Insertions in ligatures won't work

[annplaksin]

There are problems with some things, that show up within ligatures and with insertions inside ligatures:

Test insertions within ligatures
<piece: {mensural: void}, {staf: 5, black}> 
<part: 1 >
<label>Inserted stuff</label>a
{clef: C8} Bd md{var=(ins.) "*" A} | Bd md{var=(ins.) "?" A} | Bd md{var=(ins.) "." A} | Bd {var=(ins.) "b9" A} md | Bd {var=(ins.) "{clef: C10}" A} md |
</part>
<part: 2 >
{staf: 5, black}
<label>Stuff in ligatures: Accidentals won't work - Clefs in ligatures break stuff </label>
{clef: C8}
<lig>Bd* Ba</lig> <lig><obl>Bd*11 Ba</obl></lig> |
<lig>Bd? Ba</lig> <lig><obl>Bd?11 Ba</obl></lig> |
<lig>Bd. Ba</lig> <lig><obl>Bd. Ba</obl></lig> |
<lig>Bd b9 Ba</lig> <lig><obl>Bd b9 Ba</obl></lig> |
<lig>Bd Ba</lig> {clef: C8} <lig><obl>Bd Ba</obl></lig>  |
</part>
<part: 3 >
{staf: 5, black}
<label>Insertion in ligatures -- are bad!</label>
{clef: C8}
<lig>Bd{var=(ins.) "*" A} Ba</lig> <lig><obl>Bd Ba</obl></lig> |
<lig>Bd{var=(ins.) "?" A} Ba</lig> <lig><obl>Bd Ba</obl></lig> |
<lig>Bd{var=(ins.) "." A} Ba</lig> <lig><obl>Bd. Ba</obl></lig> |
</part>
</piece>

[annplaksin]

Note: Inserted SG in Oblique in Tenor "Qui regnas in celestibus"... this is important!

[JohannesTinctoris]

It's looking good in Safari right now...

-jjd

---

Dr Jeffrey J. Dean PI, AHRC Mensural Notation Project 4 Chandos Road Royal Birmingham Conservatoire Chorlton-cum-Hardy tel: +44(0)161 861 7542 Manchester M21 0ST fax: +44(0)161 861 7543 England www.earlymusictheory.org/Tinctoris/ jeffrey.dean@bcu.ac.uk jeffrey.dean@stingrayoffice.com

On 13 Nov 2020, at 17:26, Anna Plaksin notifications@github.com wrote:

Note: Inserted SG in Oblique in Tenor "Qui regnas in celestibus"... this is important!

— You are receiving this because you are subscribed to this thread. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub, or unsubscribe.

[annplaksin]

It might be broken in a short while... I just pushed the custos and clef stuff... (but this wouldn't make any sense)

[annplaksin]

Okay, "Qui regnas in celestibus" was another bug only happening in Obliques. Insertions still don't work...

[annplaksin]

Okay... inserted SC in ligatures and obliques work.

Do we need to handle inserted fermatas, accidentals and dots for now? If not, we can reduce the priority for this issue. As far as I see, in Liber de Arte contrapuncti, this isn't the case, but I'd rather like to double check.

[JohannesTinctoris]

Brilliant timing! I was just about to confirm that everything looks good now, except for one tiny detail: in II.xxx.ex1, the second SC, beneath the breve, is placed too high, so it collides with the note.

I haven't noticed any faults with the other signs in De arte contrapuncti. I think these are things that crop up in the practical pieces; we can deal with them next year...

Best, Jeff

---

Dr Jeffrey J. Dean PI, AHRC Mensural Notation Project 4 Chandos Road Royal Birmingham Conservatoire Chorlton-cum-Hardy tel: +44(0)161 861 7542 Manchester M21 0ST fax: +44(0)161 861 7543 England www.earlymusictheory.org/Tinctoris/ jeffrey.dean@bcu.ac.uk jeffrey.dean@stingrayoffice.com

On 20 Nov 2020, at 15:42, Anna Plaksin notifications@github.com wrote:

Okay... inserted SC in ligatures and obliques work.

Do we need to handle inserted fermatas, accidentals and dots for now? If not, we can reduce the priority for this issue. As far as I see, in Liber de Arte contrapuncti, this isn't the case, but I'd rather like to double check.

— You are receiving this because you commented. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub, or unsubscribe.

[annplaksin]

You should be able to change the position of the SC manually...

[JohannesTinctoris]

Done...

---

Dr Jeffrey J. Dean PI, AHRC Mensural Notation Project 4 Chandos Road Royal Birmingham Conservatoire Chorlton-cum-Hardy tel: +44(0)161 861 7542 Manchester M21 0ST fax: +44(0)161 861 7543 England www.earlymusictheory.org/Tinctoris/ jeffrey.dean@bcu.ac.uk jeffrey.dean@stingrayoffice.com

On 20 Nov 2020, at 15:49, Anna Plaksin notifications@github.com wrote:

You should be able to change the position of the SC manually...

— You are receiving this because you commented. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub, or unsubscribe.

[annplaksin]

Wonderful! Then I'll reduce the priority to "future problems"...