Closed N6REJ closed 3 months ago
β±οΈ Estimated effort to review: 2 π΅π΅βͺβͺβͺ |
π§ͺ No relevant tests |
π No security concerns identified |
β‘ Key issues to review Consistency Issue The exclusion list in the `Util::clearFolder` call for logs includes '.gitignore', which is inconsistent with the user description stating that '.gitignore' should not be deleted. Please verify if this is intended or an oversight. |
Category | Suggestion | Score |
Error handling |
Implement error handling for folder clearing operations___ **Add error handling for theUtil::clearFolder method to manage cases where the folder path might be incorrect or permissions are insufficient.** [core/classes/actions/class.action.clearFolders.php [44]](https://github.com/Bearsampp/sandbox/pull/48/files#diff-cfbca2eae07cd2bbbecf11139dc0e2583cdbcf5d89c6a4e491e9b5d6464eaf96R44-R44) ```diff -Util::clearFolder($bearsamppRoot->getLogsPath(), array('mailpit.err.log', 'mailpit.out.log', 'memcached.err.log', 'memcached.out.log', 'xlight.err.log', 'xlight.log', '.gitignore')); +if (!Util::clearFolder($bearsamppRoot->getLogsPath(), array('mailpit.err.log', 'mailpit.out.log', 'memcached.err.log', 'memcached.out.log', 'xlight.err.log', 'xlight.log', '.gitignore'))) { + error_log('Failed to clear logs folder.'); +} ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 10Why: Adding error handling is crucial for robustness, ensuring that issues with folder paths or permissions are logged and managed appropriately. This significantly improves the reliability of the code. | 10 |
Possible issue |
Ensure consistent use of constants or strings for 'Mailpit'___ **Ensure that the 'Mailpit' class constant is consistently used or declared. In theprevious code, 'Mailpit' appears without quotes, suggesting it might be intended as a constant. If it's a string, it should be quoted.** [core/classes/actions/class.action.clearFolders.php [41]](https://github.com/Bearsampp/sandbox/pull/48/files#diff-cfbca2eae07cd2bbbecf11139dc0e2583cdbcf5d89c6a4e491e9b5d6464eaf96R41-R41) ```diff -Util::clearFolder($bearsamppRoot->getTmpPath(), array('cachegrind', 'composer', 'openssl', 'mailhog', Mailpit, 'xlight', 'npm-cache', 'pip', 'yarn', '.gitignore')); +Util::clearFolder($bearsamppRoot->getTmpPath(), array('cachegrind', 'composer', 'openssl', 'mailhog', 'Mailpit', 'xlight', 'npm-cache', 'pip', 'yarn', '.gitignore')); ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 9Why: This suggestion addresses a potential bug where 'Mailpit' might be intended as a constant but is used without quotes. Ensuring consistency can prevent runtime errors and improve code clarity. | 9 |
Enhancement |
Abstract the list of files to clear into a configurable property or method___ **Consider abstracting the list of file types and logs to clear into a configurationfile or a class property, which can be easily updated without modifying the method directly.** [core/classes/actions/class.action.clearFolders.php [44]](https://github.com/Bearsampp/sandbox/pull/48/files#diff-cfbca2eae07cd2bbbecf11139dc0e2583cdbcf5d89c6a4e491e9b5d6464eaf96R44-R44) ```diff -Util::clearFolder($bearsamppRoot->getLogsPath(), array('mailpit.err.log', 'mailpit.out.log', 'memcached.err.log', 'memcached.out.log', 'xlight.err.log', 'xlight.log', '.gitignore')); +$filesToClear = $this->getFilesToClear(); // This method would retrieve the array from a config or property +Util::clearFolder($bearsamppRoot->getLogsPath(), $filesToClear); ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 8Why: Abstracting the list of files into a configuration file or class property enhances flexibility and maintainability. It allows updates without modifying the method directly, which is beneficial for larger projects. | 8 |
Maintainability |
Use a variable to store log file names for better maintainability___ **Consider using a variable to store the array of log files to be cleared. This willmake the code cleaner and easier to maintain, especially if the list of log files changes in the future.** [core/classes/actions/class.action.clearFolders.php [44]](https://github.com/Bearsampp/sandbox/pull/48/files#diff-cfbca2eae07cd2bbbecf11139dc0e2583cdbcf5d89c6a4e491e9b5d6464eaf96R44-R44) ```diff -Util::clearFolder($bearsamppRoot->getLogsPath(), array('mailpit.err.log', 'mailpit.out.log', 'memcached.err.log', 'memcached.out.log', 'xlight.err.log', 'xlight.log', '.gitignore')); +$logFiles = array('mailpit.err.log', 'mailpit.out.log', 'memcached.err.log', 'memcached.out.log', 'xlight.err.log', 'xlight.log', '.gitignore'); +Util::clearFolder($bearsamppRoot->getLogsPath(), $logFiles); ``` - [ ] **Apply this suggestion** Suggestion importance[1-10]: 7Why: This suggestion improves code maintainability by storing the log file names in a variable, making it easier to update the list in the future. However, it is a minor enhancement and not critical for functionality. | 7 |
User description
To Test: Generate logs. use clear temp function and verirfy all logs except mailpit, memcached & xlight are deleted and .gitignore is not.
PR Type
enhancement
Description
clearFolders
action withinclass.action.clearFolders.php
.mailpit.err.log
,mailpit.out.log
,memcached.err.log
,memcached.out.log
,xlight.err.log
,xlight.log
,.gitignore
) that should not be deleted.Changes walkthrough π
class.action.clearFolders.php
Add log clearing functionality to clearFolders action
core/classes/actions/class.action.clearFolders.php
clearFolders
action.