Closed cwastche closed 1 week ago
vercel[bot]
commented
1 week ago The latest updates on your projects. Learn more about Vercel for Git ↗︎
| Name | Status | Preview | Comments | Updated (UTC) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| eternum | ✅ Ready (Inspect) | Visit Preview | 💬 Add feedback | Jul 2, 2024 3:03pm |
github-actions[bot]
commented
1 week ago | ⏱️ Estimated effort to review [1-5] | 4 |
| 🧪 Relevant tests | No |
| 🔒 Security concerns | No |
| ⚡ Key issues to review |
Possible Bug: The removal of the |
|
Redundancy and Maintenance: The introduction of tableOfContents in multiple components could be refactored into a more centralized approach to avoid redundancy and ease future maintenance. | |
|
Performance Concern: The dynamic generation of components and frequent use of map in rendering methods (e.g., in Combat.tsx and Resources.tsx) could lead to performance issues, especially if these components are re-rendered often. |
github-actions[bot]
commented
1 week ago | Category | Suggestion | Score |
| Enhancement |
Replace fragment shorthand with a
___
**Replace the fragment shorthand ( | 9 |
| Possible bug |
Enhance key uniqueness to prevent rendering issues___ **To avoid potential issues with key uniqueness which can lead to rendering bugs, considerusing a more unique key for the list items in the HyperstructureConstructionTable. Currently, the key is based on the index, which might not be unique if the data changes. A combination of resource ID and index could be a better choice.** [client/src/ui/components/hints/WorldStructures.tsx [114-118]](https://github.com/BibliothecaDAO/eternum/pull/1059/files#diff-fd691959c413d4c715c44e2aef3397de6ab93b337cdd8761faec5332a080d9d6R114-R118) ```diff {constructionCost.slice(colIndex * 6, (colIndex + 1) * 6).map((cost, index) => ( -
+ Suggestion importance[1-10]: 9Why: Using a more unique key for list items helps prevent potential rendering bugs. This is crucial for ensuring the stability and correctness of the component's rendering logic. | 9 |
| Performance |
Optimize rendering by memoizing the static data array___ **Consider using React's useMemo hook to optimize the rendering of theconcepts array. This array is derived from static data and does not change unless the component re-renders for other reasons. By memoizing it, you can avoid unnecessary recalculations and re-renders.** [client/src/ui/components/hints/WorldStructures.tsx [14-32]](https://github.com/BibliothecaDAO/eternum/pull/1059/files#diff-fd691959c413d4c715c44e2aef3397de6ab93b337cdd8761faec5332a080d9d6R14-R32) ```diff -const concepts = [ +const concepts = useMemo(() => [ { name: "Hyperstructures", content: ( <>
Naturally occurring structures discovered during exploration, enabling players to harvest precious resources
from the world.
),
},
-];
+], []);
```
Suggestion importance[1-10]: 8Why: Using React's useMemo hook to memoize the static data array can improve performance by preventing unnecessary recalculations and re-renders. This is a significant optimization for components that rely on static data. | 8 |
| Accessibility |
Improve accessibility by using semantic HTML tags___ **To improve accessibility and semantic HTML structure, replace the genericdiv elements with section tags in the component rendering. This change will help screen readers and other assistive technologies better understand the structure of the page.** [client/src/ui/components/hints/WorldStructures.tsx [42-47]](https://github.com/BibliothecaDAO/eternum/pull/1059/files#diff-fd691959c413d4c715c44e2aef3397de6ab93b337cdd8761faec5332a080d9d6R42-R47) ```diff {concepts.map((concept) => ( -
+
+
))}
```
{concept.name}{concept.content} -Suggestion importance[1-10]: 7Why: Replacing generic div elements with section tags enhances the semantic structure of the HTML, which improves accessibility for screen readers and other assistive technologies. This is a good practice for better accessibility. | 7 |
| Maintainability |
Break down large JSX blocks into smaller components for better readability and maintainability___ **To improve the readability and maintainability of the JSX code, consider breaking down thelarge JSX blocks into smaller, more manageable components. This will make the code easier to understand and maintain, especially as the application scales.** [client/src/ui/components/hints/WorldStructures.tsx [37-49]](https://github.com/BibliothecaDAO/eternum/pull/1059/files#diff-fd691959c413d4c715c44e2aef3397de6ab93b337cdd8761faec5332a080d9d6R37-R49) ```diff return ( <>
-
- ))}
+ {concepts.map((concept) => {concept.name}- {concept.content} -
+
+);
+
```
{concept.name}+ {concept.content} +Suggestion importance[1-10]: 6Why: Breaking down large JSX blocks into smaller components improves code readability and maintainability. While this is beneficial, it is a minor improvement compared to performance or bug fixes. | 6 |
PR Type
Enhancement, Documentation
Description
SelectPreviewBuildingMenucomponent by removing redundantdivwrapper.Buildingshints.Combathints content withHeadline,tableOfContents, and expanded concepts.GettingStartedhints withtableOfContentsand expanded content on key concepts.Hyperstructuressection toWorld StructuresinHintModal.Hyperstructurescomponent.Resourceshints withtableOfContentsand reorganized content on resource production and storage.TheMaphints withtableOfContentsand expanded content on exploration and travel costs.Tradinghints withHeadline,tableOfContents, and expanded content on marketplace and AMM.Transporthints withHeadline,tableOfContents, and expanded content on transport and donkeys.WorldStructurescomponent with detailed tables for Hyperstructure creation and construction costs.tableOfContentsfor generating a table of contents.classNameprop toEntityListfor additional styling flexibility.hintSectionprop toOSInterfaceandOSWindowcomponents.SecondaryPopup.Headto includeHintModalButtonifhintSectionis provided.HintModalButtonfromLeaderboardPanel.HintModalButtontoWorldStructuresMenu.Changes walkthrough 📝
12 files
SelectPreviewBuilding.tsx
Simplify SelectPreviewBuildingMenu component structureclient/src/ui/components/construction/SelectPreviewBuilding.tsx
divwrapper aroundHintModalButtonandTabs.utils.tsx
Add utility function for table of contentsclient/src/ui/components/hints/utils.tsx
tableOfContentsfor generating a table ofcontents.
