BrownDwarf / disperse

A large leading tail of Helium around HAT-P-67 b, an inflated hot Saturn undergoing runaway escape
https://ui.adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2023arXiv230708959G/abstract
MIT License
1 stars 0 forks source link

Remaking Figure 14 (Keplerian Shear illustration) in Adobe Illustrator #45

Closed gully closed 11 months ago

gully commented 1 year ago

Figure 14---made in adobe illustrator---shows a top-down view of an illuminated planet losing mass preferentially on its dayside. The figure quantifies (but does not dramatacize) Kepler shear-- the fact that mass lost on the dayside will orbit the star faster than the planet and therefore appear to accelerate and lead the planet in a restframe centered on the planet.

The referee wanted to see a wider view of the illustration, such that we could see the stream of gas make a "U-turn", so to speak, since the jetisoned and blueshifted material would eventually get pushed back outwards past the orbit of the planet.

We had considered such a diagram, but the exact orbital phase of where the gas would cross the orbit is non-obvious to me: we measure blueshifts at different phases, but its not clear whether that blueshift is representative of the bulk material, or merely some non-representative layer of the gas with the right ionization balance. The right thing to do is to run an MHD simulation and see what behavior we get. That's a separate task. So we're trying to make a plausible-looking figure.

There's also the reference from Aline Vidotto, in which the planet plowing into gas can create a planetary bow shock with an extent and orientation that depends on the planet magnetic field, among other properties.

I think what we'll do is this:

We already have demos of this in power point, so the main challenge is simply sticking everything into Illustrator and laying it out.

gully commented 1 year ago

funny thing-- my Adobe Illustrator license expired, so I'm on a 7 day free trial. Better get it done (and not need edits) within a week.

gully commented 1 year ago

Ok, here is the revised version:

Fig14_KeplerianShear_revised

gully commented 11 months ago

OK, this looks really good! Considering this issue closed!