Azgaar / Fantasy-Map-Generator

Web application generating interactive and highly customizable maps
https://azgaar.github.io/Fantasy-Map-Generator
Other
4.59k stars 657 forks source link

Religion editor (brush) not following borders #745

Open leontrague opened 2 years ago

leontrague commented 2 years ago

Description

It looks like the religion brush don't follow borders properly. See in the enclosed screenshot: image This is a zoomed view, and I used the smallest available brush but it still went over the edges. If the brush editor for religions is strictly the same as for cultures, then this issue may be related to the latest updates because I used the culture brush two weeks ago and it worked fine.

Steps to reproduce

Expected behaviour

The religion area should not go over the border.

Actual behaviour

Currently, it's impossible to remove the "small patches of religion" that went over the border, because they're too small for the brush tool.

.map file

The issue is on the bottom left corner, in the islands. Tirula 2022-02-21-11-44.zip

Generator version

v1.732

Browser version

Firefox 97.0.1 (x64)

Azgaar commented 2 years ago

Hello. That usually happens in case of incorrect map data. Can you please check on a new map and also after the Heightmap edit in Risk mode?

leontrague commented 2 years ago

Ok, it looks like it works properly on a new map. Where do I find the heightmap editor in risk mode?

Azgaar commented 2 years ago

Tools -> Heightmap -> Risk

leontrague commented 2 years ago

Thanks, so I went into risk mode, immediately exited it and tried to correct the religion border, no luck. I tried again and changed some height, but still no luck.

leontrague commented 2 years ago

Furthermore, this part of the map was an imported image. Maybe this could be the problem? I didn't have it on a new map with an imported image though.

leontrague commented 2 years ago

So I found a way to get this right, by editing the state edges: it's now aligned with the religion borders. It worked on this island, not on another (smaller) one where I use provinces borders to delimit religions. Edit : when reloading the map from the saved file, the religion limits don't align any more. Do you have a solution please? :(

schizoidnightmares commented 2 years ago

This happens inconsistently for me too. I haven't seen any evidence this is caused by map file corruption. The borders draw themselves properly after selecting the religion in the editor. However there is still some "bleed." Seems to be a rendering or drawing problem.

Azgaar commented 1 year ago

Is it still hapenning?

leontrague commented 1 year ago

Yes it does, unfortunately. I just tried using the latest version of the tool and it keeps not following borders :(