search

CUL-DigitalServices / avocet-ui

Open Academic Environment (OAE) Front-End
http://www.oaeproject.org
Educational Community License v2.0
1 stars 1 forks source link

Journal lookup field error - wrong value being selected #312

Closed micheleidesmith closed 9 years ago

micheleidesmith commented 10 years ago

A user reported that the system replaced the journal title he selected with another journal title. For more details see the ZenDesk ticket: https://camacuk.zendesk.com/agent/#/tickets/3625. Text below from Philip's email:

It seems there might be an issue with the website changing people's journals to something different. See OA-1058, which has 'JOURNAL OF MULTIPLE-VALUED LOGIC AND SOFT COMPUTING' on the form but where the author sent an immediate follow-up message:

Somehow your system has replaced my journal by another one.

The correct journal is "Review of Symbolic Logic".

The same thing may have happened on OA-1052, here the form gave the journal as International Journal of Diabetes and Metabolism but the manuscript (confirmed by the author) was from the Journal of Cerebral Blood Flow and Metabolism.

Of course it's possible it was just human error and they clicked the wrong option, but 1058 in particular makes me think it might be worth looking into.

ucamhal commented 9 years ago

I've looked at the UI in the past and just now and I can't see any reason that a user's selection would be changed. Given that we can't reproduce the issue and that the auto completion is being reworked in #335 I think it makes sense to close this issue.