search

Blockstream / greenlight

Build apps using self-custodial lightning nodes in the cloud
https://blockstream.github.io/greenlight/getting-started/
MIT License
109 stars 27 forks source link

Perpetual "transport error" #418

Closed Laderlappen closed 3 months ago

Laderlappen commented 4 months ago

Good day

When doing payments I get an error with the message of "transport error". I've tried multiple times today to make a payment but was not able to.

This also been a problem for the past month but today it is not working at all. Is there something I can do on my side?

Here are some logs:

event {"details":{"invoice":{"expiry":3600,"routingHints":[{"hops":[{"htlcMaximumMsat":null,"htlcMinimumMsat":null,"cltvExpiryDelta":34,"feesBaseMsat":0,"feesProportionalMillionths":0,"shortChannelId":15040265511668863000,"srcNodeId":"02c811e575be2df47d8b48dab3d3f1c9b0f6e16d0d40b5ed78253308fc2bd7170d"}]}],"timestamp":1714381497,"descriptionHash":null,"paymentHash":"2e18b70b5cbcaee746ebf3b503495d1107f7bb52cf3260a60bcf5c978e22c5c3","network":"bitcoin","description":"Invoice for 1000 sats","minFinalCltvExpiryDelta":144,"payeePubkey":"026b4e9c35b9cd3189c6790e9c74677ac4bc925e4021d2dd37dae4ff5cd9cfe762","paymentSecret":[177,237,131,185,110,223,224,123,48,94,184,110,148,234,213,109,99,118,127,167,14,73,162,92,37,207,167,71,94,205,246,125],"amountMsat":1000000,"bolt11":"lnbc10u1pnz7c4esp5k8kc8wtwmls8kvz7hphff6k4d43hvla8pey6yhp9e7n5whkd7e7spp59cvtwz6uhjhww3ht7w6sxj2azyrl0w6jeuexpfsteawf0r3zchpsdpzf9h8vmmfvdjjqen0wgsrzvpsxqs8xct5wvcqzysrzjqtypret4hcklglvtfrdt85l3exc0dctdp4qttmtcy5es3lpt6utsm59ec89ua9xw5uqqqqqqqqqqqqqqyg9qxpqysgqhhupqyulua0lepltvr2ql8kycky2qtj29kxtfyk3ysnmj2lqjt88jjyyz3kvf0tqzffm6fx0jp9l8td500hhsl2mt66a6m757tdm69qpd4qhsh"},"nodeId":"026b4e9c35b9cd3189c6790e9c74677ac4bc925e4021d2dd37dae4ff5cd9cfe762","error":"Generic: Generic: status: Unknown, message: \"transport error\", details: [], metadata: MetadataMap { headers: {} }"},"type":"paymentFailed"}
 LOG  event {"details":{"invoice":{"expiry":3600,"routingHints":[{"hops":[{"htlcMaximumMsat":null,"htlcMinimumMsat":null,"cltvExpiryDelta":34,"feesBaseMsat":0,"feesProportionalMillionths":0,"shortChannelId":15040265511668863000,"srcNodeId":"02c811e575be2df47d8b48dab3d3f1c9b0f6e16d0d40b5ed78253308fc2bd7170d"}]}],"timestamp":1714381497,"descriptionHash":null,"paymentHash":"2e18b70b5cbcaee746ebf3b503495d1107f7bb52cf3260a60bcf5c978e22c5c3","network":"bitcoin","description":"Invoice for 1000 