search

BluSunrize / ImmersiveEngineering

Wires, transformers, high voltage! Bzzzzt!
Other
782 stars 389 forks source link

[Enhancement] New Breaker Switch Sound #2231

Closed dragonshardz closed 5 years ago

dragonshardz commented 7 years ago

N/T. Please replace the current sound of the breaker switch (somebody saying eee-oo) with this: https://freesound.org/people/Alvinwhatup2/sounds/131599/

BluSunrize commented 7 years ago

I'm afraid I can't do that, Dave. The Direwolf meme must be kept alive.

Also, that's not the sound a knifeswitch makes either. =P

Soaryn commented 7 years ago

The current sound is incredibly accurate to what an ACTUAL switch sounds like. Trust me, for I am an Engineer.

In all seriousness, the current sound must never change. 😄

ghost commented 7 years ago

The current breaker sound is completely intolerable to the point where I'm just using vanilla levers instead. Please give us a config option to mute the breaker sound...

ghost commented 7 years ago

I love the direwolf switches personally, but I think a config option to use the normal sound would be nice for some people :P

ghost commented 7 years ago

Who is direwolf? (Rhetorical question, but I've never watched a single one of his videos so I don't get this meme thing at all.)

ghost commented 7 years ago

He has this 1.11 modded multiplayer series called Forgecraft, which has Immersive Engineering on it. At some point the devs here decided to replace the breaker switch sound with Dire saying "meep moop"

ghost commented 7 years ago

Ah, I see. I agree with you.. an option to revert to the normal sound would be nice. I love breaker switches because they're so different than normal levers, and I loved the old sound.

BluSunrize commented 7 years ago

The sound stems from his Invasion series. He made the sound and then explained that the (till then) lack of sound on the switch was immersion breaking. I joked around with him a bit explaining that finding a proper sound for a knifeswitch is tricky (which it is, trust me, I tried) and then the suggestion of using his audio came up.

The feature was discussed publicly on twitter and implemented quite a while ago, with people having ample opportunity to complain about it, which noone did. Given that the broad majority was for it, or at least didn't seem to mind, I don't find this to be a thing to fix, really...

TheWhiteWolves commented 7 years ago

As the evil individual who suggested it, I like the sound, though I may be biased on that :stuck_out_tongue_closed_eyes:

ghost commented 7 years ago

I haven't played any modded minecraft in months and I don't keep up with twitter much. It was a bit of a rude surprise when I heard that awful sound. :( I suppose I'll just edit the .jar and substitute my own sound file or silence. Already did that about 4 months ago with HQM to mute the quest completion noise.. shouldn't be too hard for the IE circuit breaker.

KnightMiner commented 7 years ago

@Ambaire: don't edit the jar, resource packs exist for this reason.

ghost commented 7 years ago

Oh. You can put custom sounds in resource packs? If you don't mind, how would I do that for a sound in IE? All the tutorials I can find are for vanilla minecraft, and I'm not sure what folder structure to use for a mod.

KnightMiner commented 7 years ago

I wrote an Minecraft wiki article about it, but basically just place a new .ogg sound at the same location as the resource is in IE (in this case it should be in assets/immersiveengineering/sounds/direSwitch.ogg).

dragonshardz commented 7 years ago

Having a path for adding the sound to the resource pack is fine too, I guess.

Y'all can close this.

draeath commented 5 years ago

I think it's time for this joke to die.

Can we get a normal sound by default, now?

BluSunrize commented 5 years ago

Nope, absolutely not. I love the current one far too much =P

DisKorrupt commented 4 years ago

https://youtu.be/TjwFBwO-yiE?t=25 I'm actually particularly keen on something like this for the sound, I like the idea of the large industrial switches having that heavy sound to them as opposed to the Vanilla click of a lightswitch

BluSunrize commented 4 years ago

Were you not reading? I'm not changing the sound. Direwolf stays in the game.

Devalut commented 4 years ago

Dev's put in effort to place eastereggs such as textures or sounds on events or holidays, IE dev just slaps it in there as a festering pustule despite requests.

Nice

BluSunrize commented 4 years ago

IE also features a plethora of other eastereggs and references, from the manual entries, over advancements to the crates which change texture in December.

I know for a fact that the person from who the sound originated (Dire) still approves of it's use and the humorous context, given that he only recently had a good chuckle at it during an episode.

@Devalut if you want to insult my work, feel free to do it to my face, on Discord, and not on an issue that was closed 15 months ago, you disrespectful hack.