Azgaar / Fantasy-Map-Generator

Web application generating interactive and highly customizable maps
https://azgaar.github.io/Fantasy-Map-Generator
Other
4.55k stars 647 forks source link

App deskop #1090

Closed c0ncentus closed 2 months ago

c0ncentus commented 3 months ago

Problem

I really don't understand how to edit region on editor (even I understand it, the web is not suitable for that)

Solution

I suggest Tauri.

Web is useful making random things and shareable, and quick. App will be usefull for editing.

Alternatives

put button icons for showing/hiding element I think about warcraft III map edior is really old but still nice

DeuzeksMcKinna commented 3 months ago

"Region" is not an identifier of any element on this tool (except for States in the code). Please be specific about what element you're having issues with.

Azgaar commented 3 months ago

Hello @c0ncentus, what do you mean by "the web is not suitable for that"? I'm not sure I follow. It's a web tool, it will always be web (even if you wrap it in Tauri).

c0ncentus commented 3 months ago

https://www.koombea.com/blog/web-apps-vs-desktop-apps/ for exemple when I want edit my picture I use on local environment only (no real advantages of web apps except IA stuff because some commercial usage I guess).

Web app are suitable making blog, articles, sharing stuff, commercial usage.

so no suitable for fantazy map editor because you generate-configure/edit/load and that's all.

smartphone's app with same usage on the web are useless

"It's a web tool,"=> more an editor than a tool ? philosophical question I guess. yah it's on web (factual).

when I have this for seeing what I can done, i read/use 10% I can do because too complex for me or just a tons of tons of words compacting and deversity of abstractions on compacting buttons with different usage, I must everytime remember what buttons for what usage, just painfull.

image

I should learn this tool more than "use for learn". It's the reasons, I suggest icons.

For exemple as a newbee I explore 70%-80% (warcraft 3 map editor) of all features even if sometimes I really don't understand what it means (exemple table of number on specific UI) , when you click on specific icon, a specific popup with specific data related to the icon. image

you have also palette wich means like select brush and apply what you desire image

more visual are welcomed than tons of word compacting in small area.

DeuzeksMcKinna commented 3 months ago

Then rebuild it to your liking, it's open source.

Azgaar commented 3 months ago

@c0ncentus, that's your opinion, I have a different one. I use web apps for the majority of tasks, I edit photos using photopea.com, optimize them using tinypng.com, have online dev board, store my git online, and so on.

As for the icons and the UI, it has nothing to do with being web or not. I can build the same UI as on the screenshots, but I don't like it and in any case it's just too much work.