BlockstreamResearch / bip-frost-dkg

15 stars 7 forks source link

[llfourn] Rapid fire comments #1

Open LLFourn opened 8 months ago

LLFourn commented 8 months ago

Here's my first run through.

Nice work at separating the protocol into two. One that has an existing secure authenticated channel and one that doesn't. I made the flow chart below to try and understand what the choices are. It doesn't include the "cerifying network based protocol" idea yet:

I'm not sure if that diagram is the best way to slice it yet. It would be cool if we could make it modular and could figure out which one to use by asking a few questions.

This PR is obviously not meant to be merged but just to discuss a few topics and turn those that need action or further discussion into issues.