search

AxLabs / grantshares

GrantShares Program 🌱
https://grantshares.io
Apache License 2.0
22 stars 3 forks source link

NEO CREW3 ACCOUNT #74

Open grantshares-dapp[bot] opened 1 year ago

grantshares-dapp[bot] commented 1 year ago

Abstract

Neo Crew3 account https://crew3.xyz that can help Neo to receive a great amount of content and retweets from the people.

Proposal Information

Description

Set a Crew3 account for Neo that can help Neo to receive a great amount of content and retweets from the people on social media (Twitter, Instagram..)

Creation of different daily, weekly and monthly missions, quizzes, medium articles for helping people to understand Neo's ecosystem. There will be XPs and we can set a leaderboard (every month pay some GAS for first 3 positions).

We can also set a team for reviewing quests and for approving or rejecting the content created by people.

Motivation

Set Crew3 account and for creating quiz, reviewing tasks, monthly pay for people.

Goals: Reaching more people on social media with this organic type of marketing.

How would you bring value to the community? Because this can be a great method for growing on social media and people will have fun creating every time different content to share on social media.

Deliverables & Roadmap

Specify deliverables in detail, including the following info for each:

I can set everything in 2 weeks.

Deliverables Verifiability

How would the community be able to verify that the promised deliverables (or milestones) were successfully achieved? With Crew3 account leaderboard and with a creation of a topic in NEO Discord channel

Budget Plan

About You / Your Organization

Short-Bio

Worked in a different blockchain projects (marketing and test). For Neo's projects I've created Lyrebird Discord channel and helped the project (moderator)

I've created quizzes for Humswap project (find-pita), you can check it on Discord.

Proposal Info :clipboard:

[ {
  "target_contract" : "0x6276c1e3a68280bc6c9c00df755fb691be1162ef",
  "method" : "releaseTokens",
  "params" : [ {
    "type" : "Hash160",
    "value" : "d2a4cff31913016155e38e474a2c06d08be276cf"
  }, {
    "type" : "Hash160",
    "value" : "9c13582e34c82ac34b0247cd0848b742e43d9275"
  }, {
    "type" : "Integer",
    "value" : "100000000000"
  } ],
  "call_flags" : 15
} ]

👇 React with 👍 if you liked it, or 👎 if you think this proposal can be enhanced!

gsmachado commented 1 year ago

@piergin why did you create a new proposal, instead of editing the other one in https://grantshares.io/app/details/738656940a1de3619a1126d06014501a ?

piergin commented 1 year ago

Because I didn't receive answers anymore.

Il giorno mar 28 mar 2023 alle ore 11:27 Guil. Sperb Machado < @.***> ha scritto:

@piergin https://github.com/piergin why did you create a new proposal, instead of editing the other one in https://grantshares.io/app/details/738656940a1de3619a1126d06014501a ?

— Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/AxLabs/grantshares/issues/74#issuecomment-1486517098, or unsubscribe https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/A6TMWIFI3MLHHYFJM3C5EHLW6KVJ3ANCNFSM6AAAAAAWKJCIVE . You are receiving this because you were mentioned.Message ID: @.***>

gsmachado commented 1 year ago

@piergin can you please withdraw your last proposal, then?

Follow these steps, please:

Then, only the new proposal is valid and all the focus will come here.

piergin commented 1 year ago

Done

Il giorno mar 28 mar 2023 alle ore 11:41 Guil. Sperb Machado < @.***> ha scritto:

@piergin https://github.com/piergin can you please withdraw your last proposal, then?

Follow these steps, please:

  • Go to your old proposal https://grantshares.io/app/details/738656940a1de3619a1126d06014501a
  • Make sure you are logged in with your GitHub Account (click on the button "Connect to GitHub", on the top-right corner). If you see your GitHub avatar it means you're already connected to GitHub.
  • You will see a button, on the right column, called "Withdraw Proposal". Click on this button.

Then, only the new proposal is valid and all the focus will come here.

— Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/AxLabs/grantshares/issues/74#issuecomment-1486536581, or unsubscribe https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/A6TMWICG4V7LBQDESP4PVUDW6KW33ANCNFSM6AAAAAAWKJCIVE . You are receiving this because you were mentioned.Message ID: @.***>

gsmachado commented 1 year ago

@piergin since the first proposal, when I commented this, I can't understand what you're trying to achieve.

My more specific questions are:

  1. Why Crew3 is a platform that would help us? What's their impact?
  2. Why should we invest in this? What's the gap you're trying to bridge?
  3. What's the expected return/outcome of this proposal in metrics (something that we can measure)?

Can you please clarify?

piergin commented 1 year ago
  1. Why Crew3 is a platform that would help us? What's their impact? Crew3 is a platform that can help Neo to grow and bring people from Twitter, Instagram and other social media. It's very easy to use and can allow people to create content and being rewarded for doing so. Airdrops, testnets and quests are one of the main reason why people are on Twitter and for what I'm seeing they share original content if they will be rewarded BUT, of course just if the content will be approved by us. Organic marketing.
  2. Why should we invest in this? What's the gap you're trying to bridge? For what I can see Neo has the tech and it could be one of the best out there but it lacks people engagement and contents. Very few people share Neo's tweets and this is not good because there is no engagement from people. Crew3 can allow to bring people to this project and help it. I'm trying to increase the participation in NEO blockchain with this tool.
  3. What's the expected return/outcome of this proposal in metrics (something that we can measure)? We can proceed with testing it and evaluate it, for what I saw in other projects the amount of active people has increased and not just a bit. Couple of months of hard work will bring people for sure but we need to start as soon as we can because other projects are a bit ahead.

