search

Beep6581 / RawTherapee

A powerful cross-platform raw photo processing program
https://rawtherapee.com
GNU General Public License v3.0
2.92k stars 326 forks source link

Samsung Expert Raw format DNG 1.7 #7028

Open moonraver opened 7 months ago

moonraver commented 7 months ago

Please implement new DNG 1.7 format. People with Samsung Galaxy devices can not read and edit files captured with Expert Raw since January 2024.

Details here: https://r2.community.samsung.com/t5/CamCyclopedia/JPEG-XL-Image-Codec/ba-p/15356525.

Thank you very much.

Lawrence37 commented 7 months ago

Do you have an appropriately-licensed sample file?

moonraver commented 7 months ago

Sorry, I don't know what appropriately-licensed sample file is. I only have my pictures shot with my phone. Link is above.

Lawrence37 commented 7 months ago

We need an image with a license that permits us to use it to add support for the format. Since you own the images, it is enough to say that you are providing the image for the purpose of adding support in RawTherapee.

Where are the images? The link you provided goes to an article about JPEG XL.

moonraver commented 7 months ago

Sorry, my mistake. Here is the link to my 2 files captured with my Samsung Galaxy S23+: https://ufile.io/f/l7c8i

Lawrence37 commented 7 months ago

Thanks. I have downloaded the files

bereldhuin commented 2 months ago

Hi,

do you have any news on this issue ?

moonraver commented 2 months ago

no, nothing. Still the same.

Acrivec commented 1 month ago

I've spent an hour fighting with RawTherapee that wasn't even detecting the dng file in my folder, let alone opening it. Thank you for fixing my brain. Good to know that new .dng profile in S23U is not recognized in, apparently, lots of software.

Lawrence37 commented 1 month ago

The file browser only shows files that can be read and decoded. It is intended to prevent unsupported images and non-image files from cluttering the browser.

Acrivec commented 1 month ago

The file browser only shows files that can be read and decoded. It is intended to prevent unsupported images and non-image files from cluttering the browser.

It would be nice if the browser could add some kind of, I dunno, red exclamation mark in a triangle on the thumbnail placeholder to let the user know that "I know the file is there, but I can't read it properly!" or something. Just to save time for people who, like me, spent a lot of time not understanding why on earth the filetype that's supported isn't visible on the file list.

Lawrence37 commented 1 month ago

However, the file type is not supported. There are several versions of dng, and 1.7 is an unsupported version.

Acrivec commented 1 month ago

However, the file type is not supported. There are several versions of dng, and 1.7 is an unsupported version.

Filetype IS supported. New version of it is not. That's a difference. It should be treated the same way as a damaged file.

Lawrence37 commented 1 month ago

It is a distinct file type from a decoding and support perspective.

It should be treated the same way as a damaged file.

But it's not damaged, so why tell the user that the file is bad when it's not?

Sciencentistguy commented 2 weeks ago

Worth noting that in the mean time, the Adobe DNG Converter tool can be used to convert the JXL-based DNGs to an older (larger) file, which can then be opened by RawTherapee.