CajunAvenger / cajunavenger.github.io

cajun's shenanigans
93 stars 25 forks source link

A few inconsistencies #2

Closed Rot8erConeX closed 1 year ago

Rot8erConeX commented 1 year ago
AsparagusEduardo commented 1 year ago

I'd also suggest an option for favorite Tera Jewel, but I don't know if those have sprites yet.

Tera Jewels aren't really Pokémon, so it wouldn't make much sense to add this. It'd be like adding "Favorite Z-Crystal".

Likewise, your option for favorite fossil does not include Relicanth, a mon that is both in-universe and IRL old enough to be a fossil. Maybe change this to "favorite revived fossil" to better clarify.

I don't feel there's a need to clarify the fossil option, as it's generally agreed that the term "Fossil Pokémon" refers to Pokémon revived from fossils, which excludes Relicanth.

Rot8erConeX commented 1 year ago

Tera Jewels aren't really Pokémon, so it wouldn't make much sense to add this. It'd be like adding "Favorite Z-Crystal".

Tera Jewels aren't really Pokémon, and neither are Poké Balls, something this tracker already allows you to pick your favorite of. Some of the hats are cool, some suck. Let people pick their favorites.

The difference between the Tera Jewel and Z-Crystal is that the crystals all are the same shape, only the color differs. It'd be interesting to let people pick their favorite Z Move, but I feel it'd be hard to do without providing animations for each of them and that is probably beyond the scope of the project.

CajunAvenger commented 1 year ago

will be a day or two before i can throw code at this but responding

You have each form of Silvally listed in the appropriate type for Gen 7, but do not do the same for Arceus in Gen 4.

Silvally is the oversight there

You have each individual variant for the Floette line and Furfrou shown (as well as all the cores for Minior), but do not do the same for Alcremie or Vivillon. In Alcremie's case I understand - there's 63 forms and it would bloat the menu! Might I suggest a two-stage process for these mons? You pick the default form and then a sub-menu shows up to pick the form you want displayed? It could also apply for Unown.

Vivillon and Unown are fine to add (maybe get their own box like Eeveelution tho), Alcremie is so disruptive for such a nothing change

You have a box for favorite Gigantimax form, but not a box for favorite Mega Evolution. I'd also suggest an option for favorite Tera Jewel, but I don't know if those have sprites yet.

yea Mega wasn't in the original template i'll add this once i have a little more time for moving things around for it. pass on tera and z crystals

Less of a thing than the others, but I feel it's worth mentioning: you mention "pikachu clones" rather than "electric rodents", which makes sense since you include Mimikyu among this number (and it is reasonable since it's a literal attempt at a Pikachu clone). However, this also opens the door for "Pikablu" now known as Marill. You might want to better clarify the meaning here.

Marill's not anywhere near a pikaclone as Mimikyu

Also, within Gen 8, you have Galarian Linoone displayed right before Obstagoon when I assume it's supposed to be right after Galarian Zigzagoon. Galarian Meowth and Paldean Wooper do similar things. I assume this is because whatever you're doing to order them is based on the evolution data?

yea but i can fix that manually now