search

BiodiversityOntologies / bco

Biological Collections Ontology
Creative Commons Zero v1.0 Universal
22 stars 3 forks source link

Project to add sites and site-visits #82

Closed dr-shorthair closed 6 years ago

dr-shorthair commented 6 years ago

We are looking at making some extensions to accommodate ecological observations. These tend to be organized around sites. Those sometimes host instruments ERO_0000004 for continuous monitoring, but more often are associated with site-visits during which one or more observations are made BCO_0000003 or specimens collected OBI_0000659. An ecological observations site (the place you drive or walk to) often has sub-sites, plots, quadrats, traps, transects (where the technical work is done).

We expect that this will involve

My hunch is that this all fits nicely in the scope of BCO, but will work in a new namespace if that is preferred.

Meanwhile, I'll have to brush up on my Protege skills as I'm normally a TopBraid user ;-)

pbuttigieg commented 6 years ago

Linking to revisions in ENVO to support environmental monitoring and related processes.

a small number of sub-classes of site BFO_0000029

ENVO has the environmental zone branch which may be useful for these. It specifies the BFO:site and uses subclass axioms to express what physical entities it overlaps. We'd be happy to host any classes you need, linking back to your ORCID and project identifiers.

pbuttigieg commented 6 years ago

@dr-shorthair @ramonawalls

I think BCO should have classes under an ecosystem observation class, axiomatised with ENVO's ecosystem. This can be specified quite systematically using other environments or environmental zones.

The visiting of sites could be seen as part of an observation process, but I think it's more natural to have them as upstream events in a larger planned process.

I was thinking of adding this to ENVO, but BCO is the better home for this. I also have no objection to moving environmental monitoring et al. to BCO. This may help modularlisation efforts (@cmungall )

ramonawalls commented 6 years ago

Well, @dr-shorthair, we can't all afford such fancy software! Actually, I hope to move to a more automated build process at some point soon, which should allow new terms to be created outside Protege.

I agree that BCO is a good place to host classes for ecological observations. My concern is that the phrase is extremely broad, and could encompass all kinds of observations for many different purposes. @pbuttigieg 's suggestion for ecosystem observations is a good start at being more specific, but it may not encompass everything that you have in mind.

Note that bco observing process is not restricted to human observations, and can include observations by machine sensors.

Regarding things like site visits, I would love to expand on those further. We have some really simple (i.e. not logically defined) classes for taxonomic observing process that include the idea of site visits, so we could use the logic there as well. People are getting more interested in using Darwin core to describe various sampling and observing protocols, so the time is right to get these semantics worked out.

@dr-shorthair, when you are ready to dive into this, let me know if you want to set up a call.

dr-shorthair commented 6 years ago

may not encompass everything that you have in mind

I will be guided by actual practice here. We are primarily wanting to capture the processes used in (often state agency based) surveys, monitoring and campaigns. We have a lot of data to test it against.

Some of these practices feature dependencies between site-visits and observations that are not necessarily interesting scientifically, but are useful for management and discovery. RO_0002427 causally downstream of or within might be used to link observation and specimen collection processes to a site-visit. Not sure that scenario was envisaged by @cmungall though ...

dr-shorthair commented 6 years ago

OK @ramonawalls @pbuttigieg @robgur - I'm ready to dive in. With our geographic distribution, I suspect 20:00 UTC is the only practical time for a call.

ramonawalls commented 6 years ago

Thanks, @dr-shorthair. Back from vacation and recovering from my cold, so I'm also ready to dive it.

@pbuttigieg Can you do 20:00 UTC (21:00 CET, I guess) any day in the coming week? @robgur That is 4PM for you. Which days are you available (or not).

I can do any day between now and 9/21 at that time except Monday 9/17 and Thursday 9/20 (presumably 1 day later for Simon). If we can't all make it, we'll start with just Simon and I.

robgur commented 6 years ago

I will try to make it. -r

On Tue, Sep 11, 2018 at 2:15 PM Ramona Walls notifications@github.com wrote:

Thanks, @dr-shorthair https://github.com/dr-shorthair. Back from vacation and recovering from my cold, so I'm also ready to dive it.

@pbuttigieg https://github.com/pbuttigieg Can you do 20:00 UTC (21:00 CET, I guess) any day in the coming week? @robgur https://github.com/robgur That is 4PM for you. Which days are you available (or not).

