aammd
commented
8 years ago organization
Did your reviewee follow the directory naming convention that we are using? Was it easy to find the different R scripts?
YOUR WORDS HERE
documentation
Review the code that performs the assertions. Are the comments in the code readable? Are there any lines of code that appear without any description of what they are doing?
YOUR WORDS HERE
Assertions
what things does your reviewee test for in the assertions? Is anything missing? Suggest an improvement to their quality control
YOUR WORDS HERE
Metadata (two parts)
clear and human-readable
Is the metadata thorough? When, where and how was this work done? Do you have any questions about what the data mean?
YOUR WORDS HERE
correct and machine-readable
Choose one from below (depending on what your reviewee has done) and describe how to fix any problems you find:
EML-- use the functioneml_read()from theEMLpackage. Will it read into R?csvy-- copy and paste the YAML information into this validator and click "Validate".datapackage-- copy and paste thedatapackage.jsonfile into this validator and click "Validate"
YOUR WORDS HERE
Reuse your colleagues data
Do something with your reviewee's data! Write an R script that reads the data in, then does something. Don't forget to write comments!
Paste the entire R script you wrote below, inside a fenced code block
If you've made a plot, you can add that in a separate comment
YOUR CODE HERE
_what follows below is an example only! don't copy and paste this, but rather the relevant template from the course website, like this one_
Hello @%s,
You've been assigned to conduct the final Peer Review for @%s ! Here are the steps you should follow:
Step 1: Clone your reviewee's repo to your computer. You can do this via Rstudio, following the steps from our github lecture
Step 2: Go to the Peer Review Instructions and copy and paste the outline into a comment on this issue (or, to be safe, into your favourite text editor first, THEN paste it below when you are done!).
Step 3: Submit the marks that go with your review with this form
Thank you for your review, and for an excellent class! :smile_cat: @aammd