CWWhitney / hosyana_review

Review of decision supporting holistic modeling methods
MIT License
0 stars 0 forks source link

Review collection - Include or Exclude #7

Open PrajnaKARai opened 1 year ago

PrajnaKARai commented 1 year ago

● Check for inclusion criteria - everybody checks 2-3 letters of the alphabet in Zotero organized by first author's last name ● Tag (Zotero) the field of application; main keywords; model process (data sources, model structures etc.), ‘Include’ or ‘exclude’ ……. ● In Notes in the Zotero, quotes from the paper where they discuss how they support decisions should be recorded ● In case of ‘exclude,’ give reasons

CWWhitney commented 1 year ago

We can exclude and add a not with the reason beginning with the term 'Bin:' so that we can find it later and remove it. This also allows us to keep track of why and to have a transparent process.

Screenshot 2023-07-05 at 4 27 19 PM

We will transfer the papers to a collection of their own and write a paragraph about why we excluded papers. So far we have excluded papers which are reviews, speeches, or otherwise do not have a particular application or method.

CWWhitney commented 4 months ago

Started a 'bin' folder in Zotero and have been assessing the collection 1960-1989 (as well as others) for papers that can be excluded