EntityList.tsx
Add className prop to EntityList componentclient/src/ui/components/list/EntityList.tsx
classNameprop toEntityListfor additional styling flexibility.Config.tsx
Add hintSection prop to OSInterfaceclient/src/ui/components/navigation/Config.tsx - Added `hintSection` prop to `OSInterface`.
OSWindow.tsx
Enhance OSWindow with hintSection prop and HintModalButtonclient/src/ui/components/navigation/OSWindow.tsx
hintSectionprop toOSWindowcomponent.SecondaryPopup.Headto includeHintModalButtonifhintSectionis provided.
LeaderboardPanel.tsx
Remove HintModalButton from LeaderboardPanelclient/src/ui/components/worldmap/leaderboard/LeaderboardPanel.tsx - Removed `HintModalButton` from `LeaderboardPanel`.
SecondaryPopup.tsx
Update SecondaryPopup.Head to include HintModalButtonclient/src/ui/elements/SecondaryPopup.tsx
SecondaryPopup.Headto includeHintModalButtonifhintSectionis provided.
Guilds.tsx
Add hintSection prop to OSWindow in Guilds componentclient/src/ui/modules/guilds/Guilds.tsx - Added `hintSection` prop to `OSWindow` in `Guilds` component.
LeaderBoard.tsx
Add hintSection prop to OSWindow in Leaderboard componentclient/src/ui/modules/leaderboard/LeaderBoard.tsx - Added `hintSection` prop to `OSWindow` in `Leaderboard` component.
Military.tsx
Add className prop to EntityList in Military componentclient/src/ui/modules/military/Military.tsx - Added `className` prop to `EntityList` in `Military` component.
BottomNavigation.tsx
Update conditions for showing leaderboard and guilds buttonsclient/src/ui/modules/navigation/BottomNavigation.tsx
quest status.
WorldStructuresMenu.tsx
Add HintModalButton to WorldStructuresMenuclient/src/ui/modules/world-structures/WorldStructuresMenu.tsx - Added `HintModalButton` to `WorldStructuresMenu`.
10 files
Buildings.tsx
Remove storage of food section from Buildings hintsclient/src/ui/components/hints/Buildings.tsx - Removed the section on storage of food.
Combat.tsx
Enhance and restructure Combat hints contentclient/src/ui/components/hints/Combat.tsx
HeadlineandtableOfContentsfor better structure.GettingStarted.tsx
Improve GettingStarted hints with table of contents and expandedcontentclient/src/ui/components/hints/GettingStarted.tsx
tableOfContentsfor better navigation.HintModal.tsx
Rename Hyperstructures section to World Structures in HintModalclient/src/ui/components/hints/HintModal.tsx - Renamed `Hyperstructures` section to `World Structures`.
Hyperstructures.tsx
Remove Hyperstructures componentclient/src/ui/components/hints/Hyperstructures.tsx - Removed the entire Hyperstructures component.
Resources.tsx
Enhance Resources hints with table of contents and reorganized contentclient/src/ui/components/hints/Resources.tsx
tableOfContentsfor better navigation.TheMap.tsx
Improve TheMap hints with table of contents and expanded contentclient/src/ui/components/hints/TheMap.tsx
tableOfContentsfor better navigation.Trading.tsx
Enhance Trading hints with table of contents and expanded contentclient/src/ui/components/hints/Trading.tsx
HeadlineandtableOfContentsfor better structure.Transport.tsx
Improve Transport hints with table of contents and expanded contentclient/src/ui/components/hints/Transport.tsx
HeadlineandtableOfContentsfor better structure.WorldStructures.tsx
Add new WorldStructures component with detailed tablesclient/src/ui/components/hints/WorldStructures.tsx
costs.