I can do any day between now and 9/21 at that time except Monday 9/17 and Thursday 9/20 (presumably 1 day later for Simon). If we can't all make it, we'll start with just Simon and I.

— You are receiving this because you were mentioned. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/BiodiversityOntologies/bco/issues/82#issuecomment-420369595, or mute the thread https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AAcc7Ah4oVCzcfO9GaBRQk1BxqjL652fks5uZ_3bgaJpZM4WG-Zb .

dr-shorthair commented 6 years ago

Wednesday, Thursday and Friday (actually Thursday, Friday and Saturday ;-) ) no good for me. , so it'd best be Tuesday (Wednesday) at 20:00 UTC. I'll send an invitation.

tucotuco commented 6 years ago

I'm still lost in NZ but should be unlost by the 18th, Argentina time. May I please be included in the invitation as well?

On 12:15, Wed, Sep 12, 2018 Simon Cox notifications@github.com wrote:

Wednesday, Thursday and Friday (actually Thursday, Friday and Saturday ;-) ) no good for me. , so it'd best be Tuesday (Wednesday) at 20:00 UTC. I'll send an invitation.

— You are receiving this because you are subscribed to this thread. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/BiodiversityOntologies/bco/issues/82#issuecomment-420468699, or mute the thread https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AAcP6yD03-IVqiDiRm1KSbgXwIEYhhfFks5uaFIhgaJpZM4WG-Zb .

ramonawalls commented 6 years ago

Happy to have you on the call, John! I'll forward the invite to you.

Ramona

Ramona L. Walls, Ph.D. Senior Scientific Analyst, CyVerse, University of Arizona Research Associate, Bio5 Institute, University of Arizona

On Wed, Sep 12, 2018 at 3:00 PM John Wieczorek notifications@github.com wrote:

I'm still lost in NZ but should be unlost by the 18th, Argentina time. May I please be included in the invitation as well?

On 12:15, Wed, Sep 12, 2018 Simon Cox notifications@github.com wrote:

Wednesday, Thursday and Friday (actually Thursday, Friday and Saturday ;-) ) no good for me. , so it'd best be Tuesday (Wednesday) at 20:00 UTC. I'll send an invitation.

— You are receiving this because you are subscribed to this thread. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub < https://github.com/BiodiversityOntologies/bco/issues/82#issuecomment-420468699 , or mute the thread < https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AAcP6yD03-IVqiDiRm1KSbgXwIEYhhfFks5uaFIhgaJpZM4WG-Zb

.

— You are receiving this because you were mentioned. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/BiodiversityOntologies/bco/issues/82#issuecomment-420812101, or mute the thread https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/ADKDrrPwEU6g7nT7Rm5STAkjhu9xCtwwks5uaYPegaJpZM4WG-Zb .

dr-shorthair commented 6 years ago

Renamed this issue to reflect the fact that most of the chat is about project initiation and organizing a meeting. Assume we will create more detailed issues for substantive work.

pbuttigieg commented 6 years ago

Teleconference concluded with @ramonawalls @tucotuco @dr-shorthair and Guru in attendance. Further issues to address this use case will be posted on the BCO tracker and cross-linked with ENVO as needed. BCO will handle the semantics of the "visits" and ENVO of the "sites" (save for sites with fiat boundaries defined by acts of observation such as transects, which will reside in BCO).

robgur commented 6 years ago

Excellent outcome! Sorry to miss this...

On Tue, Sep 18, 2018 at 5:21 PM Pier Luigi Buttigieg < notifications@github.com> wrote:

Teleconference concluded with @ramonawalls https://github.com/ramonawalls @tucotuco https://github.com/tucotuco @dr-shorthair https://github.com/dr-shorthair and Guru in attendance. Further issues to address this use case will be posted on the BCO tracker and cross-linked with ENVO as needed. BCO will handle the semantics of the "visits" and ENVO of the "sites" (save for sites with fiat boundaries defined by acts of observation such as transects, which will reside in BCO).

— You are receiving this because you were mentioned. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/BiodiversityOntologies/bco/issues/82#issuecomment-422559897, or mute the thread https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AAcc7GlrJu_PvVLkUlD6511DNooBCMzwks5ucWO-gaJpZM4WG-Zb .

dr-shorthair commented 6 years ago

I'll close this issue, and get going with more atomic requests.