sats","minFinalCltvExpiryDelta":144,"payeePubkey":"026b4e9c35b9cd3189c6790e9c74677ac4bc925e4021d2dd37dae4ff5cd9cfe762","paymentSecret":[177,237,131,185,110,223,224,123,48,94,184,110,148,234,213,109,99,118,127,167,14,73,162,92,37,207,167,71,94,205,246,125],"amountMsat":1000000,"bolt11":"lnbc10u1pnz7c4esp5k8kc8wtwmls8kvz7hphff6k4d43hvla8pey6yhp9e7n5whkd7e7spp59cvtwz6uhjhww3ht7w6sxj2azyrl0w6jeuexpfsteawf0r3zchpsdpzf9h8vmmfvdjjqen0wgsrzvpsxqs8xct5wvcqzysrzjqtypret4hcklglvtfrdt85l3exc0dctdp4qttmtcy5es3lpt6utsm59ec89ua9xw5uqqqqqqqqqqqqqqyg9qxpqysgqhhupqyulua0lepltvr2ql8kycky2qtj29kxtfyk3ysnmj2lqjt88jjyyz3kvf0tqzffm6fx0jp9l8td500hhsl2mt66a6m757tdm69qpd4qhsh"},"nodeId":"026b4e9c35b9cd3189c6790e9c74677ac4bc925e4021d2dd37dae4ff5cd9cfe762","error":"Generic: Generic: status: Unknown, message: \"transport error\", details: [], metadata: MetadataMap { headers: {} }"},"type":"paymentFailed"}
 LOG  event {"details":{"invoice":{"expiry":3600,"routingHints":[{"hops":[{"htlcMaximumMsat":null,"htlcMinimumMsat":null,"cltvExpiryDelta":34,"feesBaseMsat":0,"feesProportionalMillionths":0,"shortChannelId":15040265511668863000,"srcNodeId":"02c811e575be2df47d8b48dab3d3f1c9b0f6e16d0d40b5ed78253308fc2bd7170d"}]}],"timestamp":1714381497,"descriptionHash":null,"paymentHash":"2e18b70b5cbcaee746ebf3b503495d1107f7bb52cf3260a60bcf5c978e22c5c3","network":"bitcoin","description":"Invoice for 1000 sats","minFinalCltvExpiryDelta":144,"payeePubkey":"026b4e9c35b9cd3189c6790e9c74677ac4bc925e4021d2dd37dae4ff5cd9cfe762","paymentSecret":[177,237,131,185,110,223,224,123,48,94,184,110,148,234,213,109,99,118,127,167,14,73,162,92,37,207,167,71,94,205,246,125],"amountMsat":1000000,"bolt11":"lnbc10u1pnz7c4esp5k8kc8wtwmls8kvz7hphff6k4d43hvla8pey6yhp9e7n5whkd7e7spp59cvtwz6uhjhww3ht7w6sxj2azyrl0w6jeuexpfsteawf0r3zchpsdpzf9h8vmmfvdjjqen0wgsrzvpsxqs8xct5wvcqzysrzjqtypret4hcklglvtfrdt85l3exc0dctdp4qttmtcy5es3lpt6utsm59ec89ua9xw5uqqqqqqqqqqqqqqyg9qxpqysgqhhupqyulua0lepltvr2ql8kycky2qtj29kxtfyk3ysnmj2lqjt88jjyyz3kvf0tqzffm6fx0jp9l8td500hhsl2mt66a6m757tdm69qpd4qhsh"},"nodeId":"026b4e9c35b9cd3189c6790e9c74677ac4bc925e4021d2dd37dae4ff5cd9cfe762","error":"Generic: Generic: status: Unknown, message: \"transport error\", details: [], metadata: MetadataMap { headers: {} }"},"type":"paymentFailed"}
