a8c

erricgunawan commented 1 month ago

Jumps forwards and backwards

While playing my podcasts, it always skips forward or backwards. Does it multiple times a podcast and almost every podcast. Very annoying when listening to 6-8 podcasts a day.

Oct 8, 2024 Version 7.73

8853283-zen (1-star iOS App Review)

erricgunawan commented 1 month ago

I’ve tested it out a few times. It’s not quite as bad but still skips around when I try to fast forward past as breaks.

Version 7.73

8853858-zen

erricgunawan commented 1 month ago

The interface is great, easy to navigate and lots of options - so much better an Apple Podcasts. BUT it skips way too often

8897055-zen - 2-star iOS App Review - Version 7.74

mdrockwell commented 3 weeks ago

If I use the skip fwd/bk buttons while listening to a podcast with ads then later it involuntarily skips back on its own once or more and it effectively cuts off the end of the episode? It happens to me nearly every time.

8891290-zd-a8c

joashrajin commented 3 days ago

This issue was occurring for all podcasts, although I have found that downloading the episode beforehand seems to eliminate the issue. Ideally this would not be necessary so I hope y'all can fix it but appreciate you reaching out.

9016273-zd-a8c