BIAPT / AEC-wPLI-comparison

This repository is for the study of AEC vs wPLI and their relation to the classification of consciousness
2 stars 2 forks source link

Investigate the difference between the wPLI code we are using and the other we were using previously #24

Closed yacineMahdid closed 4 years ago

yacineMahdid commented 4 years ago

We are having some issue with the analysis and it might be due by the wPLI generation part. I need to create an experiment where we can see the difference between the two approach given the same dataset.

Attempt 1

When we are using the weighted phase lag index we get (with a step size of 1 seconds): Unconscious:

Pre-ROC:

Attempt 2

When we are using PLI only (without surrogate correction and with a step size of 5 seconds) Unconscious

Pre-ROC:

Attempt 3

When we are using PLI only (without surrogate correction and with a step size of 1 seconds) Unconscious

Pre-ROC:

Attempt 4

Redo the analysis with Jason matrices (still looking for how they were generated) Unconscious

Pre-ROC:

Attempt 5

Redo the analysis with the code used by Jason to generate the matrices

Pre-ROC:

Attempt 6

Redo the analysis with Lucrezia code + surrogate correction

Pre-ROC:

yacineMahdid commented 4 years ago

I've found the source of the difference, we just now need to fix it. I'll do a series of bug fix in order to get it right and document it.

yacineMahdid commented 4 years ago

The source of the discrepancy is that Jason used PLI + surrogate analysis with wPLI. Which doesn't hold very well theoretically.