search

AztecProtocol / dev-rel

All of Aztec's workshops, resources, tutorials, ideas, and useful tools
43 stars 17 forks source link

Check EVM chains for Noir Solidity verifier compatibility #255

Closed critesjosh closed 3 months ago

critesjosh commented 5 months ago

Mark each with ✅ or ❌

  1. Tron
  2. BSC
  3. Arbitrum
  4. Blast
  5. Base
  6. Merlin
  7. Avalanche
  8. Polygon
  9. Optimism
  10. Cronos

related to: https://github.com/noir-lang/noir/issues/4964

critesjosh commented 5 months ago

The quickest way to test might be to get the default Solidity verifier, paste it into remix, deploy to a corresponding testnet and try to verify a proof, or James suggestion of writing a script

Savio-Sou commented 4 months ago

On further research, it's probably best to exclude Tron as it is not nor is it aiming to be Ethereum EVM compatible: https://developers.tron.network/docs/tvm#differences-from-evm

As of now then the top 10 EVMs by TVL list becomes:

  1. BSC
  2. Arbitrum
  3. Blast
  4. Base
  5. Merlin
  6. Polygon (PoS)
  7. Avalanche
  8. Optimism
  9. Linea
  10. Mode
signorecello commented 4 months ago

So we're tackling:

I would recommend using volume instead of TVL, although on DefiLlama it only gives us 24h volume. In any case seems like the resulting list would probably be more in line with what people are using

Savio-Sou commented 4 months ago

24h volume sounds easily fluctuating due to e.g. campaigns, short-term sentiments, etc.

If we have a reliable data source of for example 30d volume, that could be a good metric to switch over for; otherwise starting with TVL seems simplest.