Azure-Samples / cognitive-services-speech-sdk

Sample code for the Microsoft Cognitive Services Speech SDK
MIT License
2.95k stars 1.86k forks source link

es-ES Not show phoneme #2345

Closed hiddow closed 5 months ago

hiddow commented 6 months ago

Is your feature request related to a problem? Please describe. Currently, Azure Speech Assessment provides valuable insights into pronunciation accuracy, but it can be challenging for language learners focusing on Spanish (es-ES) to pinpoint the exact phonemes where they may be struggling. Detailed phoneme-level feedback would significantly enhance the learning process.

Describe the solution you'd like I would like Azure Speech Assessment to include a detailed breakdown of the output at the phoneme level for Spanish (es-ES) assessments. This would involve:

Individual Phoneme Scores: Assign accuracy ratings (e.g., Correct, Substitution, Deletion, Insertion) to each phoneme within the assessed text. Visual Representation: Provide a clear visual representation of this breakdown, potentially highlighting problematic phonemes for quick identification.

Describe alternatives you've considered Manual Phonetic Analysis: It's possible to manually transcribe the audio using the International Phonetic Alphabet (IPA) and compare against a reference, but this is extremely time-consuming and requires specialized knowledge. Third-Party Tools: There are some limited phonetic analysis tools, but integrating this functionality within Azure's suite would be far more streamlined.

Additional context Detailed phoneme-level feedback has the potential to greatly benefit:

Spanish Language Learners: Allows users to target specific areas of pronunciation difficulty, leading to more focused and effective practice. Language Instructors: Provides actionable data for lesson planning and individualized pronunciation guidance.

image
jpalvarezl commented 6 months ago

Hello @hiddow thank you for using the SDK. As you may be aware currently es-ES is not part of the supported languages for this feature.

I will notify the feature team for this area to review the issue and they will evaluate, given their current roadmap and resources, whether this can be moved into active development.

yulin-li commented 6 months ago

@wangkenpu could you check?

wangkenpu commented 6 months ago

It's by design. For new feature requests, please fill Microsoft Forms. After you submit the form, our team will contact you in 2 weeks.

github-actions[bot] commented 5 months ago

This item has been open without activity for 19 days. Provide a comment on status and remove "update needed" label.

pankopon commented 5 months ago

Closed as by design.

fabswt commented 2 months ago

People really like getting pronunciation feedback on Gliglish.com for en-US (I'm using Azure's Pronunciation Assessment), but I cannot extend it to more languages without phoneme-level data.

It's a little absurd to offer phoneme-level scores without phoneme-level data.

I submitted a response to the form mentioned above.