Bali10050 / Lightly

A modern style for qt applications.
Other
111 stars 7 forks source link

Figure out a new name #40

Open TKK13909 opened 2 weeks ago

TKK13909 commented 2 weeks ago

It's probably time to actually decide on a new name for this project before it gains any more traction. Whether it's Darkly, Brightly, or you just decide to keep the original one. I'm willing to help with the name transition once the decision gets made.

Bali10050 commented 2 weeks ago

I think Darkly sounds the best, but I'm interested in @DeltaCopy's opinion too, because he has probably spent at least as much time on this project as me, with probably better coding skills than me. Also, if we rename the project we can close #10 pretty quickly. It looks like ./kstyle/lightly.json changes the name that shows up in the system settings, but I haven't yet found what else needs to be changed to make it work, and I don't know how I can rename everything at once

DeltaCopy commented 1 week ago

Darkly misconstrued may mean a darker orientated style which it isn't. Although I am not good with coming up with names, I think that an original name would be better suited. We already have Lightly, Glassly, Klassly .. For inspiration maybe looking at the style contrast between Breeze and Lightly may help. The minimalist, clean, and yet still modern looks this application style offers. breathe, liquid, fluid, zenith, clarity comes to mind.

Whatever is chosen there will be several activities required to reflect the name change

TKK13909 commented 1 week ago

You mentioned 'Clarity' and that gave me an idea. I know some other projects that use Esperanto words for their name (Forgejo is the only one coming to mind at the moment) and the Esperanto word for Clarity is 'Klareco' which incidentally starts with a K like a lot of other stuff in the KDE world.

Just a thought...

By the way, @Bali10050, do you want to use this issue for brainstorming or would you prefer some other method?

Bali10050 commented 1 week ago

By the way, @Bali10050, do you want to use this issue for brainstorming or would you prefer some other method?

If it works, don't fix it

Also, the name will be decided by the first person who finds out how to properly rename the project, because I have failed miserably in that part.

DeltaCopy commented 1 week ago

Can you elaborate on what you mean by:

how to properly rename the project

The repository itself, as well as all the assets inc. the src code cmake build files etc.. ?

Bali10050 commented 1 week ago

Can you elaborate on what you mean by:

how to properly rename the project

I haven't found out yet what needs to be renamed for it to not only show up in the system settings, but to make it actually selectable, and to make the default lightly installable alongside it.

DeltaCopy commented 1 week ago

Looking at how Klassy style works will help as it references a lot of Breeze code but still manages to have a different name. I've just renamed Lightly to Zen as a POC and it works.

Having both Lightly and this new name installed in parallel sounds too difficult to maintain in the long-term. There are multiple files which require updating including CMakeLists.txt files to reflect the new name.

To give you an idea here are some of them.

  modified:   CMakeLists.txt
  modified:   kstyle/CMakeLists.txt
  modified:   kstyle/config/CMakeLists.txt
  modified:   kstyle/config/lightlystyleconfig.cpp
  modified:   kstyle/config/lightlystyleconfigmodule.cpp
  modified:   kstyle/config/main.cpp    
  modified:   kstyle/lightlystyle.cpp
  modified:   kstyle/lightlystyleconfigdata.kcfgc
  modified:   kstyle/lightlystyleplugin.cpp
  modified:   kstyle/lightlystyleplugin.h
  modified:   liblightlycommon/CMakeLists.txt

rename

Bali10050 commented 1 week ago

I created a Rename branch as a first step