Hope that now is clear, let me know.

Il giorno mar 28 mar 2023 alle ore 11:52 Guil. Sperb Machado < @.***> ha scritto:

@piergin https://github.com/piergin since the first proposal, when I commented this https://github.com/AxLabs/grantshares/issues/67#issuecomment-1477875108, I can't understand what you're trying to achieve.

My more specific questions are:

  1. Why Crew3 is a platform that would help us? What's their impact?
  2. Why should we invest in this? What's the gap you're trying to bridge?
  3. What's the expected return/outcome of this proposal in metrics (something that we can measure)?

Can you please clarify?

— Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/AxLabs/grantshares/issues/74#issuecomment-1486551690, or unsubscribe https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/A6TMWIHZPNTEPMEMS3Q2C43W6KYFHANCNFSM6AAAAAAWKJCIVE . You are receiving this because you were mentioned.Message ID: @.***>

piergin commented 1 year ago

Hi, Do you have any news?

Il giorno mar 28 mar 2023 alle ore 12:42 r c @.***> ha scritto:

  1. Why Crew3 is a platform that would help us? What's their impact? Crew3 is a platform that can help Neo to grow and bring people from Twitter, Instagram and other social media. It's very easy to use and can allow people to create content and being rewarded for doing so. Airdrops, testnets and quests are one of the main reason why people are on Twitter and for what I'm seeing they share original content if they will be rewarded BUT, of course just if the content will be approved by us. Organic marketing.
  2. Why should we invest in this? What's the gap you're trying to bridge? For what I can see Neo has the tech and it could be one of the best out there but it lacks people engagement and contents. Very few people share Neo's tweets and this is not good because there is no engagement from people. Crew3 can allow to bring people to this project and help it. I'm trying to increase the participation in NEO blockchain with this tool.
  3. What's the expected return/outcome of this proposal in metrics (something that we can measure)? We can proceed with testing it and evaluate it, for what I saw in other projects the amount of active people has increased and not just a bit. Couple of months of hard work will bring people for sure but we need to start as soon as we can because other projects are a bit ahead.

Hope that now is clear, let me know.

Il giorno mar 28 mar 2023 alle ore 11:52 Guil. Sperb Machado < @.***> ha scritto:

@piergin https://github.com/piergin since the first proposal, when I commented this https://github.com/AxLabs/grantshares/issues/67#issuecomment-1477875108, I can't understand what you're trying to achieve.

My more specific questions are:

  1. Why Crew3 is a platform that would help us? What's their impact?
  2. Why should we invest in this? What's the gap you're trying to bridge?
  3. What's the expected return/outcome of this proposal in metrics (something that we can measure)?

Can you please clarify?

— Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/AxLabs/grantshares/issues/74#issuecomment-1486551690, or unsubscribe https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/A6TMWIHZPNTEPMEMS3Q2C43W6KYFHANCNFSM6AAAAAAWKJCIVE . You are receiving this because you were mentioned.Message ID: @.***>

gsmachado commented 1 year ago

Crew3 is a platform that can help Neo to grow and bring people from Twitter, Instagram and other social media. It's very easy to use and can allow people to create content and being rewarded for doing so. Airdrops, testnets and quests are one of the main reason why people are on Twitter and for what I'm seeing they share original content if they will be rewarded BUT, of course just if the content will be approved by us. Organic marketing.

☝️ about this: yes, sure, I understand the idea.

Crew3 can allow to bring people to this project and help it. I'm trying to increase the participation in NEO blockchain with this tool. [...] We can proceed with testing it and evaluate it, for what I saw in other projects the amount of active people has increased and not just a bit. Couple of months of hard work will bring people for sure but we need to start as soon as we can because other projects are a bit ahead.

☝️ about this: do you have any traction number from other spaces? Like, how many people engaged in other spaces/projects since they started, and any metrics?! Maybe, can you approach someone and ask?

Besides my questions above, why don't you edit the proposal and add these information? The proposal description is poor compared to other proposals we received.

I would suggest that you follow my previous advice and edit the proposal with more content, a better plan what you will do (specifically) with the money, etc.

At this stage, I think that the investment of 1000 GAS is a bit too high for, maybe, little return. I'm not exactly sure, but that's my gut feeling. Maybe because the proposal didn't provide much detail, is not polished enough, and also you didn't add any track record from past work.

Thanks 🙏 and looking forward to your comments.

gsmachado commented 1 year ago

Maybe some other people from the community can give their opinions here.

@DylanNNT, @deanragnarok

deanragnarok commented 1 year ago

I am aligned with @gsmachado. My confidence on the ability of the proposal to deliver is very much influenced by the detail and specificity of the proposal itself. You really should endeavor to preempt the types of questions that the GrantShares voting members will ask and try to provide that information upfront. The fact that the proposal didn't even describe what Crew3 was and that there is no clear metrics / goals for the endeavor gives me the impression that there isn't really a plan here other than to use Crew3.

Every time a proposal is funded through GrantShares we all take a leap of faith. As a proposer, it's up to you to make the leap manageable by giving us some degree of confidence on where we are going to land. I encourage you to reevaluate your proposal come back with a much clearer plan, with actionable items, schedules, budget breakdown, etc, and anything else that would help understand your ability to create missions, quizzes, Medium articles etc.

Just by being here you've already taken the first step to doing something constructive for the Neo community, so don't be disheartened. I think we all want to see initiatives like the one you are describing, but as it stands we just do not have a clear picture of how you intend to action it.