Feedback from Covey on v0.6+ paper draft

BrownDwarf / welter

Inferring starspot properties in the IGRINS spectrum of LkCa 4

MIT License

5 stars 0 forks source link

Feedback from Covey on v0.6+ paper draft #46

Open gully opened 8 years ago

gully commented 8 years ago

paraphrased

[x] Description of Triplespec data observations
[x] Improve abstract with specific feedback
[x] Emphasize point about veiled lines from (relatively) featureless portions of starspot spectrum
[x] Clarify discussion of which orders were discarded and why
[ ] Enhance the discussion section with specific feedback
[ ] More specific feedback in marked-up draft

gully commented 8 years ago

[x] Explicitly show the equation leading to Teff calculation

gully commented 8 years ago

[ ] More support for this claim:

Temperature uncertainties for young K and M dwarfs are larger than any formal uncertainties in individual measurements.

gully commented 7 years ago

I didn't exactly clarify why I tossed which orders, but the referee wanted less jargon and less methods, so I chose not to expand (in fact, I might have cut more). All the jupyter notebooks will be open source, so folks can see the raw data.

Note to self: I'm not sure if I got to all the discussion section comments... might be worth double checking these, since I remember them being good.