 LOG  event {"details":{"invoice":{"expiry":3600,"routingHints":[{"hops":[{"htlcMaximumMsat":null,"htlcMinimumMsat":null,"cltvExpiryDelta":34,"feesBaseMsat":0,"feesProportionalMillionths":0,"shortChannelId":15040265511668863000,"srcNodeId":"02c811e575be2df47d8b48dab3d3f1c9b0f6e16d0d40b5ed78253308fc2bd7170d"}]}],"timestamp":1714381497,"descriptionHash":null,"paymentHash":"2e18b70b5cbcaee746ebf3b503495d1107f7bb52cf3260a60bcf5c978e22c5c3","network":"bitcoin","description":"Invoice for 1000 sats","minFinalCltvExpiryDelta":144,"payeePubkey":"026b4e9c35b9cd3189c6790e9c74677ac4bc925e4021d2dd37dae4ff5cd9cfe762","paymentSecret":[177,237,131,185,110,223,224,123,48,94,184,110,148,234,213,109,99,118,127,167,14,73,162,92,37,207,167,71,94,205,246,125],"amountMsat":1000000,"bolt11":"lnbc10u1pnz7c4esp5k8kc8wtwmls8kvz7hphff6k4d43hvla8pey6yhp9e7n5whkd7e7spp59cvtwz6uhjhww3ht7w6sxj2azyrl0w6jeuexpfsteawf0r3zchpsdpzf9h8vmmfvdjjqen0wgsrzvpsxqs8xct5wvcqzysrzjqtypret4hcklglvtfrdt85l3exc0dctdp4qttmtcy5es3lpt6utsm59ec89ua9xw5uqqqqqqqqqqqqqqyg9qxpqysgqhhupqyulua0lepltvr2ql8kycky2qtj29kxtfyk3ysnmj2lqjt88jjyyz3kvf0tqzffm6fx0jp9l8td500hhsl2mt66a6m757tdm69qpd4qhsh"},"nodeId":"026b4e9c35b9cd3189c6790e9c74677ac4bc925e4021d2dd37dae4ff5cd9cfe762","error":"Generic: Generic: status: Unknown, message: \"transport error\", details: [], metadata: MetadataMap { headers: {} }"},"type":"paymentFailed"}
 LOG  event {"details":{"invoice":{"expiry":3600,"routingHints":[{"hops":[{"htlcMaximumMsat":null,"htlcMinimumMsat":null,"cltvExpiryDelta":34,"feesBaseMsat":0,"feesProportionalMillionths":0,"shortChannelId":15040265511668863000,"srcNodeId":"02c811e575be2df47d8b48dab3d3f1c9b0f6e16d0d40b5ed78253308fc2bd7170d"}]}],"timestamp":1714381497,"descriptionHash":null,"paymentHash":"2e18b70b5cbcaee746ebf3b503495d1107f7bb52cf3260a60bcf5c978e22c5c3","network":"bitcoin","description":"Invoice for 1000 sats","minFinalCltvExpiryDelta":144,"payeePubkey":"026b4e9c35b9cd3189c6790e9c74677ac4bc925e4021d2dd37dae4ff5cd9cfe762","paymentSecret":[177,237,131,185,110,223,224,123,48,94,184,110,148,234,213,109,99,118,127,167,14,73,162,92,37,207,167,71,94,205,246,125],"amountMsat":1000000,"bolt11":"lnbc10u1pnz7c4esp5k8kc8wtwmls8kvz7hphff6k4d43hvla8pey6yhp9e7n5whkd7e7spp59cvtwz6uhjhww3ht7w6sxj2azyrl0w6jeuexpfsteawf0r3zchpsdpzf9h8vmmfvdjjqen0wgsrzvpsxqs8xct5wvcqzysrzjqtypret4hcklglvtfrdt85l3exc0dctdp4qttmtcy5es3lpt6utsm59ec89ua9xw5uqqqqqqqqqqqqqqyg9qxpqysgqhhupqyulua0lepltvr2ql8kycky2qtj29kxtfyk3ysnmj2lqjt88jjyyz3kvf0tqzffm6fx0jp9l8td500hhsl2mt66a6m757tdm69qpd4qhsh"},"nodeId":"026b4e9c35b9cd3189c6790e9c74677ac4bc925e4021d2dd37dae4ff5cd9cfe762","error":"Generic: Generic: status: Unknown, message: \"transport error\", details: [], metadata: MetadataMap { headers: {} }"},"type":"paymentFailed"}
 ERROR  [Error: Generic: Generic: status: Unknown, message: "transport error", details: [], metadata: MetadataMap { headers: {} }]
kingonly commented 3 months ago

