CSSEGISandData / COVID-19

Novel Coronavirus (COVID-19) Cases, provided by JHU CSSE
https://systems.jhu.edu/research/public-health/ncov/
29.13k stars 18.43k forks source link

Please add back Hong Kong, Taiwan and Macau, dont merge them into China!!! #425

Closed ShawTim closed 4 years ago

ShawTim commented 4 years ago

Yesterday the data of Hong Kong, Taiwan and Macau are still there. We are here for data, not for political correctness.

norrsken-jagare commented 4 years ago

The data from Hong Kong, Macao and Taiwan are issued from separate organisations than the one in mainland China. The regions also have their own borders so it does not make sense to merge them into the data for mainland China. Please split the data so that they could be analysed independently. Thank you.

eacvo67347 commented 4 years ago

John Hopkins has lost all credibility here.

sam0737 commented 4 years ago

Grouping HK, TW, MO data's into CN's is like grouping Puerto Rico's into United State's, or Princess Diamond into UK or Japan. Taiwan is not even part of the WHO!

All these territories are taking different attitudes and measures towards COVID-19, they also have different administrative body, and different medical system.

Please keep the data the way it is, so they could be analysed properly.

jeromaxyu commented 4 years ago

Yes, putting things like credible-less WHO make your dashboard no difference, think again

yookoala commented 4 years ago

Separating different jurisdictions from each other helps visitor to better understand the actual status. It's stupid to merge them and confuse everybody just for the sake of a political gesture.

albertcsm commented 4 years ago

The definition of cases is significantly different among those regions, I don’t understand the merge, is it by accident, or politics?

JiPiBi commented 4 years ago

In my extractions , in time series , I dont see that Macau , Hong Kong or Taiwan are integrated in Mainland China , so where is the issue ?

Province/State Country/Region
Hong Kong Hong Kong SAR
Taiwan Taipei and environs
anthonywong commented 4 years ago

In my extractions , in time series , I dont see that Macau , Hong Kong or Taiwan are integrated in Mainland China , so where is the issue ?

The dataset looks fine but the accompanying website for data visualisation doesn't. Look at the tally under "Confirmed Cases by Country/Region". Hong Kong, for example, used to have its own entry there but it's no longer the case. We are eager to know why.

Combining data of Taiwan, Hong Kong and Macau just doesn't make any sense. The government and people in these regions take very different measures to tackle this pandemic, and the numbers of infections in these areas can clearly demonstrate that. Data should be segregated for the purpose of drawing meaning conclusion rather than pursuing politically correctness (if that's the real motive behind the change).

CSSEGISandData commented 4 years ago

please see issue #482