The paper titled “A Comprehensive Study for Stillbirth” provides an analysis of stillbirth trends in Toronto from 2011 to 2023 using various analytical methods.
Strong Positive Points
The dataset chosen is relevant and interesting.
The data is presented in well-organized, easy-to-read charts.
Critical Improvements Needed
The paper lacks an abstract and introduction, which are essential for guiding readers. These sections would provide a clear overview of the research objective and context.
The scripts for data simulation, collection, and cleaning are not included. Without these, the paper is not reproducible, which is a critical issue for the validity of the research.
A README file is missing, making it difficult for readers and users to understand the contents of the repository. This is essential for both accessibility and transparency.
Suggestions for Improvement
If any large language models were used during the research, it is recommended to include a usage statement and list the prompts used. This adds clarity on how AI tools influenced the research.
Including more references and relevant literature would strengthen the research by providing better support for the findings and situating the study within the broader academic context.
Please Consider Adding/Changing/Removing
Change figure and section references from default text to more descriptive labels. This improves readability and professionalism.
Adding a discussion section would help cover the broader implications of the research, data, and findings, and it would allow for further research.
Evaluation
R is appropriately cited - 1
LLM usage is documented - 0
Title - 1
Author, date, and repo - 2
Abstract - 0
Introduction - 0
Data - 4
Measurement – 4
Cross-references - 2
Prose - 2
Graphs/tables/etc. - 2
Referencing - 3
Commits - 0
Sketches - 0
Simulation - 0
Tests - 0
Reproducibility - 0
Code style - 0
General excellence – 1
Overall score = 24/64
Reason
The paper is missing many critical elements and lacks essential details. Key sections, such as R scripts and code, are not included, making the paper incomplete. While the title is provided and the data is visualized using various charts, several sections are absent, and there is minimal content related to the research process itself.
Opening Statement Summary
The paper titled “A Comprehensive Study for Stillbirth” provides an analysis of stillbirth trends in Toronto from 2011 to 2023 using various analytical methods.
Strong Positive Points
Critical Improvements Needed
Suggestions for Improvement
Please Consider Adding/Changing/Removing
Evaluation
R is appropriately cited - 1 LLM usage is documented - 0 Title - 1 Author, date, and repo - 2 Abstract - 0 Introduction - 0 Data - 4 Measurement – 4 Cross-references - 2 Prose - 2 Graphs/tables/etc. - 2 Referencing - 3 Commits - 0 Sketches - 0 Simulation - 0 Tests - 0 Reproducibility - 0 Code style - 0 General excellence – 1
Overall score = 24/64
Reason
The paper is missing many critical elements and lacks essential details. Key sections, such as R scripts and code, are not included, making the paper incomplete. While the title is provided and the data is visualized using various charts, several sections are absent, and there is minimal content related to the research process itself.