@Laderlappen can you please check again how are things looking on your end? You shouldn't see transport errors anymore (they can happen, but very rarely).

Laderlappen commented 3 months ago

@kingonly

I tried payments again now. Most of them still fail. But at least some of them go through now. The first few attempts failed.

I have a retry mechanism in the payments to retry 3 times if the payment fails. Here is an example of the first attempt failing and then the second one works (It looks like this happens most of the time, the fist attempt always fails):

 LOG  Breez already initialized.
 LOG  event {"type":"backupStarted"}
 LOG  event {"type":"backupStarted"}
 LOG  event {"type":"backupStarted"}
 LOG  event {"type":"backupStarted"}
 LOG  event {"type":"backupStarted"}
 LOG  event {"type":"backupSucceeded"}
 LOG  event {"type":"backupSucceeded"}
 LOG  event {"type":"backupSucceeded"}
 LOG  event {"type":"backupSucceeded"}
 LOG  event {"type":"backupSucceeded"}
 LOG  event {"type":"synced"}
 LOG  event {"type":"synced"}
 LOG  event {"type":"synced"}
 LOG  event {"type":"synced"}
 LOG  event {"type":"synced"}
 LOG  event {"details":{"invoice":{"expiry":3600,"routingHints":[{"hops":[{"htlcMaximumMsat":null,"htlcMinimumMsat":null,"cltvExpiryDelta":34,"feesBaseMsat":0,"feesProportionalMillionths":0,"shortChannelId":15040265511668863000,"srcNodeId":"02c811e575be2df47d8b48dab3d3f1c9b0f6e16d0d40b5ed78253308fc2bd7170d"}]}],"timestamp":1715154125,"descriptionHash":null,"paymentHash":"4a41b05e462ba541e503cfdf95e73e28da6e0a916566162e302c5b15ee647c5e","network":"bitcoin","description":"Invoice for 100 sats","minFinalCltvExpiryDelta":144,"payeePubkey":"026b4e9c35b9cd3189c6790e9c74677ac4bc925e4021d2dd37dae4ff5cd9cfe762","paymentSecret":[212,19,222,206,46,169,11,77,123,20,74,143,173,24,131,247,203,186,219,161,96,197,191,40,247,226,202,99,117,181,98,37],"amountMsat":100000,"bolt11":"lnbc1u1pnrktxdsp56sfaan3w4y9567c5f2866xyr7l9m4kapvrzm728hut9xxad4vgjspp5ffqmqhjx9wj5regrel0etee79rdxuz53v4npvt3s93d3tmny030qdpqf9h8vmmfvdjjqen0wgsrzvpsypekzarncqzysrzjqtypret4hcklglvtfrdt85l3exc0dctdp4qttmtcy5es3lpt6utsm59ec89ua9xw5uqqqqqqqqqqqqqqyg9qxpqysgqf49atpvlw4a7jmmc0flj9gregzv6z5yngtkcfrr68fu7g9ac86frcth20r9kg8vt98aa6vjlqa5yezvf6u7hv60x2wx6mez255hazqcq248qvj"},"nodeId":"026b4e9c35b9cd3189c6790e9c74677ac4bc925e4021d2dd37dae4ff5cd9cfe762","error":"Generic: Generic: status: Unknown, message: \"transport error\", details: [], metadata: MetadataMap { headers: {} }"},"type":"paymentFailed"}
 LOG  event {"details":{"invoice":{"expiry":3600,"routingHints":[{"hops":[{"htlcMaximumMsat":null,"htlcMinimumMsat":null,"cltvExpiryDelta":34,"feesBaseMsat":0,"feesProportionalMillionths":0,"shortChannelId":15040265511668863000,"srcNodeId":"02c811e575be2df47d8b48dab3d3f1c9b0f6e16d0d40b5ed78253308fc2bd7170d"}]}],"timestamp":1715154125,"descriptionHash":null,"paymentHash":"4a41b05e462ba541e503cfdf95e73e28da6e0a916566162e302c5b15ee647c5e","network":"bitcoin","description":"Invoice for 100 