BUGS-NYU / nyu-cs-wiki

The go-to guide for NYU CS students
https://nyucswiki.com
Creative Commons Attribution Share Alike 4.0 International
4 stars 19 forks source link

Content License #79

Closed sachiniyer closed 8 months ago

sachiniyer commented 9 months ago

Is the content also licensed by MIT?

As I understand it, licensing the content under MIT, means anyone can take the content without attribution. You can address this one thing specifically with the MIT with attribution license.

However, Creative Commons licensing has a ton more stuff about creative works specifically (e.g. DRM).

I would propose keeping code licensed under MIT, while licensing the content under CC (something like BY-SA or BY-NA-SA). This has been done in many other projects (e.g. privacy guides license chooser...)

aminoa commented 9 months ago

Thanks for pointing this out - I think CC BY-SA is a good fit for the project. Also, I'd like to relicense this project to use GPLv3 (the standard license chosen for BUGS projects).

sachiniyer commented 9 months ago

Effects of different licenses with examples

Effects of BY

Action Decision
Attribution :white_check_mark:
Stays CC :x:
Other Colleges :white_check_mark:
Other OS projects :white_check_mark:
Proprietary Projects :white_check_mark:
Proprietary LLMS :white_check_mark:
Open Source LLMS :white_check_mark:

Effects of BY-NC

Action Decision
Attribution :white_check_mark:
Stays CC :x:
Other Colleges :white_check_mark:
Other OS projects :white_check_mark:
Proprietary Projects :x:
Proprietary LLMS :x:
Open Source LLMS :white_check_mark:

Effects of BY-SA

Action Decision
Attribution :white_check_mark:
Stays CC :white_check_mark:
Other Colleges :white_check_mark:
Other OS projects :white_check_mark:
Proprietary Projects :white_check_mark:
Proprietary LLMS :white_check_mark:
Open Source LLMS :white_check_mark:

Effects of BY-NC-SA

Action Decision
Attribution :white_check_mark:
Stays CC :white_check_mark:
Other Colleges :white_check_mark:
Other OS projects :white_check_mark:
Proprietary Projects :x:
Proprietary LLMS :x:
Open Source LLMS :white_check_mark:
aminoa commented 9 months ago

Ah thanks, appreciate the reference. I made a forum post in the BUGS Discord to open up discussion to more community members.

sachiniyer commented 8 months ago

Closing, as I now see a license in the repo.