search

COSIMA / access-om2

Deprecated ACCESS-OM2 global ocean - sea ice coupled model code and configurations.
22 stars 23 forks source link

JRA55 cyclones with incorrect sign #186

Open aekiss opened 4 years ago

aekiss commented 4 years ago

Some tropical cyclones occurring over the Northeast Pacific and the North Atlantic from 1959 to 1987 were erroneously represented as anti-cyclonic vortices in the Japanese 55-year Reanalysis (JRA-55) dataset. A detailed report is available at the JRA-55 website: https://jra.kishou.go.jp/JRA-55/index_en.html#quality https://jra.kishou.go.jp/JRA-55/document/quality_issues_20200122_en.pdf

Presumably all versions of JRA55-do up to and including (at least) v1.4.0 inherit this issue.

aekiss commented 4 years ago

This problem afflicted two snapshots of one cyclone in 1959 in the Northeast Pacific but lots of storms from 1967 - 1987 in the North Atlantic.

russfiedler commented 4 years ago

Didn't Al Gore get pilloried by the "skeptics" for having a hurricane spinning the wrong way on the cover of a book or promo for his film?

aekiss commented 4 years ago

Tsujino email to omip-cmip@llnl.gov, 3 Feb:

Since the JRA-55 team does not have a plan to re-run the reanalysis, there does not seem to be no other options for us but to replace the surface atmospheric fields around the erroneous tropical cyclones of JRA55-do with those from another reanalysis. There would be various opinions regarding what reanalysis to be chosen, but I would like to use 20CRv3, considering a possible backward extension of the entire dataset in the future. We will report on the impact of these errors on long-term ocean-climate simulations and local SSTs as soon as an OMIP simulation is conducted with a corrected dataset.

So I guess we just wait and see when they produce an update that patches over this issue...

aekiss commented 4 years ago

RYF8485 (1 May 1984 - 30 April 1985) has four faulty North Atlantic storms

            Time        Position
Year/Storm# YYYYMMDDHH  Lat     Lon  
1984/01L    1984061400  30.2    278.2
1984/02L    1984062006  22.7    261.5
1984/09L    1984090806  23.2    261.9
1984/17L    1984102800  30.8    271.0

but RYF9091 and RYF0304 are OK.

aekiss commented 4 years ago

The upcoming JRA55-do v1.5 will correct this issue by replacing the erroneous cyclones with data from 20CRv3 : https://climate.mri-jma.go.jp/~htsujino/docs/JRA55-do/v1_5-manual/jra55do_v1_5_doc.html

aekiss commented 3 years ago

JRA55-do v1.5.0 is now available, which covers 01Jan1958 - 15Jul2020 and fixes this cyclone sign error https://climate.mri-jma.go.jp/pub/ocean/JRA55-do/

access-hive-bot commented 1 year ago

This issue has been mentioned on ACCESS Hive Community Forum. There might be relevant details there:

https://forum.access-hive.org.au/t/ryf-for-different-years/444/6

access-hive-bot commented 12 hours ago

This issue has been mentioned on ACCESS Hive Community Forum. There might be relevant details there:

https://forum.access-hive.org.au/t/cosima-twg-meeting-minutes-2024/1734/21