search

BenedictBCJJ / pe

0 stars 0 forks source link

Empty group still exist after deleting all members #10

Open BenedictBCJJ opened 3 years ago

BenedictBCJJ commented 3 years ago

This behaviour is not specified in the DG not sure if it should behave like this image.png

nus-pe-bot commented 3 years ago

Team's Response

Thank you for your feedback. The team has reviewed this report and decided that this is not an issue.

Reason: The behaviour of deleting a person should not cause the deletion of a group.

Elaboration: Since the deletion of a person in the UG did not specify whether it will cause the deletion of a group if the deleted person was the only person in the group, the behaviour shown should be expected. We believe that deleting a group if a person was to be deleted to be more of the exceptional case. Hence no extra documentation should be needed to explain the behaviour above.

This behaviour is also justified as the user may want the group to still exist despite having no persons in it i.e to add more persons into the group afterwards.

Items for the Tester to Verify

:question: Issue response

Team chose [response.Rejected]

Reason for disagreement: This is a documentation bug, since it is not specified in the UG and we cannot determine if this is the expected behaviour or the behaviour is unexpected to the user. For example the user wants to delete some users and the users all happen to be in a group or a bunch of groups, the user might think that deleting all user would delete the group too but ends up with a bunch of empty groups instead.

e.g A B C D E are the groups and a is in A, b is in B and so on. User wants to delete A, B, C and a, b, c and figures that deletings users instead of, group then users, would be faster as the group would be deleted too, he deletes a, b, c. Now he is left with group A, B, C that he no longer uses.