CSSEGISandData / COVID-19

Novel Coronavirus (COVID-19) Cases, provided by JHU CSSE
https://systems.jhu.edu/research/public-health/ncov/
29.16k stars 18.46k forks source link

Recovery data to be discountinued #4465

Open CSSEGISandData opened 2 years ago

CSSEGISandData commented 2 years ago

Further to #4369, we have made the decision to pull data for recoveries beginning August 4. After this date, the recovery data in the time series and recovery and active case data in the daily reports will be nullified.

feldenkraiz commented 2 years ago

Maybe the total number of recovered ones is not reliable, but then at least daily changes are needed, since this affects the number of active patients.

lordruzi commented 2 years ago

Hi, just out of interest, is the discontinuation of recovered data because of scientific reasons or simply a decision not to track it?

wormuths commented 2 years ago

This decision puts the entire dataset provided by JHU in question.

If data "accuracy" is the key reason for this decision, then you would stop reporting total cases. Scientifically, it is a fact that most asymptomatic cases go unreported, so the total case count would be unreliable as well. That data is still reported, however. The same holds true for deaths, since COVID was listed as the primary reason for people who died of other reasons, but tested positive for the virus.

The simple (scientific) breakdown is this. Cumulative cases and deaths always rise. Cumulative/Death=Scary. Current cases and recoveries allow people to calculate the actual (relatively low) death rates. Current/Recovered=Context.

Scary=Reported Context=Unreliable/Hidden

I'm done with JHU's data website and every product that sources its data.

tobiu commented 2 years ago

in case you create charts based on this data, they now look like this: Screenshot 2021-08-28 at 11 47 54

Especially with the 4th delta wave hitting many countries now, keeping track of the active cases is the most helpful indicator.

ronylpatil commented 2 years ago

Why recovered cases data is discontinued?

wormuths commented 2 years ago

Why recovered cases data is discontinued?

My guess is because all covid decisions are political now. Recovery data doesn’t show that we’re all going to die. LOL