Closed ponderingdemocritus closed 3 months ago
The latest updates on your projects. Learn more about Vercel for Git โ๏ธ
Name | Status | Preview | Comments | Updated (UTC) |
---|---|---|---|---|
eternum | โ Ready (Inspect) | Visit Preview | ๐ฌ Add feedback | Jun 25, 2024 3:55am |
โฑ๏ธ Estimated effort to review [1-5] | 4 |
๐งช Relevant tests | No |
๐ Security concerns | No |
โก Key issues to review |
Possible Bug: The new CSS class .clip-squared-top defined in tailwind.config.js might have an incorrect polygon definition. The coordinates provided seem to form an incomplete polygon which might not render as expected. It's advisable to review and test this specific shape to ensure it meets the intended design requirements. |
Code Duplication: The button toggle for showing battle details has been implemented twice in Battle.tsx . Consider refactoring to avoid duplication and maintain cleaner code. | |
Styling Consistency: The changes in BattleActions.tsx introduce different icon sizes and border styles which might affect the visual consistency across the application. Ensure that these changes align with the overall design system. | |
Performance Concern: The EntityAvatar.tsx now calculates an avatar index based on the address prop. This operation is performed every time the component renders, which could be optimized by memoizing the result to avoid unnecessary recalculations. |
Category | Suggestion | Score |
Enhancement |
Improve alt text descriptions for better accessibility___ **The alt attribute for images should provide meaningful descriptions rather than just"coin". This improves accessibility and SEO.** [client/src/ui/modules/military/battle-view/BattleActions.tsx [151]](https://github.com/BibliothecaDAO/eternum/pull/1004/files#diff-a2b38e5f9c040c3591adb945a143c3fe234beb433a77a677a8d069ea47a6a462R151-R151) ```diff - + ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 9Why: The suggestion enhances accessibility and SEO by providing meaningful alt text, which is crucial for usability and search engine optimization. | 9 |
Simplify gradient calculation in the useMemo hook___ **The gradient calculation in the useMemo hook can be simplified by directly using thepercentages without recalculating them.** [client/src/ui/modules/military/battle-view/BattleProgressBar.tsx [62-67]](https://github.com/BibliothecaDAO/eternum/pull/1004/files#diff-f9a547b6a282b885d288bf085e915af12ff12ce991fc19051cff70106c89c9deR62-R67) ```diff const gradient = useMemo(() => { - const attackPercentage = parseFloat(attackingHealthPercentage); - const defendPercentage = parseFloat(defendingHealthPercentage); - return `linear-gradient(to right, #582C4D ${attackPercentage}%, #582C4D ${attackPercentage}%, #6B7FD7 ${attackPercentage}%, #6B7FD7 ${ - attackPercentage + defendPercentage + return `linear-gradient(to right, #582C4D ${attackingHealthPercentage}%, #582C4D ${attackingHealthPercentage}%, #6B7FD7 ${attackingHealthPercentage}%, #6B7FD7 ${ + parseFloat(attackingHealthPercentage) + parseFloat(defendingHealthPercentage) }%)`; }, [attackingHealthPercentage, defendingHealthPercentage]); ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 6Why: The suggestion simplifies the gradient calculation, improving code readability and maintainability. However, the improvement is relatively minor. | 6 | |
Add conditional rendering for
___
**Consider adding a conditional rendering or a visibility toggle for | 6 | |
Syntax |
Clean up CSS syntax by removing duplicated semicolons___ **Remove the duplicated semicolons in the CSS class definitions to clean up the syntax andprevent potential CSS parsing errors.** [client/src/index.css [223-230]](https://github.com/BibliothecaDAO/eternum/pull/1004/files#diff-9ba564eb566d9d518337365ff59440cd64b7217d0ddb75f1c2524003735b99adR223-R230) ```diff .ornate-borders-y { border-top: none; - border-left: 15px solid transparent;; - border-right: 15px solid transparent;; + border-left: 15px solid transparent; + border-right: 15px solid transparent; border-bottom: none; -moz-border-image: url("/border-2.png") 30 30 round; /* Old firefox */ -webkit-border-image: url("/border-2.png") 30 30 round; /* Safari */ -o-border-image: url("/border-2.png") 30 30 round; /* Opera */ border-image: url("/border-2.png") 30 30 round; } ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 9Why: Removing duplicated semicolons in CSS is important for preventing potential parsing errors and maintaining clean syntax. The suggestion accurately identifies and corrects the issue. | 9 |
Possible issue |
Correct the polygon points for better shape rendering___ **The polygon definition for ".clip-squared-top" seems incorrect as it specifies only fivepoints, which might not render as expected. Consider revising the polygon points to ensure it forms a complete shape.** [client/tailwind.config.js [230-231]](https://github.com/BibliothecaDAO/eternum/pull/1004/files#diff-c161da30d9a464d0e8adede24e77041c08ea806f0ea5e7547344f60a2e0099fcR230-R231) ```diff ".clip-squared-top": { - clipPath: "polygon(0 0, 100% 0, 100% 100%, 0 100%, 10% 10%)", + clipPath: "polygon(0 0, 100% 0, 100% 100%, 0 100%, 0 0)", } ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 8Why: The suggestion correctly identifies a potential rendering issue with the polygon definition and provides a fix to ensure the shape is complete. This is important for visual consistency. | 8 |
