BiologicalRecordsCentre / UKBMS-online

Issue tracking for UKBMS online recording site
2 stars 0 forks source link

Registration emails #74

Closed IanMiddlebrook closed 6 years ago

IanMiddlebrook commented 6 years ago

Hi @BirenRathod

Several new registrants over the last couple of weeks say they have not received an email after registering for a new account on the UKBMS site. They've also tried requesting a new password and not received an email. I've mentioned that they might find the email in their SPAM/JUNK folder, but many fail to find anything in there either. Could we firstly check that all the emails are being sent out (I always seem to receive the notification, so that part is OK). Perhaps more importantly, If the emails are being sent out but not getting through, is there anything we can do to change the emails so that they are less likely to be blocked?

Thanks,

Ian

BirenRathod commented 6 years ago

Hello @IanMiddlebrook, @Gary-van-Breda , @DavidRoy

Due to some reason using any CEH email stop sending email outside. This could be due to our internal email security system in action. So I changed that to no-reply@ukbms.org and it works. so I left the setting like that. So user will get an email.

Also, I found there was no terms of condition page created. Because of that when every time new user registered, there was an error generated in the log. So I have created terms of use page. The page has got long list of text which might not require for UKBMS transact. please amend that to suitable text.

IanMiddlebrook commented 6 years ago

Thanks @BirenRathod The only problem now is that I've stopped receiving notifications when new accounts are set up. I used to receive them from brc@ceh.ac.uk and they were still coming through, but I see a few more (mostly spam) accounts have been set up in the last 3 hours, but I've not received any notification.

BirenRathod commented 6 years ago

Hello @IanMiddlebrook

I have now added brc@ceh.ac.uk email to user registration notification. So you should be receive that.

IanMiddlebrook commented 6 years ago

Hi @BirenRathod Sorry, I receive the notifications at imiddlebrook@butterfly-conservation.org . They used to come FROM brc@ceh.ac.uk

Thanks, Ian

IanMiddlebrook commented 6 years ago

Thanks @BirenRathod They're coming though now

IanMiddlebrook commented 6 years ago

Hi @BirenRathod
Just looking through the new registrations this morning, and it looks like I stopped receiving notification emails early this morning (after 3am) as there are a bunch of new accounts on the website that I've not received notification of. May just be a temporary problem, but it's ongoing.

@DavidRoy As an additional point, we've gone back to getting a lot of bogus/spam accounts now - dozens each day that I need to delete. Is there anything we could do to discourage this? For example, I'm sure they sign up for the forum, but is there any need for the forum to be visible to people before they login? I can't think of any, so if we removed the forum from the menu until people login I wonder if that would help?

thanks,

Ian

IanMiddlebrook commented 6 years ago

Sorry @BirenRathod I also see that none of the most recent registrations have accessed their accounts, so I assume they are not getting their registration emails either.

BirenRathod commented 6 years ago

@IanMiddlebrook

To block bogus/spam accounts, please chnage the settings in the "acccount settings" of "people" to "Visitors, but administrator approval is required"

About email, first try to create account by your self and see if you receive any email.

IanMiddlebrook commented 6 years ago

Hi @BirenRathod I've tried to create an account, and did not receive any email.

Re. blocking bogus accounts, that doesn't sound like it will reduce my workload - ie. will it actually reduce the number of people 'trying' to register.

BirenRathod commented 6 years ago

@IanMiddlebrook

I will look into email bit.

Neither it reduces your workload nor it will reduce number of people trying to register (email goes to you anyway) but it will definitely stop the bogus account.

IanMiddlebrook commented 6 years ago

Thanks @BirenRathod it looks like emails are coming through again. I just received a new notification, so I tried to set up a new account and the notification was received at my other email address.

Regarding the issue of junk accounts - my main objective was to reduce my workload dealing with them, which your suggestion doesn't achieve. I'll raise it in a separate issue.

Thanks again,

Ian

BirenRathod commented 6 years ago

No problem.

That's right. it will increase your workload. Other solution is to block them by using forum by Captcha. The site had already enabled this module, you just need to configure for forum. if you want let me know.

IanMiddlebrook commented 6 years ago

Thanks @BirenRathod at the moment, most of the spam accounts are not even using real email addressess, so they don't get on to the site or contribute to the forum. It's just a real pain coming in every moving to see dozens of emails about accounts that I then need to delete. I don't know if that's also a problem on iRecord?

BirenRathod commented 6 years ago

Yes, same problem of Drupal. iRecord has got spambot module running in the background.

BirenRathod commented 6 years ago

but that is not an ideal solution in your case as you need to active their account after every registration.

DavidRoy commented 6 years ago

Closing this as registration email issue now resolved. Spam account issue still to be address by #78