Closed llooFlashooll closed 6 months ago
There is no misalignment issue because u8
has an alignment that is compatible with all other alignments.
This is the third false positive safety issue you've filed on my repos. I'm going to have to ask you to stop filing issues in the future on my repos unless you have a Miri stack trace. (It's possible to have UB without a Miri stack trace, but I don't know how else to increase the signal to noise ratio that you're producing.)
Also, why is the activity on your GitHub private? I'd like to see whether you're filing these types of issues on other projects.
You also don't disclose what tool you're using.
Please increase your transparency or stop filing issues on my repos.
Ok, thank you. I do not intend to do this. That's my bad. I will carefully handle each reported issue. I am anonymous since I am undergoing research. Hope you can understand. Thanks again.
Once upon a time, I was a PhD student too. And I wasn't anonymous.
Basically, I'm appreciate of issues, but if you're just some human front for a tool with a high false positive rate, then you're going to be wasting a lot of peoples' time. And that's annoying.
Thank you very much for your instructions. I would of course be willing and happy to open source and share all finally. I would only report when it's TP. Those are my bad.
Hi, I am scanning the byteorder in the latest version with my own static analyzer tool.
Unsafe conversion found at src/io.rs:1591:5: 1591:66; SliceFromRawPartsMut:
This unsound implementation would create a misalignment issues.
The problematic value is further manipulated at: src/io.rs:565:13: 565:33, src/io.rs:600:13: 600:33, src/io.rs:638:13: 638:33, src/io.rs:679:13: 679:33, src/io.rs:718:9: 718:29, src/io.rs:750:13: 750:33, src/io.rs:785:13: 785:33, src/io.rs:823:13: 823:33, src/io.rs:864:13: 864:33, src/io.rs:905:13: 905:33, src/io.rs:990:13: 990:33
This would potentially cause undefined behaviors in Rust. If we further manipulate the problematic converted types, it would potentially lead to different consequences. I am reporting this issue for your attention.