BIOL548O / Discussion

A repository for course discussion in BIOL548O
0 stars 0 forks source link

Finding data for AlexdeBruyn #9

Closed aammd closed 8 years ago

aammd commented 8 years ago

Hello @AlexdeBruyn,

In the pre-course survey, you indicated that you don't have any data. Experience with real data is more useful to you than working through exercises with your own messy data. Therefore, I wanted to have a discussion with you about what kind of data you might be able to use.

Here are some suggestions (ranked very loosely from most to least helpful):

If none of the above datasets work, we'll have to find something else. This could be a part of the Kaggle dataset, the candy dataset, or some other random dataset you enjoy. I could also give you some of my own data which are still unpublished.

Which of these options appeals most to you? Let's try to figure this out by Thursday.

Andrew

AlexdeBruyn commented 8 years ago

I've got a bunch of data showing relative abundances of different orders of insect at different experimental sites that I collected for my undergraduate thesis. Could that potentially work?

Date: Mon, 8 Feb 2016 22:59:05 -0800 From: notifications@github.com To: Discussion@noreply.github.com CC: alex_debruyn@hotmail.com Subject: [Discussion] Finding data for AlexdeBruyn (#9)

Hello @AlexdeBruyn,

In the pre-course survey, you indicated that you don't have any data. Experience with real data is more useful to you than working through exercises with your own messy data. Therefore, I wanted to have a discussion with you about what kind of data you might be able to use.

Here are some suggestions (ranked very loosely from most to least helpful):

Data from a pilot experiment

Data from your supervisor / collaborator / senior grad student (assure them that these data will remain confidential and unpublished)

Data from any previous degree you've done (Honours / Masters). This would be especially useful to you if the data are unpublished (even if the paper is published)

Published data from a paper in your field

Data emailed to you from an author in your field

Data (relevant to your work) obtained from the Web -- ie from a data archive or elsewhere. If you know where to look, i can help you get it.

Plan B

If none of the above datasets work, we'll have to find something else. This could be a part of the Kaggle dataset, the candy dataset, or some other random dataset you enjoy. I could also give you some of my own data which are still unpublished.

Which of these options appeals most to you? Let's try to figure this out by Thursday.

Andrew

— Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub.

aammd commented 8 years ago

relative abundances of different orders of insect at different experimental sites

I mean, relative abundances of insects are my favourite so yes, I support this :100: % That said, do you have the original, raw, count data? That would be even more fun than the relative abundances (by which I assume you mean the total abundance of each species, divided by the total abundance of all species)

AlexdeBruyn commented 8 years ago

Ironically enough for the theme of this course, I don't think I have the digitized data on my curent computer. I'll look through my old emails to see if I can find it in any attachments. However, I can get my parents back home to look at my lab notebook and re-send me the data set.

Date: Tue, 9 Feb 2016 05:37:11 -0800 From: notifications@github.com To: Discussion@noreply.github.com CC: alex_debruyn@hotmail.com Subject: Re: [Discussion] Finding data for AlexdeBruyn (#9)

relative abundances of different orders of insect at different experimental sites

I mean, relative abundances of insects are my favourite so yes, I support this %

That said, do you have the original, raw, count data? That would be even more fun than the relative abundances (by which I assume you mean the total abundance of each species, divided by the total abundance of all species)

— Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub.

aammd commented 8 years ago

Sounds good. Ideally you'd have it by Thursday, which is when we're going to start work on our individual projects. If that seems unworkable, do you have a backup option? I'm sure I could find you some insect count data somewhere, though it might be pretty gnarly :stuck_out_tongue_winking_eye:

aammd commented 8 years ago

Hey Alex. This choice of data sounds great for the course. The table of different insect orders that you showed me earlier looks to me like a summary of the original data. i imagine that you collected these insects in a series of samples. Do you have that raw data, showing which insects are found in which sample?

aammd commented 8 years ago

@AlexdeBruyn any luck finding those original data, at the sample level? Just curious :smile_cat:

AlexdeBruyn commented 8 years ago

Each site is actually a single giant sample, collected over a 24 hour period. So yes, one single sample gathered over 2000 flies into a small bottle of alcohol, hahah. The dataset that I have provided contains all of the original information, just converted from tally marks to numbers. The bit of data I am trying to add in is the subset of Ichneumonid Wasps collected from Tagish II, which I identified to the family level.

aammd commented 8 years ago

Awesome! :bug: :bee: :ant: :beetle:

Closing now because it sounds like you are sorted