search

CESNET / libyang

YANG data modeling language library
BSD 3-Clause "New" or "Revised" License
368 stars 292 forks source link

Calling the lyd_new_any interface returns inconsistent results between version 2.1.30 and version 2.1.128 #2236

Open sicongPang opened 5 months ago

sicongPang commented 5 months ago

image

input parameters：

data：

<edit-config xmlns=\"urn:ietf:params:xml:ns:netconf:base:1.0\">\n  <target>\n    <running/>\n  </target>\n  <default-operation>none</default-operation>\n  <error-option>stop-on-error</error-option>\n</edit-config>\n

mod:

{ctx = 0x197abc0, name = 0x196f710 "ietf-netconf", revision = 0x1970d00 "2011-06-01", ns = 0x1964d00 "urn:ietf:params:xml:ns:netconf:base:1.0", prefix = 0x196eba0 "nc",
  filepath = 0x0, org = 0x195af40 "IETF NETCONF (Network Configuration) Working Group",
  contact = 0x1970440 "WG Web:   <http://tools.ietf.org/wg/netconf/>\nWG List:  <netconf@ietf.org>\nWG Chair: Bert Wijnen\n          <bertietf@bwijnen.net>\nWG Chair: Mehmet Ersue\n          <mehmet.ersue@nsn.com>\nEditor:   Martin Bjorklund\n          <mbj@tail-f.com>\nEditor:   Juergen Schoenwaelder\n          <j.schoenwaelder@jacobs-university.de>\nEditor:   Andy Bierman\n          <andy.bierman@brocade.com>",
  dsc = 0x19705d0 "NETCONF Protocol Data Types and Protocol Operations.\nCopyright (c) 2011 IETF Trust and the persons identified as\nthe document authors.  All rights reserved.\nRedistribution and use in source and binary forms, with or\nwithout modification, is permitted pursuant to, and subject\nto the license terms contained in, the Simplified BSD License\nset forth in Section 4.c of the IETF Trust's Legal Provisions\nRelating to IETF Documents\n(http://trustee.ietf.org/license-info).\nThis version of this YANG module is part of RFC 6241; see\nthe RFC itself for full legal notices.", ref = 0x0, parsed = 0x1970320, compiled = 0x19836b0, identities = 0x0, augmented_by = 0x1985ef8, deviated_by = 0x0, implemented = 1 '\001',
  to_compile = 0 '\000', latest_revision = 5 '\005'}

rpc_e->edit_cont:

<testsdk xmlns=\"urn:test:yang:test-vrp-testsdk\">
  <TsdkTypeInners>
    <TsdkTypeInner operation=\"create\">
      <TestIndex>10001</TestIndex>
      <TestBinary>42594</TestBinary>
      <TestBool>false</TestBool>
      <TestInt16>20</TestInt16>
      <TestInt32>2147483647</TestInt32>
      <TestInt64>2000</TestInt64>
      <TestInt8>127</TestInt8>
      <TestString1>test</TestString1>
      <TestString2>writebackadd</TestString2>
      <TestUint16>3</TestUint16>
      <TestUint32>100</TestUint32>
      <TestUint64>4294967295</TestUint64>
      <TestUint8>255</TestUint8>
      <TestName>1</TestName>
      <TestTimeticks>4294967295</TestTimeticks>
      <TestIpversion>ipv4</TestIpversion>
      <TestIpaddress>0.0.0.0</TestIpaddress>
      <TestIpnozone>::</TestIpnozone>
      <TestIpv4nozone>158.5.156.1</TestIpv4nozone>
      <TestIpv6nozone>1234:ABCD:1234:ABCD:1234:ABCD:1234:ABCD</TestIpv6nozone>
      <TestDate>1970-01-01</TestDate>
      <TestTime>11:11:11</TestTime>
      <TestDatetime>1971-01-01T10:10:10</TestDatetime>
      <TestTimehhmm>11:11</TestTimehhmm>
      <TestPassword>test#$</TestPassword>
      <TestPasswordex>test#$~@-^*%/.+:;=</TestPasswordex>
      <TestTribit1>0</TestTribit1>
      <TestTribit2>0</TestTribit2>
      <TestTribit4>0</TestTribit4>
      <TestTribit8>0</TestTribit8>
      <TestCistring>jidajiojhwiuehrd328bhb</TestCistring>
      <TestMAC>0000-0000-0000</TestMAC>
    </TsdkTypeInner>
  </TsdkTypeInners>
</testsdk>