sats","minFinalCltvExpiryDelta":144,"payeePubkey":"026b4e9c35b9cd3189c6790e9c74677ac4bc925e4021d2dd37dae4ff5cd9cfe762","paymentSecret":[212,19,222,206,46,169,11,77,123,20,74,143,173,24,131,247,203,186,219,161,96,197,191,40,247,226,202,99,117,181,98,37],"amountMsat":100000,"bolt11":"lnbc1u1pnrktxdsp56sfaan3w4y9567c5f2866xyr7l9m4kapvrzm728hut9xxad4vgjspp5ffqmqhjx9wj5regrel0etee79rdxuz53v4npvt3s93d3tmny030qdpqf9h8vmmfvdjjqen0wgsrzvpsypekzarncqzysrzjqtypret4hcklglvtfrdt85l3exc0dctdp4qttmtcy5es3lpt6utsm59ec89ua9xw5uqqqqqqqqqqqqqqyg9qxpqysgqf49atpvlw4a7jmmc0flj9gregzv6z5yngtkcfrr68fu7g9ac86frcth20r9kg8vt98aa6vjlqa5yezvf6u7hv60x2wx6mez255hazqcq248qvj"},"nodeId":"026b4e9c35b9cd3189c6790e9c74677ac4bc925e4021d2dd37dae4ff5cd9cfe762","error":"Generic: Generic: status: Unknown, message: \"transport error\", details: [], metadata: MetadataMap { headers: {} }"},"type":"paymentFailed"}
 LOG  event {"details":{"invoice":{"expiry":3600,"routingHints":[{"hops":[{"htlcMaximumMsat":null,"htlcMinimumMsat":null,"cltvExpiryDelta":34,"feesBaseMsat":0,"feesProportionalMillionths":0,"shortChannelId":15040265511668863000,"srcNodeId":"02c811e575be2df47d8b48dab3d3f1c9b0f6e16d0d40b5ed78253308fc2bd7170d"}]}],"timestamp":1715154125,"descriptionHash":null,"paymentHash":"4a41b05e462ba541e503cfdf95e73e28da6e0a916566162e302c5b15ee647c5e","network":"bitcoin","description":"Invoice for 100 sats","minFinalCltvExpiryDelta":144,"payeePubkey":"026b4e9c35b9cd3189c6790e9c74677ac4bc925e4021d2dd37dae4ff5cd9cfe762","paymentSecret":[212,19,222,206,46,169,11,77,123,20,74,143,173,24,131,247,203,186,219,161,96,197,191,40,247,226,202,99,117,181,98,37],"amountMsat":100000,"bolt11":"lnbc1u1pnrktxdsp56sfaan3w4y9567c5f2866xyr7l9m4kapvrzm728hut9xxad4vgjspp5ffqmqhjx9wj5regrel0etee79rdxuz53v4npvt3s93d3tmny030qdpqf9h8vmmfvdjjqen0wgsrzvpsypekzarncqzysrzjqtypret4hcklglvtfrdt85l3exc0dctdp4qttmtcy5es3lpt6utsm59ec89ua9xw5uqqqqqqqqqqqqqqyg9qxpqysgqf49atpvlw4a7jmmc0flj9gregzv6z5yngtkcfrr68fu7g9ac86frcth20r9kg8vt98aa6vjlqa5yezvf6u7hv60x2wx6mez255hazqcq248qvj"},"nodeId":"026b4e9c35b9cd3189c6790e9c74677ac4bc925e4021d2dd37dae4ff5cd9cfe762","error":"Generic: Generic: status: Unknown, message: \"transport error\", details: [], metadata: MetadataMap { headers: {} }"},"type":"paymentFailed"}
 LOG  event {"details":{"invoice":{"expiry":3600,"routingHints":[{"hops":[{"htlcMaximumMsat":null,"htlcMinimumMsat":null,"cltvExpiryDelta":34,"feesBaseMsat":0,"feesProportionalMillionths":0,"shortChannelId":15040265511668863000,"srcNodeId":"02c811e575be2df47d8b48dab3d3f1c9b0f6e16d0d40b5ed78253308fc2bd7170d"}]}],"timestamp":1715154125,"descriptionHash":null,"paymentHash":"4a41b05e462ba541e503cfdf95e73e28da6e0a916566162e302c5b15ee647c5e","network":"bitcoin","description":"Invoice for 100 sats","minFinalCltvExpiryDelta":144,"payeePubkey":"026b4e9c35b9cd3189c6790e9c74677ac4bc925e4021d2dd37dae4ff5cd9cfe762","paymentSecret":[212,19,222,206,46,169,11,77,123,20,74,143,173,24,131,247,203,186,219,161,96,197,191,40,247,226,202,99,117,181,98,37],"amountMsat":100000,"bolt11":"lnbc1u1pnrktxdsp56sfaan3w4y9567c5f2866xyr7l9m4kapvrzm728hut9xxad4vgjspp5ffqmqhjx9wj5regrel0etee79rdxuz53v4npvt3s93d3tmny030qdpqf9h8vmmfvdjjqen0wgsrzvpsypekzarncqzysrzjqtypret4hcklglvtfrdt85l3exc0dctdp4qttmtcy5es3lpt6utsm59ec89ua9xw5uqqqqqqqqqqqqqqyg9qxpqysgqf49atpvlw4a7jmmc0flj9gregzv6z5yngtkcfrr68fu7g9ac86frcth20r9kg8vt98aa6vjlqa5yezvf6u7hv60x2wx6mez255hazqcq248qvj"},"nodeId":"026b4e9c35b9cd3189c6790e9c74677ac4bc925e4021d2dd37dae4ff5cd9cfe762","error":"Generic: Generic: status: Unknown, message: \"transport error\", details: [], metadata: MetadataMap { headers: {} }"},"type":"paymentFailed"}