Maintainability |
Standardize the application of CSS classes across similar components___ **Ensure consistency in the use of CSS classes forTroopCard components. The class w-1/3 is applied directly in some instances and conditionally in others. Consider refactoring to maintain a consistent approach.** [client/src/ui/modules/military/battle-view/Troops.tsx [16-26]](https://github.com/BibliothecaDAO/eternum/pull/1004/files#diff-91a2d2f8f54e7a7655eb1a9a90930dd08eee7b9fa3063d3a5847fa77486da641R16-R26) ```diff Suggestion importance[1-10]: 8Why: Ensuring consistency in the use of CSS classes improves code readability and maintainability. The suggestion correctly identifies the inconsistency and proposes a standardized approach. | 8 |
Remove unnecessary whitespace in the className attribute___ **TheclassName attribute in the motion.div tag has an extra space at the end which should be removed to maintain clean code standards.** [client/src/ui/modules/military/battle-view/Battle.tsx [59]](https://github.com/BibliothecaDAO/eternum/pull/1004/files#diff-02b2d9dfda96c1b646f0988359539b6a4cc61edaaaeaa8705cffc5d705b4d37dR59-R59) ```diff -className="absolute bottom-0 " +className="absolute bottom-0" ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 7Why: The suggestion improves code cleanliness by removing unnecessary whitespace, which is good for maintainability, though it is a minor issue. | 7 | |
Remove commented-out conditional rendering code for clarity___ **Consider removing the commented-out conditional rendering code for better code clarity andmaintainability. If the feature is no longer needed, it's best to remove it entirely.** [client/src/ui/modules/military/battle-view/Troops.tsx [9-13]](https://github.com/BibliothecaDAO/eternum/pull/1004/files#diff-91a2d2f8f54e7a7655eb1a9a90930dd08eee7b9fa3063d3a5847fa77486da641R9-R13) ```diff -{/* {noArmy ? ( -
- No defending Army!. The residents are shaking in terror.
-
-) : ( */}
+{/* Conditional rendering removed for clarity */}
```
Suggestion importance[1-10]: 7Why: Removing commented-out code can improve code clarity and maintainability, but it is not a critical change. The suggestion correctly identifies the commented-out code and proposes its removal. | 7 |
User description
PR Type
Enhancement
Description
.clip-squared-top
intailwind.config.js
.TopLeftContainer
inWorld
layout.Battle
.BattleActions
.BattleDetails
.BattleProgressBar
.EntityAvatar
inBattleSideView
.EntityAvatar
.LockedResources
.TopScreenView
.Troops
.SettingsWindow
fromLeftNavigationModule
.SettingsWindow
toTopLeftNavigation
.TopMiddleNavigation
.index.css
.Changes walkthrough ๐
15 files
tailwind.config.js
Added new clipPath class `.clip-squared-top`.
client/tailwind.config.js - Added new CSS class `.clip-squared-top` with a specific clipPath.
World.tsx
Repositioned `TopLeftContainer` in `World` layout.
client/src/ui/layouts/World.tsx
TopLeftContainer
to a different position in the JSX structure.Battle.tsx
Added toggle button and updated styles in `Battle`.
client/src/ui/modules/military/battle-view/Battle.tsx
BattleActions.tsx
Updated button styles and images in `BattleActions`.
client/src/ui/modules/military/battle-view/BattleActions.tsx
outline
.BattleDetails.tsx
Simplified CSS classes in `BattleDetails`.
client/src/ui/modules/military/battle-view/BattleDetails.tsx - Simplified CSS classes for `BattleDetails`.
BattleProgressBar.tsx
Refactored gradient logic and updated styles in `BattleProgressBar`.
client/src/ui/modules/military/battle-view/BattleProgressBar.tsx
BattleSideView.tsx
Updated layout and added `EntityAvatar` in `BattleSideView`.
client/src/ui/modules/military/battle-view/BattleSideView.tsx
EntityAvatar
with address prop.EntityAvatar.tsx
Added address prop and updated image logic in `EntityAvatar`.
client/src/ui/modules/military/battle-view/EntityAvatar.tsx
EntityAvatar
.LockedResources.tsx
Updated layout and styles in `LockedResources`.
client/src/ui/modules/military/battle-view/LockedResources.tsx - Updated layout and CSS classes for `LockedResources`.
TopScreenView.tsx
Added ornate borders to `TopScreenView`.
client/src/ui/modules/military/battle-view/TopScreenView.tsx - Added ornate borders to `TopScreenView`.
Troops.tsx
Updated styles in `Troops`.
client/src/ui/modules/military/battle-view/Troops.tsx - Updated CSS classes for `TroopRow` and `TroopCard`.
LeftNavigationModule.tsx
Removed `SettingsWindow` from `LeftNavigationModule`.
client/src/ui/modules/navigation/LeftNavigationModule.tsx - Removed `SettingsWindow` component.
TopLeftNavigation.tsx
Added `SettingsWindow` to `TopLeftNavigation`.
client/src/ui/modules/navigation/TopLeftNavigation.tsx - Added `SettingsWindow` component.
TopMiddleNavigation.tsx
Updated styles in `TopMiddleNavigation`.
client/src/ui/modules/navigation/TopMiddleNavigation.tsx - Updated CSS classes for `TopMiddleNavigation`.
index.css
Added new ornate border styles.
client/src/index.css - Added new ornate border classes.