CEMPD / VERDI

This is the repo for the VERDI project, written in java.
GNU General Public License v3.0
17 stars 13 forks source link

Wind vector striping #252

Closed cwsimmon closed 2 years ago

cwsimmon commented 3 years ago

Reported by Russ Bullock

There was no MPAS model data containing wind vectors included in the software package, so I extracted only the 3-d zonal and meridional wind components from a daily MPAS-A output file (history file) along with the necessary mesh definition data and loaded the resulting file into Verdi. The wind vector display is showing spurious North/South stripes of vectors just east and west of the Greenwich meridian when the full domain is first displayed. The stripe to the east is most obvious. These do not appear on any zoomed or windowed maps, but they reappear with the Max_Zoom_Out command.

yadongxuEPA commented 3 years ago

To Reproduce Steps to reproduce the behavior:

1) Load the extracted wind components file "UV_only.2016-07-04.nc" (provided by Russ Bullock) into verdi and create tile plot of "uReconstructMeridional" variable. 2) On the top menu bar, go to Controls, check the box in front of "Show Wind Vectors" in the dropdown menu.

Tested with VERDI_2.1_linux64_20210707.tar.gz and confirmed that there were some North/South wind vector stripes when the map was Max_Zoom_Out.
issue_252_VERDI_testing_1_07072021

lizadams commented 3 years ago

What do the variable names mean? uReconstructMeridonal and uReconstructZonal?
Should I add tileplots of both of these variables to the User Manual?

Screen Shot 2021-08-18 at 4 39 44 PM Screen Shot 2021-08-18 at 4 39 54 PM

I zoomed into the US region for these plots.

yadongxuEPA commented 3 years ago

Hi Liz, I think "uReconstructMeridional" means meridional wind components and "uReconstructZonal" means zonal wind components.

Yadong

lizadams commented 3 years ago

The files for this testing are available on the following google drive. https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1ykwOX9h7YwB07bX7fD7wNOmCkLOJPSDb?usp=sharing

There is a large file size limit of 100 M that we can't exceed on github. The compressed size is 500 M 514M Aug 22 09:06 mpas_UV_only.2016-07-04.nc.gz

the CMAS account currently owns the github/cempd/VERDI account, and we cant use github LFS using a forked account I am not sure how to use the command line using an account other than my lizadams account. Need to resolve this issue and see if we can get large files supported under VERDI.

lizadams commented 3 years ago

Added instructions on how to download the file from the google drive, and also added two plots demonstrating how to display the wind vectors under this section of the documentation. https://github.com/CEMPD/VERDI/blob/master/doc/User_Manual/VERDI_ch12.md#mpas-netcdf-data-convention

There is still a line in the middle of the plot when you display the full map, as described above by Russ Bullock and Yadong Xu.

yadongxuEPA commented 2 years ago

Retested with VERDI_2.1_linux64_20211203.tar.gz, the issue has improved, but not completely resolved. We can see that the North/South wind vector stripes substantially decreased when max zoom-out, but there were still some stripes left.
issue_252_testing_20211203_1_marked issue_252_testing_20211203_2