 LOG  event {"details":{"invoice":{"expiry":3600,"routingHints":[{"hops":[{"htlcMaximumMsat":null,"htlcMinimumMsat":null,"cltvExpiryDelta":34,"feesBaseMsat":0,"feesProportionalMillionths":0,"shortChannelId":15040265511668863000,"srcNodeId":"02c811e575be2df47d8b48dab3d3f1c9b0f6e16d0d40b5ed78253308fc2bd7170d"}]}],"timestamp":1715154125,"descriptionHash":null,"paymentHash":"4a41b05e462ba541e503cfdf95e73e28da6e0a916566162e302c5b15ee647c5e","network":"bitcoin","description":"Invoice for 100 sats","minFinalCltvExpiryDelta":144,"payeePubkey":"026b4e9c35b9cd3189c6790e9c74677ac4bc925e4021d2dd37dae4ff5cd9cfe762","paymentSecret":[212,19,222,206,46,169,11,77,123,20,74,143,173,24,131,247,203,186,219,161,96,197,191,40,247,226,202,99,117,181,98,37],"amountMsat":100000,"bolt11":"lnbc1u1pnrktxdsp56sfaan3w4y9567c5f2866xyr7l9m4kapvrzm728hut9xxad4vgjspp5ffqmqhjx9wj5regrel0etee79rdxuz53v4npvt3s93d3tmny030qdpqf9h8vmmfvdjjqen0wgsrzvpsypekzarncqzysrzjqtypret4hcklglvtfrdt85l3exc0dctdp4qttmtcy5es3lpt6utsm59ec89ua9xw5uqqqqqqqqqqqqqqyg9qxpqysgqf49atpvlw4a7jmmc0flj9gregzv6z5yngtkcfrr68fu7g9ac86frcth20r9kg8vt98aa6vjlqa5yezvf6u7hv60x2wx6mez255hazqcq248qvj"},"nodeId":"026b4e9c35b9cd3189c6790e9c74677ac4bc925e4021d2dd37dae4ff5cd9cfe762","error":"Generic: Generic: status: Unknown, message: \"transport error\", details: [], metadata: MetadataMap { headers: {} }"},"type":"paymentFailed"}
 ERROR  [Error: Generic: Generic: status: Unknown, message: "transport error", details: [], metadata: MetadataMap { headers: {} }]
 LOG  Retrying payment
 LOG  event {"type":"backupStarted"}
 LOG  event {"type":"backupStarted"}
 LOG  event {"type":"backupStarted"}
 LOG  event {"type":"backupStarted"}
 LOG  event {"type":"backupStarted"}
 LOG  event {"type":"backupSucceeded"}
 LOG  event {"type":"backupSucceeded"}
 LOG  event {"type":"backupSucceeded"}
 LOG  event {"type":"backupSucceeded"}
 LOG  event {"type":"backupSucceeded"}
 LOG  event {"type":"backupStarted"}
 LOG  event {"type":"backupStarted"}
 LOG  event {"type":"backupStarted"}
 LOG  event {"type":"backupStarted"}
 LOG  event {"type":"backupStarted"}
 LOG  event {"type":"backupSucceeded"}
 LOG  event {"type":"backupSucceeded"}
 LOG  event {"type":"backupSucceeded"}
 LOG  event {"type":"backupSucceeded"}
 LOG  event {"type":"backupSucceeded"}
 LOG  event {"type":"synced"}
 LOG  event {"type":"synced"}
 LOG  event {"type":"synced"}
 LOG  event {"type":"synced"}
 LOG  event {"type":"synced"}
 LOG  event {"details":{"metadata":null,"details":{"data":{"reverseSwapInfo":null,"swapInfo":null,"lnurlWithdrawEndpoint":null,"paymentPreimage":"3a5634d4048c9e0908af5814373aceb6a1f99b231a5c9196982d145c6dbf9bf4","lnurlMetadata":null,"lnurlPayDomain":null,"lnurlSuccessAction":null,"lnAddress":null,"pendingExpirationBlock":null,"openChannelBolt11":null,"bolt11":"lnbc1u1pnrktxdsp56sfaan3w4y9567c5f2866xyr7l9m4kapvrzm728hut9xxad4vgjspp5ffqmqhjx9wj5regrel0etee79rdxuz53v4npvt3s93d3tmny030qdpqf9h8vmmfvdjjqen