ouput： "data" results output from version 2.1.128：

<edit-config xmlns=\"urn:ietf:params:xml:ns:netconf:base:1.0\">
  <target>
    <running/>
  </target>
  <default-operation>none</default-operation>
  <error-option>stop-on-error</error-option>
  <config>
    <testsdk xmlns="urn:test:yang:test-vrp-testsdk">
      <TsdkTypeInners>
        <TsdkTypeInner>
          <TestIndex>10001</TestIndex>
          <TestName>1</TestName>
          <TestBinary>42594</TestBinary>
          <TestBool>false</TestBool>
          <TestInt16>20</TestInt16>
          <TestInt32>2147483647</TestInt32>
          <TestInt64>2000</TestInt64>
          <TestInt8>127</TestInt8>
          <TestString1>test</TestString1>
          <TestString2>writebackadd</TestString2>
          <TestUint16>3</TestUint16>
          <TestUint32>100</TestUint32>
          <TestUint64>4294967295</TestUint64>
          <TestUint8>255</TestUint8>
          <TestTimeticks>4294967295</TestTimeticks>
          <TestIpversion>ipv4</TestIpversion>
          <TestIpaddress>0.0.0.0</TestIpaddress>
          <TestIpnozone>::</TestIpnozone>
          <TestIpv4nozone>158.5.156.1</TestIpv4nozone>
          <TestIpv6nozone>1234:abcd:1234:abcd:1234:abcd:1234:abcd</TestIpv6nozone>
          <TestDate>1970-01-01</TestDate>
          <TestTime>11:11:11</TestTime>
          <TestDatetime>1971-01-01T10:10:10</TestDatetime>
          <TestTimehhmm>11:11</TestTimehhmm>
          <TestPassword>test#$</TestPassword>
          <TestPasswordex>test#$~@-^*%/.+:;=</TestPasswordex>
          <TestTribit1>0</TestTribit1>
          <TestTribit2>0</TestTribit2>
          <TestTribit4>0</TestTribit4>
          <TestTribit8>0</TestTribit8>
          <TestCistring>jidajiojhwiuehrd328bhb</TestCistring>
          <TestMAC>0000-0000-0000</TestMAC>
        </TsdkTypeInner>
      </TsdkTypeInners>
    </testsdk>
  </config>
</edit-config>

"data" results output from version 2.1.30：

<edit-config xmlns="urn:ietf:params:xml:ns:netconf:base:1.0">
  <target>
    <running/>
  </target>
  <default-operation>none</default-operation>
  <error-option>stop-on-error</error-option>
  <config><testsdk xmlns="urn:test:yang:test-vrp-testsdk">
  <TsdkTypeInners>
    <TsdkTypeInner operation="create">
      <TestIndex>10001</TestIndex>
      <TestBinary>42594</TestBinary>
      <TestBool>false</TestBool>
      <TestInt16>20</TestInt16>
      <TestInt32>2147483647</TestInt32>
      <TestInt64>2000</TestInt64>
      <TestInt8>127</TestInt8>
      <TestString1>test</TestString1>
      <TestString2>writebackadd</TestString2>
      <TestUint16>3</TestUint16>
      <TestUint32>100</TestUint32>
      <TestUint64>4294967295</TestUint64>
      <TestUint8>255</TestUint8>
      <TestName>1</TestName>
      <TestTimeticks>4294967295</TestTimeticks>
      <TestIpversion>ipv4</TestIpversion>
      <TestIpaddress>0.0.0.0</TestIpaddress>
      <TestIpnozone>::</TestIpnozone>
      <TestIpv4nozone>158.5.156.1</TestIpv4nozone>
      <TestIpv6nozone>1234:ABCD:1234:ABCD:1234:ABCD:1234:ABCD</TestIpv6nozone>
      <TestDate>1970-01-01</TestDate>
      <TestTime>11:11:11</TestTime>
      <TestDatetime>1971-01-01T10:10:10</TestDatetime>
      <TestTimehhmm>11:11</TestTimehhmm>
      <TestPassword>test#$</TestPassword>
      <TestPasswordex>test#$~@-^*%/.+:;=</TestPasswordex>
      <TestTribit1>0</TestTribit1>
      <TestTribit2>0</TestTribit2>
      <TestTribit4>0</TestTribit4>
      <TestTribit8>0</TestTribit8>
      <TestCistring>jidajiojhwiuehrd328bhb</TestCistring>
      <TestMAC>0000-0000-0000</TestMAC>
    </TsdkTypeInner>
  </TsdkTypeInners>
</testsdk>
</config>
</edit-config>

The main difference between the two is the output TsdkTypeInner field. 2.1.30 has the "create" operator, but 2.1.128 does not have the "create" operator.

michalvasko commented 5 months ago

Not sure what that create attribute is supposed to represent but it does even have a namespace, which makes it invalid in YANG. So I assume it is a bug and it is correctly fixed in newer versions.