The impacts of the new productivity OMs on extirpation risk are minor (even with heavy tailed distribution the median is ~5% extirpated though the uncertainty is obviously large). Would we like to stick with this as the third conservation-based PM or show something more sensitive and that varies more across operating models. For example, the mean proportion of MUs, across years and trials, that meet their escapement goals (approximated here by MU-specific return abundance exceeding the lower FRP + management adjustment in a given year). Shown in panels (g-i) below.
The impacts of the new productivity OMs on extirpation risk are minor (even with heavy tailed distribution the median is ~5% extirpated though the uncertainty is obviously large). Would we like to stick with this as the third conservation-based PM or show something more sensitive and that varies more across operating models. For example, the mean proportion of MUs, across years and trials, that meet their escapement goals (approximated here by MU-specific return abundance exceeding the lower FRP + management adjustment in a given year). Shown in panels (g-i) below.