0wgsrzvpsypekzarncqzysrzjqtypret4hcklglvtfrdt85l3exc0dctdp4qttmtcy5es3lpt6utsm59ec89ua9xw5uqqqqqqqqqqqqqqyg9qxpqysgqf49atpvlw4a7jmmc0flj9gregzv6z5yngtkcfrr68fu7g9ac86frcth20r9kg8vt98aa6vjlqa5yezvf6u7hv60x2wx6mez255hazqcq248qvj","label":"","paymentHash":"4a41b05e462ba541e503cfdf95e73e28da6e0a916566162e302c5b15ee647c5e","destinationPubkey":"026b4e9c35b9cd3189c6790e9c74677ac4bc925e4021d2dd37dae4ff5cd9cfe762","keysend":false},"type":"ln"},"amountMsat":100000,"paymentTime":1715154205,"status":"complete","id":"4a41b05e462ba541e503cfdf95e73e28da6e0a916566162e302c5b15ee647c5e","paymentType":"sent","description":"Invoice for 100 sats","error":null,"feeMsat":0},"type":"paymentSucceed"}
 LOG  event {"details":{"metadata":null,"details":{"data":{"reverseSwapInfo":null,"swapInfo":null,"lnurlWithdrawEndpoint":null,"paymentPreimage":"3a5634d4048c9e0908af5814373aceb6a1f99b231a5c9196982d145c6dbf9bf4","lnurlMetadata":null,"lnurlPayDomain":null,"lnurlSuccessAction":null,"lnAddress":null,"pendingExpirationBlock":null,"openChannelBolt11":null,"bolt11":"lnbc1u1pnrktxdsp56sfaan3w4y9567c5f2866xyr7l9m4kapvrzm728hut9xxad4vgjspp5ffqmqhjx9wj5regrel0etee79rdxuz53v4npvt3s93d3tmny030qdpqf9h8vmmfvdjjqen0wgsrzvpsypekzarncqzysrzjqtypret4hcklglvtfrdt85l3exc0dctdp4qttmtcy5es3lpt6utsm59ec89ua9xw5uqqqqqqqqqqqqqqyg9qxpqysgqf49atpvlw4a7jmmc0flj9gregzv6z5yngtkcfrr68fu7g9ac86frcth20r9kg8vt98aa6vjlqa5yezvf6u7hv60x2wx6mez255hazqcq248qvj","label":"","paymentHash":"4a41b05e462ba541e503cfdf95e73e28da6e0a916566162e302c5b15ee647c5e","destinationPubkey":"026b4e9c35b9cd3189c6790e9c74677ac4bc925e4021d2dd37dae4ff5cd9cfe762","keysend":false},"type":"ln"},"amountMsat":100000,"paymentTime":1715154205,"status":"complete","id":"4a41b05e462ba541e503cfdf95e73e28da6e0a916566162e302c5b15ee647c5e","paymentType":"sent","description":"Invoice for 100 sats","error":null,"feeMsat":0},"type":"paymentSucceed"}
 LOG  event {"details":{"metadata":null,"details":{"data":{"reverseSwapInfo":null,"swapInfo":null,"lnurlWithdrawEndpoint":null,"paymentPreimage":"3a5634d4048c9e0908af5814373aceb6a1f99b231a5c9196982d145c6dbf9bf4","lnurlMetadata":null,"lnurlPayDomain":null,"lnurlSuccessAction":null,"lnAddress":null,"pendingExpirationBlock":null,"openChannelBolt11":null,"bolt11":"lnbc1u1pnrktxdsp56sfaan3w4y9567c5f2866xyr7l9m4kapvrzm728hut9xxad4vgjspp5ffqmqhjx9wj5regrel0etee79rdxuz53v4npvt3s93d3tmny030qdpqf9h8vmmfvdjjqen0wgsrzvpsypekzarncqzysrzjqtypret4hcklglvtfrdt85l3exc0dctdp4qttmtcy5es3lpt6utsm59ec89ua9xw5uqqqqqqqqqqqqqqyg9qxpqysgqf49atpvlw4a7jmmc0flj9gregzv6z5yngtkcfrr68fu7g9ac86frcth20r9kg8vt98aa6vjlqa5yezvf6u7hv60x2wx6mez255hazqcq248qvj","label":"","paymentHash":"4a41b05e462ba541e503cfdf95e73e28da6e0a916566162e302c5b15ee647c5e","destinationPubkey":"026b4e9c35b9cd3189c6790e9c74677ac4bc925e4021d2dd37dae4ff5cd9cfe762","keysend":false},"type":"ln"},"amountMsat":100000,"paymentTime":1715154205,"status":"complete","id":"4a41b05e462ba541e503cfdf95e73e28da6e0a916566162e302c5b15ee647c5e","paymentType":"sent","description":"Invoice for 100 sats","error":null,"feeMsat":0},"type":"paymentSucceed"}
 LOG  event {"details":{"metadata":null,"details":{"data":{"reverseSwapInfo":null,"swapInfo":null,"lnurlWithdrawEndpoint":null,"paymentPreimage":"3a5634d4048c9e0908af5814373aceb6a1f99b231a5c9196982d145c6dbf9bf4","lnurlMetadata":null,"lnurlPayDomain":null,"lnurlSuccessAction":null,"lnAddress":null,"pendingExpirationBlock":null,"openChannelBolt11":null,"bolt11":"lnbc1u1pnrktxdsp56sfaan3w4y9567c5f2866xyr7l9m4kapvrzm728hut9xxad4vgjspp5ffqmqhjx9wj5regrel0etee79rdxuz53v4npvt3s93d3tmny030qdpqf9h8vmmfvdjjqen0wgsrzvpsypekzarncqzysrzjqtypret4hcklglvtfrdt85l3exc0dctdp4qttmtcy5es3lpt6utsm59ec89ua9xw5uqqqqqqqqqqqqqqyg9qxpqysgqf49atpvlw4a7jmmc0flj9gregzv6z5yngtkcfrr68fu7g9ac86frcth20r9kg8vt98aa6vjlqa5yezvf6u7hv60x2wx6mez255hazqcq248qvj","label":"","paymentHash":"4a41b05e462ba541e503cfdf95e73e28da6e0a916566162e302c5b15ee647c5e","destinationPubkey":"026b4e9c35b9cd3189c6790e9c74677ac4bc925e4021d2dd37dae4ff5cd9cfe762","keysend":false},"type":"ln"},"amountMsat":100000,"paymentTime":1715154205,"status":"complete","id":"4a41b05e462ba541e503cfdf95e73e28da6e0a916566162e302c5b15ee647c5e","paymentType":"sent","description":"Invoice for 100 sats","error":null,"feeMsat":0},"type":"paymentSucceed"}
 LOG  event {"details":{"metadata":null,"details":{"data":{"reverseSwapInfo":null,"swapInfo":null,"lnurlWithdrawEndpoint":null,"paymentPreimage":"3a5634d4048c9e0908af5814373aceb6a1f99b231a5c9196982d145c6dbf9bf4","lnurlMetadata":null,"lnurlPayDomain":null,"lnurlSuccessAction":null,"lnAddress":null,"pendingExpirationBlock":null,"openChannelBolt11":null,"bolt11":"lnbc1u1pnrktxdsp56sfaan3w4y9567c5f2866xyr7l9m4kapvrzm728hut9xxad4vgjspp5ffqmqhjx9wj5regrel0etee79rdxuz53v4npvt3s93d3tmny030qdpqf9h8vmmfvdjjqen0wgsrzvpsypekzarncqzysrzjqtypret4hcklglvtfrdt85l3exc0dctdp4qttmtcy5es3lpt6utsm59ec89ua9xw5uqqqqqqqqqqqqqqyg9qxpqysgqf49atpvlw4a7jmmc0flj9gregzv6z5yngtkcfrr68fu7g9ac86frcth20r9kg8vt98aa6vjlqa5yezvf6u7hv60x2wx6mez255hazqcq248qvj","label":"","paymentHash":"4a41b05e462ba541e503cfdf95e73e28da6e0a916566162e302c5b15ee647c5e","destinationPubkey":"026b4e9c35b9cd3189c6790e9c74677ac4bc925e4021d2dd37dae4ff5cd9cfe762","keysend":false},"type":"ln"},"amountMsat":100000,"paymentTime":1715154205,"status":"complete","id":"4a41b05e462ba541e503cfdf95e73e28da6e0a916566162e302c5b15ee647c5e","paymentType":"sent","description":"Invoice for 100 sats","error":null,"feeMsat":0},"type":"paymentSucceed"}
 LOG  Payment response: {"payment": {"amountMsat": 100000, "description": "Invoice for 100 sats", "details": {"data": [Object], "type": "ln"}, "error": null, "feeMsat": 0, "id": "4a41b05e462ba541e503cfdf95e73e28da6e0a916566162e302c5b15ee647c5e", "metadata": null, "paymentTime": 1715154205, "paymentType": "sent", "status": "complete"}}
 LOG  Payment succeeded
Laderlappen commented 3 months ago

I had a payment now that succeeded without a retry. So the first attempt does not consistently fail.

roeierez commented 3 months ago

@Laderlappen this elaborate on the transport error you get sometimes: https://github.com/breez/breez-sdk/issues/966

cdecker commented 3 months ago

As the Breez SDK is planning to build a stop-gap solution, I also opened a tracking issue for gl-client itself here https://github.com/Blockstream/greenlight/issues/428

We'll keep that one open until it is fixed internally, and I'm closing this issue.